WARNING ⚠️ THIS IS AN ESSAY ABOUT HOW LONG IT TAKES TO GO LOOPY!
some of this is also paraphrased vs actual words people said.
I always plan in my head these sit down adult conversations then it all goes to shit and we end up with these ad hoc discussions. Today though, fucking hell I really took the biscuit though. Had a imaginary glass of wine to myself while I wrote this ( i think i would down a whole bottle at the moment if wine was open). Suggest you all do the same.
Came back from picking DD1 up and he was at the door waiting.
Felt a bit like deja vu, me in the gym gear having a conversation at the kitchen while the kids are about.
So while making lunch we start this.
If we take into account emotional affair etc then yes he accepts he has as far as I am concerned, been having an emotional affair with her. This apparently is no reflection on me or our relationship or how he feels about me. He supposes to a lot of people it might seem he was wantjng extra attention but for him it was more he could be 'unfiltered, vent about stuff without the blow back of it impacting how I thought of him' and that guys are pretty crap at being sounding boards and he was so aware it would likely get carried back via wives to me.
I asked what they would talk about and actually it is stuff I would have judged him on, told him not to over think or we had argued about but which I tended to be forceful about. If I am being objective I can see why he may seek outside counsel but at the moment the fact it was from her is too much. I was also aware he spoke to her about stuff and he would relay back some of what she spoke to him about but that he used her for some much emotional guidance is tough, even though I know I would not have been able to listen.
Stuff like worried if he would be a good dad or get annoyed, being annoyed about not wanting to go to the gym or feeling motivated, disliking projects at work, going for promotion at the expense of him having flexi time, wondering if this is it, Feeling guilt about leaving his sisters to care for his mum and dad as they get older. As a lot of you have said a fair amount if navel gazing from a man in his mid 30s.
He is still adament there was no physical aspect after we got married and no penetrative sex. He was continually apologetic about that. 100% accepts there is no jusitification for that behaviour. That was just attraction. He agrees prior to our wedding he had an affair. The specifics were they were mutually attracted. Were chatting a lot and flirting but nothing much happened and then one night they got drink at a night out and kissed. This happened on a few other occassions as well Inc at work and then there was that night when he did that. That was it.
He said now their friendship means too much to ruin it by doing anything else and also he is married to me and whether i believe it or not he is faithful to me. Again poonted out the emotional aspect.
He accepts that he shouldn't be going to talk to someone else about issues we were having or I should be the first port of call when he feels that way but he points out I wouldn't be annoyed if it had been a guy I went to which he is also right about but as I stated I would be miffed if he had a female friend he discussed it with but she was not just a female friend to begin with and that is the crux of the matter. It also seems that they were not super duper close friends first time round so why did he not just leave it be and bring her back in to his life. He just said he didn't know. They worked on the project and he enjoyed her company, not in a wanting to have sex with her way but just hanging out. They had similar interest was easy to talk to. He thought I would get on with her and that is why he had everyone socialise. He admits he compartmentalised the bit before when they were intimate.
I said the lying for 8 years and then bringing her back in was the big problem.
He peddled the same bullshut about protecting me with lies but then admitted that he protected himself and his rep pre wedding and then as time went on, he just believed his own lies which meant he actually felt okay having her back in our lives. I asked if he ever got scared about being caught and he said no because he had in his own head rationalised that pre weddjng was a mistake and this was a new leaf where we were all friends. He knows that is fucked up. Again said she really did think I knew and that she is furious and at how he treated me. Said they have had minimal contact.
At this point he got teary eyed ( not sure if he is upset about the lying to me and losing me or the minimal contact with OW) and said he fucked up and he doesn't know how to fix it. I told him she needs to go if we are to work and he nodded and says he knows that.
Being a glutton for punishment I then asked how he felt about cutting her out and he said it would be gutting and feeling like someone had died but he would do what he has to do to make things better with us.
At that point I then started crying and just kept saying you love her though, she will never be out our life. He just stood there behind me holding me while I sobbed but he didn't say no he didn't love her just that she isn't me, I shouldn't be thinking he doesn't love me.
Not my finest moment then going on about how much I hate her and why her. He just said nothing.
When I finally calmed down.I asked what it was about her that he would lose everything for her. He said he wasn't wanting to sacrifice everything for her and that he would end his friendship with her to make sure I didn't feel the way I have been or to feel insecure or worried but that he cannot control how he has felt and that if he could he would not be feeling what he had because it is 'mental' and confusing. He kept saying what he thinks or feels for her though is no reflection on me, his love for me, his desire to stay married to me.or make it work. All that is his first priority but in the background he is also dealing with these feelings.
He just said what he has said all along, he has no idea what he is feeling. Had I asked him 6 weeks ago if he loved her, he would have swore blind she was a friend he cared for deeply but that was it but the more he has been forced to figure out what he feels the more confused he is. He thinks therapy might help process the feelings. He actually admitted without prompting it was wrong at the beginning to have been so honest with me about saying he loved her, that he must have hurt me laying bare his feelings about her. He doesn't love her the way he loves me, it isn't even a sexual attraction or that he wants to be with her, he can't describe it , he just wants her in his life and to be happy and if he can help with that happiness he will where he can. He understands that for us to be together she will have to go but it leaves him so sad.
Apparently she was the 'missing piece' in his life. I actually fucking laughed at that point and told him he should hear himself. That he just apologised for being too honest then comes out with that. He just sat there like a wee boy not knowing what to do. I told him it was clear as day he loved her and that might not be sexual but he cannot be in love with two women and stay married to me, that most men would have grasped that concept. Two married people cannot be in a mutual appreciation society with other people's partners.
