Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would I be unreasonable to ask my elderly mum for an apology?

146 replies

NotAMumTutor · 10/08/2026 17:39

It's about me and my elderly mum - she's 90 this year - and how honest I should be with her. Sometimes I just like being a bit off-the-wall/goofy and my brother's 70th was one of those occasions. I did a silly slightly squatting pose in the group photos, which could have suggested going to the loo, but my intention was to mimic letting others behind me be seen (as a joke, as I'm 5 foot nothing). Anyway, the whole event wasn't that fun, just pleasant, and I was feeling a bit bored (having gotten a bit stressed on the way due to time constraints).
So I did the pose, with mum also in the group photo; she's very young for her age - fully able both physically and mentally, and everyone's shocked at her numerical age based on these facts. However, on and off, she reacts to me with signs of contempt (by no means always, as we can spend a pleasant day together - say once every 3 months! - without much conflict... although I do like to speak my mind in response to some of her views... )
Anyway, during the group photoshot (which wasn't in any way 'formal' but just a friendly group activity, probably suggested by a sibling who was also feeling bored!) mum very aggressively (not at all in a jokey or nice way) told me off for striking the silly pose, to which I felt obliged NOT to obey her - I'm nearly 64 for goodness sake!! I just responded by saying I like doing that, and kept my response light-hearted, though feeling that her behaviour towards me was shocking - talking to me as if I was about 4 in front of other people. Nothing was said, but, in my own mind, I think it reflected VERY badly on her character, and not mine at all.
Am I being unreasonable, given that the family will be celebrating her 90th later this year, if I ask her to have a chat with me about this, and hopefully be able to get her to apologise? Or is it reasonable, to expect some sort of apology before I'm obliged to keep it all sweetness for the celebration? The meetup to chat would be just me and her, to avoid embarrasing her in front of anyone (and anyway, they might feel obliged to take her side for an easy life).
Honestly, I think she fits the classic narcissist pattern, as she needs people to fit in with her restricted ideas of behaviour to be 'rewarded' with a pleasant attitude from her in response, and unless this can be resolved, I may end up boycotting the event - but I don't want to take it that far, as I doubt I'd get any support for that stance, and would risk falling out with my whole family for something that wasn't my fault.
I don't feel like I should let her 'get away with' this sort of behaviour and belittle me in such an extreme way! It certainly wasn't a pleasant experience, even though I knew 100% it wasn't me in the wrong - if I want to be silly, that's 100% my decision as a free individual!
Sorry this is sooo long.

OP posts:
IronEverything · 10/08/2026 18:05

You weren't being "goofy". You were being stupid and attention seeking and ruining a group photo.

Why the hell should she apologise?

You should stay away from her party so everyone can enjoy it without being annoyed.

Livpool · 10/08/2026 18:05

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 10/08/2026 18:00

It sounds like you were bored as the focus wasn't on you, and so you acted out.
Your mum was probably annoyed you couldn't keep it together for a photo celebrating someone else.
Let it go.
If you want to go the the 90th, go, if not, don't, but it should be on what you want to do, not on what your family will approve of.

Agree with this. We have someone in our family who does stuff like this and is very much a “I’m mad me’ person. We call him Uncle Knobhead 🤷🏼‍♀️

Leavesandthings · 10/08/2026 18:05

God why is everyone being so horrible to the OP?

I'm sorry you feel like your mum often has a contemptuous attitude towards you, that's not nice whatever anyone's age.

TheignT · 10/08/2026 18:06

SauviGone · 10/08/2026 18:00

Given the age of some of these relatives, you’ve possibly ruined one of the final group photos of these people all together, by dicking about and squatting down to look like you’re taking a shit.

No wonder your mum was irritated.

Yes it would be sad if it's someone's last photo with the family.

You got it wrong OP maybe your mum went a bit far with the telling off but she probably felt embarrassed at you being silly.

As Elsa would say let it go.

blacksax · 10/08/2026 18:06

You would be wasting your time asking her for an apology. As far as she was concerned (and I'm inclined to agree), you did something stupid and it was you who were in the wrong. She told you off.

Move on. Go to the family event. And act your age, not your shoe size.

And yes, I'm a similar age to you.

NoCommentingFromNowOn · 10/08/2026 18:08

Let it go, she’s 90, she’ll never apologise.

This bit…

However, on and off, she reacts to me with signs of contempt

I wouldn’t allow that, in the sense she can speak to you how she likes and you can vote with your feet. Just stay places until she speaks to you inappropriately then leave. But no 90 year old will ever change, so it on you to take yourself out of the situation.

TheignT · 10/08/2026 18:08

Think carefully about going, with relatives in their 90s there might not be many more celebrations. You could really regret it in the future.

