Op I am sorry you are in this situation. At the minute Mr Selfish still thinks he is the prize and wants you to wait while he chooses.
You need to push him off the fence.
If you want him to consider you need risk losing him and the marriage. Personally I would say ‘husband I love you and want our marriage to work. However there is one thing worse than not being married to you and that is sharing you. I am not prepared to tolerate that. I am not being party to this situation. You need to also understand that the more time that elapses the less likely I am to consider us reconciling’. Then leave the room and do not engage further. If possible leave the building.
The pick me dance will not work. Choose yourself. You are the prize. You defending him and wanted to help him. He didn’t meet this lady post split up. He’s a lying shitbag who is STILL controlling your truth. He thinks he gets to call what your truth is so HE gets to make his choices. Bugger that. Push him off the fence.
Unless he works on his whys and realises he is a shitbag that made thousands of poor choices he isn’t safe as a partner.
You need to make a list of why YOU are the prize (and believe me you are).
- You defended him even when he left. You saw the best in him and wanted to help him.
- your words (vows) meant something. You have integrity and loyalty.
He has a but in his fidelity. I’m faithful ‘but’ not if I won’t get caught.
Any mention of ‘unmet needs’ laugh and walk away. It’s nonsense. You can’t increase someone’s, honesty, loyalty and commitment vía nights out, cooking them steak or oral sex. It’s bollocks.
He chose to cheat. He has poor character traits, dishonesty, poor self esteem, thinking he deserves to control your truth, thinking he deserves 100% where you only deserve 60%, lack of integrity, pretending he believes in the vows he made, needing external validation, needs ego kibbles and smoke blowing up his behind, selfish, risking stds, poor self control, unable to self soothe, poor communication, running away when the going gets tough. Until he fixes whatever poor traits he has (and believe me he will have some of the above and others) he is a shit partner. And sadly those poor character traits are why most cheaters are incapable of reconciling.
Unless he fixes his whys and he gets to his root cause (with the blame squarely at his feet) he is liable to cheat again. Look after yourself op. Treat yourself like you would treat a best friend. Be aware infidelity causes Ptsd.