Apparently my reaction was exactly why having someone else to talk to was so important.
Seems I am very nurturing and supportive in a practical way but on the odd infrequent occassions when he has been confused or frustrated, I have always suggested going to the gym, building a bridge to get over it, I have let him scratch the surface but then the practicalities of life have got in the way and he felt investigating those feelings with me would make me think less of him and he just didn't know how to. I have to say this isn't him gaslighting me, i tend to be quite practiical when people get too overly sensitive or bogged down in emotions. If we move forward that will be something we need to both work on. I wonder if subconsciously I encouraged him to not over think, as I never wanted him to question our relationship. The irony is that we are both closet over thinkers but we're so worried about what the other thinks we have not been honest with each other, driving me to insecurity and him to her. If I really dig deep, I am so determined to not be an emotional wreck like my mum that I probably suppress a lot and encourage others too because I don't k OW how to deal with overly emotional people.
Meanwhile OW talks to him about these things. It doesn't matter what she thinks of him appatently because she isn't his partner, she says it how she sees it but mostly just listens. Also said she has never once spoken against me and often told H to discuss it with me. He was encouraged by her openess in talking about how she felt. She spoke to my H because her H wanted to fix things or offer advice but really she just wanted someone to listen and as time went on he saw the benefits of having her just listen too. That initially it was her that was more open than him talking about her dad and brother's death, cancer and the more open she was the more open he became with her. She isn't judgemental or needing to give solutions. Maybe I should take a fucking plaster cast of her ear as a final goodbye present from her to him.
I suggested he get a counsellor and he said yes but that he found talking to her easy, that now he can accept counselling would help but it has been so gradual their chats that initally he would not have thought he needed it.
I pointed out to him AGAIN this was an emotional affair but he said it wasn't all serious chats and very rarely does he moan about me to her but it was just someone in his life that let him release all the build up. Between OW, me and all his other friends he felt compete as everyone offered something to help him be 'emotionally fulfilled'. Hence she was the missing piece because she offered the listening that no one else did. Again I reiterated he should talk to me. He pointed out I should have spoken to him about my feelings too. Touché. However hearing my H band about phrases like being 'emotionally fulfilled' made me see red and I said I needed to go out. This is when it seems I did a full body swap.
Proceeded to go full on woman possessed and went to OW'd house unannounced, almost wanted to surprise her and see if she said the same things as H or if I could catch them out.
Did not account for her being out and her H being home.
Anyway ended up talking to him for a while.
We managed to really fuck up their honeymoon. He said he knows when she is lying and he can hand on heart say she thought I knew. He does think it suited her to not bring it up because she is a people pleaser and didn't want to risk the friendship with H and I but apparently she was furious and kept talking about how awful I must be feeling and he had messed up the thing that means the most to him. Poor guy, I was a bit of an arsehole to him. I said I think it suits him for H and I to stay together then there is no risk of my H and OW getting together. He is very blunt. Said he could not give a monkeys if H and I split or make a go of it because at the end of the day H is her mate and it is highly likely they will stay friends even if just at work so I have to accept it, work throught it or walk away . I asked him why he put up with it and he said there was nothing to really put up with. Initially he had check messages and kept tabs but there really seems to have been nothing going on. He doesn't like my H because he is a hypocrite ( aka having a go at people cheating and yet he did to) but he has been a good friend to OW and he views H as being like a brother to OW and apparently he listens to her talk about all the boring shit she is interested in that he isn't and my H listens it seems. I pointed out brothers tend not to go down on their sisters (seriously why am I not this ruthless with H?!) and he laughed. Burst out laughing. Told me finally he was glad to see me have a bit of backbone. Asked him if he would class it as an emotional affair. He said no. She comes home and talks about what they have talked about ( the way H sometimes did with me) and that they go weeks etc not being in contact. I asked how he could be so sure and he said he trusts her plus He said he couldn't get annoyed about something she did when they weren't together but it annoyed him for a good while that her and H were still friendly but as he is still friends with his ex he could hardly kick off about it. He pointed out that everyone understands why I am so angry and upset (clearly I have been discussed by the group) but he can say as someone who was close and had sex with someone and is now their friend, the feelings of attraction to someone can go away and you just enjoy their company. I told him I didn't want her in our lives if I was to try and rebuild things with H. He said that was fair enough but OW is not the other woman she doesn't want my H or my life so the anger I feel to her would be better directed at H as he was the lying prick in all this. He also said it does seem like H does want to work it out with me. OW came in just as I was leaving and I told her she needs to stay away as she might not love H but he loves her. She said he really doesn't but my gut is telling me otherwise.
So there we are. She can be gone physically but I'll still be competing with her emotionally I think ( unless he gets a damn good counsellor) and I know in reality his navel gazing is the last thing I want to hear about when cooking dinner for the kids etc. We have a good life in the grand scheme and are relatively comfortable with a nice home and two healthy kids what can we really moan about. Keep thinking how we can incorporate 'talking about our feelings' into our marriage and it feels so alien a concept as we are so practical a couple and get on with things. I don't want date nights to be spent in a marriage counsellors. Gah if she had never come back in being miss perfect listener I wouldn't need to be dealing with this. Maybe i am wrong but sometimes people can over think and put themselves in the centee of the universe when in actual fact in the grand scheme you do not need to analyse every emotion you feel. I can't control his thoughts or keep wondering what it is about her over me or try to be her replacement. I'll go mad.