Sazdun, you are correct. This man is very stubborn. HIS wants/needs are front and center.
He is obsessed with OW and is scrambling to keep her and maintain the status quo. The purpose of his self-serving missive is to manipulate you into accepting OW in his life forever. He is NOT taking you seriously. If he were, he’d have definitively ended his personal relationship with her.
My Ballsy Girl. When he met OW, you’d been together 7 years and were engaged. Where was this adoration of you when he was, at the very least, spending 2013-14 bonding, flirting, kissing, sexting, and going down on OW, at the very least? He actually downplayed your relationship so he could “see where her and him would go.” He refers to the cunnilingus as a stupid, impulsive mistake, but he was clearly cheating with OW for a good while prior to that night.
I don’t want to have sex/an affair. He appears to only consider physical involvement to be infidelity. He is not accepting/admitting that their deeply intimate connection, which he is desperate to sustain, is an emotional affair. And he is lying by denying their physical attraction. Sazdun, I strongly advise you to order Not Just Friends by Dr. Shirley Glass for you both to read.
Seeing things that weren’t there. He is absolutely gaslighting you re his broken-hearted response at OW’s wedding. You know what you saw and what he said in the immediate aftermath. Trust that. He is re-writing history.
I too am disturbed that he lamented hurting you and OW in the same breath. I also agree that he has made a public mockery of you by keeping you in the dark for years while everyone was privy.
He had an EA/PA pre-marriage, and later restarted an emotional affair with OW under her terms, conducting it in your orbit and creating space to act on their deepening intimacy. They’ve had the best of both worlds. H enjoyed his marriage/family, and OW basked in the validating glow of your family and friends. Both of them have been hugely gratified by their emotional bond, sexual frisson, KISA/Damsel dynamic, and flirty, intimate banter. They will fight giving it up.
Sazdun, you have no marriage until H cuts OW loose.