Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Long-standing argument with my partner.

129 replies

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 18:57

Hello everyone.

I am new here and was wondering if anybody can offer me any advice.

My relationship has hit a bump in the road at the moment due to an issue which has not been resolved for a while. It all revolves around Easter Sunday.

My partner has a small family, his Mum and his Grandma. His lovely Grandma turns 100 on Easter Sunday! Unfortunately, this also clashes with Easter Sunday plans we had already made with my family for us (he/we didn't realise the clash in dates!)

Easter Sunday has always been a big occasion in my family, not to mention it is also my birthday weekend too.

I shared with him that I would like to try and do both things if we can. He initially categorically said no to doing both and is saying that he can't understand why I would prioritise Easter (which he said consists of basically a roast) over his Grandma's 100th Birthday. He said that if it were him in my shoes, he would drop his plans for me.

I said to him that I understand what he is saying, but feel that I have missed two Christmases with my family as we choose to stay as a couple but he didn't feel like he could leave his Grandma and Mum at Christmas. His response was that if I wanted to see my family at Christmas, it would be without him as he needed to see his Mum and Grandma. I explained that there have been occasions where him and his family have been priority.

We saw his Grandma and Mum yesterday and they started talking about her birthday. His Grandma would like to go to the sea-side. I explained that unfortunately I wouldnt be able to go to the seaside but will drop by afterwards when they return for tea and birthday cake at her carehome. I have tried to compromise and do both things.

His Grandma and Mum's face dropped and they both looked really sad. When we left after we saw them, I said to my partner that I felt awful for letting them down. He said that he thought their reactions were very mild, and that if he was in their position he would have responded far worse. This obviously added to the guilt and I didnt feel that this was a fair comment from him.

Things have been icy between me and him since, and I keep offering for them to message me when they are back at the carehome and I can leave my parents for a while and pop by to celebrate with them. I reassured my partner that I care about his feelings and can see how much this means to him.

He is refusing my offer and throwing it back at me with "I dont understand - you said you wanted to spend the time with your family, so now youre going to just leave them at some point through the day?" My parents are very flexible, and the nursing home is close by so it wouldnt be an issue. I feel like he knows this but now he is being awkward and stubborn.

I guess I am stuck in a rut of feeling guilty. I desperately want to do a little bit of both things, but he seems resistant to what I am offering and it is becoming emotionally draining.

I guess I just feel that with big occasions there seems to be no compromise on his part sometimes. He does come to my family events and is always happy to, just never on special occasions.

Am I being selfish and unreasonable? After going through this in my head 10000 times, it is nice to vent and get some opinions. Thank you.

OP posts:
SoRainbowRhythms · 11/03/2024 18:58

I would go to the birthday. 100 is a big deal. There's lots of other easters.

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 19:00

@SoRainbowRhythms thank you. It is nice to hear other people's views on this outside of the relationship.

OP posts:
Fortitudinal · 11/03/2024 19:01

He sounds rigid and controlling around this stuff, but on this one occasion I think a 100th birthday takes precedence.

All the other issues around Christmas etc still needs a fair solution, which you obviously haven’t got yet.

Collywobblewobbles · 11/03/2024 19:02

Fortitudinal · 11/03/2024 19:01

He sounds rigid and controlling around this stuff, but on this one occasion I think a 100th birthday takes precedence.

All the other issues around Christmas etc still needs a fair solution, which you obviously haven’t got yet.

I agree with this

citrinetrilogy · 11/03/2024 19:02

His grandma is only going to have a 100th birthday once. It is a huge deal.

dammit88 · 11/03/2024 19:02

A 100th birthday is very very special. I think you are wrong here sorry.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 11/03/2024 19:03

I agree that a 100th birthday takes precedence over a roast dinner for Easter.

Sarvanga38 · 11/03/2024 19:03

SoRainbowRhythms · 11/03/2024 18:58

I would go to the birthday. 100 is a big deal. There's lots of other easters.

Me too. There aren’t many opportunities to celebrate a 100th birthday.

napody · 11/03/2024 19:03

Fortitudinal · 11/03/2024 19:01

He sounds rigid and controlling around this stuff, but on this one occasion I think a 100th birthday takes precedence.

All the other issues around Christmas etc still needs a fair solution, which you obviously haven’t got yet.

Another in agreement with this.
What the 100-year-old birthday girl wants, she gets as far as I'm concerned. How wonderful she's getting to the seaside.

Blueblueblueblueblu · 11/03/2024 19:04

The 100th is a huge deal. Is he annoyed you're trying to compromise or does he see it as her not being able to do her seaside plan because you're not able to?

TeeBee · 11/03/2024 19:05

Any chance that your family could do their celebration the day before or after? Or is that not an option?

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 19:06

@Blueblueblueblueblu I feel that he is annoyed that I am trying to compromise. My family occasions go well into the evening/night, so I am hoping that we can have most of the day with her and then go back to my parents afterwards.

OP posts:
Blueblueblueblueblu · 11/03/2024 19:06

Will he still go to the seaside with her and she gets the day she wants?

SirChenjins · 11/03/2024 19:07

I’m with him I’m afraid - a 100th birthday is a massive deal. Could you have a joint Easter Sunday meal and birthday meal on the Saturday instead?

