Hi @TwinklyTornadoBear Happy Christmas Eve Eve to you as well!
I could have written some of your post! The astounding lack of memory for detail combined with a need to never be wrong = brain infills the detail (incorrectly), DP convinced his version must be correct and cannot accept a different version, or even accept there is a small
possibility it might be HIM that has misremembered. I wouldn’t mind too much but it’s his absolute insistence that I’m wrong. It’s always me that’s wrong. And it often causes confusion. He’ll say he’s booked something. Then the next day will say he hasn’t booked it. And when I say “but you told me yesterday you had booked it!” Hell flatly deny saying that. When I say I am certain he definitely said he’d booked the appointment, he just gets annoyed with me and says I have misremembered again! (But I know I haven’t!! It’s utterly maddening).
Like your DH he has a catchphrase which is “we will have to agree to disagree!” And exactly the same as you, this is just to shut me down whilst maintaining he is right. He says this, and once he’s said his shut down phrase, I must not make a single utterance about our lack of agreement, or shake my head or sigh or make any indication that I am frustrated. If I do he will simply shout “AGREE TO DISAGREE” at me again and again and again, louder and louder.
I’ve started doing this back to him!! We don’t agree. He’s misremembered again but is insisting his made up version is correct snd everyone else is wrong. I will say ok well let’s just agree to disagree then. (Ha!). And he can’t do it!!! He can’t allow himself to be shut down the way he does to me. So I say his stupid catchphrase at him and he’ll say “fine. All I’m saying is….” And repeats his viewpoint because he must have the last word. I’ll interject and say “but I thought we were agreeing to disagree, no?” and again he will say that’s fine but will then need to repeat his version a few more times. Laughable that when he issues the dreaded phrase we must all be silent immediately. But when it is issued to him, he can’t handle it and needs to have the last word. (He also tells me that I always have to have the last word!!!! And I’m like “I am literally walking out of the room in silence while you shout your last word at me. I am walking up the stairs and you’re still shouting at me! How is this me having the last word??”)
I realise this all sounds very toxic and petty! Mostly I just smile to myself and disengage immediately when he tells me I’ve misremembered. I’m like “hmm ok”. The kids also know not to bother disagreeing with him. They know he will just insist he is right and end up shouting at them.
I think the poor memory for detail, filling in of blanks, insistence on being right and getting quite angry about it seem to be common. My DB finds the exact same with just autistic DW. He manages it by just saying “ok”. This isn’t good enough though. She needs him to agree with her. And she will keep on and on at him to admit he’s wrong. Eventually he will just get up and walk away and say he doesn’t want to argue. She usually gets upset at that point and says he’s being horrible to her….
I try not to take it too seriously. It’s annoying but not worth getting too upset about. I would love it if DP could acknowledge that he doesn’t have a great memory for detail and sometimes gets a bit muddled with what he might have told me. But I may be waiting a long time! So I tend to make a joke of it as humour seems to be my go to coping mechanism.