Thanks for making my point for me. And you're a prime example of why devolution isn't enough. While we're in a union, with a more powerful country, we're at the risk of people like you getting what they want, and giving England ALL the power, instead of just most of it. But thanks for stepping up, to be the proof of my earlier point.
As for devolution being a failure. Oh please, have you seen the state of the rUK? England's public services are failing, education, tuition fees, crime, homelessness, poverty, public transportation, water treatment, cost of living etc. There's nothing you can throw at the Scottish government, that the English government haven't failed with. And unlike them, Scotland's budget is out of our control, as are many reserved powers.
So on that basis, the UK doesn't deserve to manage its own affairs, and a much bigger more capable foreign power should take over and control it, the way you would like for Scotland.
Anyway, i'm done talking with you. I have no time for people who hate Scotland and would sell all the autonomy we have to another country.
"Does anyone believe Holyrood has improved lives for people"
Yes, massively so.