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 19:07

@TeeBee It could be an option. But I think my Mum would potentially feel offended if I asked her to move the day, as other family members are coming too.

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 11/03/2024 19:07

I have to say I agree with him, a 100th birthday would take precedence over anything for me. And (personally) I wouldn’t like my family to feel like they’ve been squeezed in as an afterthought on such a special occasion as a 100th birthday, so if it was me and DH, I’d be telling DH not to bother if he couldn’t do it all.

SirChenjins · 11/03/2024 19:08

Cross posts - just saw your mum won’t want to move the Easter meal.

There will be other Easters, you only get one 100th. Are you having a birthday meal with your family another day?

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 19:09

@Blueblueblueblueblu yes - they will still go to the seaside and I've said to them not to change any plans for me.

I guess I had made my decision beforehand and when I told her I realised how much it meant to her that I would be there. Maybe I've been selfish.

OP posts:
chrisfromcardiff · 11/03/2024 19:09

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 18:57

Hello everyone.

I am new here and was wondering if anybody can offer me any advice.

My relationship has hit a bump in the road at the moment due to an issue which has not been resolved for a while. It all revolves around Easter Sunday.

My partner has a small family, his Mum and his Grandma. His lovely Grandma turns 100 on Easter Sunday! Unfortunately, this also clashes with Easter Sunday plans we had already made with my family for us (he/we didn't realise the clash in dates!)

Easter Sunday has always been a big occasion in my family, not to mention it is also my birthday weekend too.

I shared with him that I would like to try and do both things if we can. He initially categorically said no to doing both and is saying that he can't understand why I would prioritise Easter (which he said consists of basically a roast) over his Grandma's 100th Birthday. He said that if it were him in my shoes, he would drop his plans for me.

I said to him that I understand what he is saying, but feel that I have missed two Christmases with my family as we choose to stay as a couple but he didn't feel like he could leave his Grandma and Mum at Christmas. His response was that if I wanted to see my family at Christmas, it would be without him as he needed to see his Mum and Grandma. I explained that there have been occasions where him and his family have been priority.

We saw his Grandma and Mum yesterday and they started talking about her birthday. His Grandma would like to go to the sea-side. I explained that unfortunately I wouldnt be able to go to the seaside but will drop by afterwards when they return for tea and birthday cake at her carehome. I have tried to compromise and do both things.

His Grandma and Mum's face dropped and they both looked really sad. When we left after we saw them, I said to my partner that I felt awful for letting them down. He said that he thought their reactions were very mild, and that if he was in their position he would have responded far worse. This obviously added to the guilt and I didnt feel that this was a fair comment from him.

Things have been icy between me and him since, and I keep offering for them to message me when they are back at the carehome and I can leave my parents for a while and pop by to celebrate with them. I reassured my partner that I care about his feelings and can see how much this means to him.

He is refusing my offer and throwing it back at me with "I dont understand - you said you wanted to spend the time with your family, so now youre going to just leave them at some point through the day?" My parents are very flexible, and the nursing home is close by so it wouldnt be an issue. I feel like he knows this but now he is being awkward and stubborn.

I guess I am stuck in a rut of feeling guilty. I desperately want to do a little bit of both things, but he seems resistant to what I am offering and it is becoming emotionally draining.

I guess I just feel that with big occasions there seems to be no compromise on his part sometimes. He does come to my family events and is always happy to, just never on special occasions.

Am I being selfish and unreasonable? After going through this in my head 10000 times, it is nice to vent and get some opinions. Thank you.

I would go to the 100 birthday party and then I would rethink if I really want to be with the rigid partner. He doesn't sound very pleasant.

sandyhappypeople · 11/03/2024 19:09

if your family Easter celebrations go well into the night, why can't you go to the seaside in the day then join your family in the evening?

TeeBee · 11/03/2024 19:10

Is there an option of both families doing the seaside trip and the meal? Could make both more fun perhaps?

MegMarchHare · 11/03/2024 19:10

This sounds absolutely nuts. How long have you been with this guy? Are you married - doesn't sound like it? Why does he insist on you coming as a pair to all family occasions? You are having all the tense negotiations of an unhappily married couple... For what? Enjoy your freedom while you have it!

This isn't about a 100th birthday Vs Easter Sunday. It's about the fact that the two of you can't make plans, negotiate or compromise without it being a big all-or-nothing drama. You do not need to feel guilty at all (especially as you are happy to do a bit of both events). He is being unreasonable and unpleasant and overbearing, and I don't see what the point of this relationship is, because it sounds like a massive ball ache to me.

Alexanadra · 11/03/2024 19:10

So my narcissistic boyfriend has used an old photo from 15 years ago for his new passport....because he is too stingy to pay for a new one and said he's not 'photogenic'...and it's been accepted! Am tempted to dob him in...what do I do? I recently paid a fortune to renew mine.

Sarvanga38 · 11/03/2024 19:10

QuirkyOtter · 11/03/2024 19:07

@TeeBee It could be an option. But I think my Mum would potentially feel offended if I asked her to move the day, as other family members are coming too.

Even on hearing that it’s because of a 100th birthday celebration? Blimey.

britneyisfree · 11/03/2024 19:11

You're putting your foot down at the wrong time! Very few people get a 100th birthday. You should've prioritised your family at other times tbh.

He still sounds like a dick though.