BitOutOfPractice · 10/08/2026 18:09

If you are “100% sure” that you did nothing wrong, why start an AIBU? You sound quite tiresome to me. And your poor brother!

mtobrokeme · 10/08/2026 18:09

Whilst I don’t find your jokey behaviour ‘puerile’, ‘childish’ or ‘annoying’ in the way some of the fun police have described you I do think you’ve made a mountain out of a molehill and should immediately forget about it! I don’t think there is a need for an apology or a chat at all!

Likeiloveyou · 10/08/2026 18:09

You behaved like a toddler so your mother responded accordingly.

lazysusannah · 10/08/2026 18:10

You're lacking in self awareness.

Calling your mum a narc when you've behaved in a childish selfish manner, and upset her? Maybe it's not her who is the narc.

I'm actually almost speechless that you think your behaviour was fun, or whatever.

The party was not about you and your silly jokes.
It was about your Mum and making it a lovely day for her.

Messing around in photos is what kids sometimes do.

No wonder your mum was upset.

I'm older than you and my Mum is much older than yours.

I went to her 90th and if I'd done what you had, I'd be embarrassed and feel an idiot.

Grow up.

Arregaithel · 10/08/2026 18:12

I'm nearly 64 for goodness sake!! check yourself? @NotAMumTutor

Pedant61 · 10/08/2026 18:13

OP, read these posts. Your behaviour was embarrassing and juvenile - if anyone should be apologising, it's you!

CheltenhamLady · 10/08/2026 18:13

I am with your mum, it was really childish and irritating behaviour. I doubt anyone else present found it amusing. you really are not quirky or goofy, you are quite thoughtless. I imagine others were mystified that you felt it appropriate.

Morepositivemum · 10/08/2026 18:13

Op she’ll always be your mother, and I’m sorry but you deserved a telling off!!

Deadringer · 10/08/2026 18:14

You were bored and goofy, grow up fgs! My mum lived to be 98 and right up to the end would admonish us 'kids' if necessary. God i miss her.

Leavesandthings · 10/08/2026 18:14

She was squatting to fit into a group photo, she didn't moony the camera or shit on the floor for god's sake.

DorsetMermaid · 10/08/2026 18:23

"is it reasonable, to expect some sort of apology before I'm obliged to keep it all sweetness for the celebration?"

There is a reasonable middle ground which would be to just say to her 'you upset me mum when you told me off in front of other people' and then just have a quiet sensible chat about it. No need for apology. No need for anger. No need for fake sweetness'

OP - you wondered about narcissism. It might be worth you reading up on it and having a think.

"When a narcissist is criticised, they experience a deep and painful threat to their ego called a narcissistic injury. Rather than feeling normal embarrassment, they feel intense shame, severe humiliation, and an overwhelming sense of profound weakness. Because their grandiosity masks a very fragile self-image, they perceive any negative feedback not as a comment on their actions, but as an existential attack on their entire worth."

harriethoyle · 10/08/2026 18:25

Am robustly team mum on this one. She probably wanted a nice group photo from one of the few big birthdays she will attend in light of her own age and you were titting around, acting the fool and trying to draw attention up to yourself. I’d have told you to belt up too.

AmusedMember · 10/08/2026 18:26

64?! Maybe time to grow up?

Armorlux · 10/08/2026 18:27

I remember my mum telling off my then 6 year old DS for messing about during the photos at my brother's wedding. He deserved it and he was only 6.

He doesn't behave like that now and nor should any adult. It's very tiresome.

Topseyt123 · 10/08/2026 18:39

You are 64 but you behaved like a 6 year old. 🙄 Squatting down in a family group photo to mimic doing a poo and a wee??? Really!! Have you never left the school playground?

I would have found your behaviour very irritating and I am only 60.

You think your mother is a narcissist, but give no examples of that. She probably thinks you are childish and a bit of an arse.

I wouldn't bother discussing it. It's you who owes her and others an apology by the sound of it. Just accept that you were a dickhead, grow up and don't do it again!

Rhaidimiddim · 10/08/2026 18:44

rubyslippers · 10/08/2026 17:42

i’d have been irritated by your behaviour in the pics and I’m not 90
you say you’re goofy - but there’s a time and place and maybe photos for what sounds like a relatively formal 70th (you said it wasn’t that fun) was neither the time or place

Edited

I agree. If it was a formal event and the person honoured/ hosting wanted some photos to record it - you doing a silly pose in mutiple photos was you not reading the room.

blackrabbitwhiterabbit · 10/08/2026 18:48

Oh dear, this sounds like me and my mother. She thinks I'm immature and 'silly'. I doubt you'll get an apology, though.

Cherrysoup · 10/08/2026 18:49

Did you spoil the only group shot? If so, that would be a real shame. I think she’s allowed to tell you off, I think I might have told you off too. As a pp said, puerile, not actually funny.