Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

How can I forgive myself after having an affair?

51 replies

HLL11 · 06/03/2018 12:47

I’m wondering whether there’s anyone there who can relate to my situation, and if so whether they can tell me how they dealt with it. I know many will have a lot of negative things to say, but constructive feedback would be very welcome. Basically, I feel like my life is a mess. I don’t recognise myself or understand my behaviour. I feel like another person has come in and taken over. I feel like I’ve lost control and I’m spiralling. I have everything. A beautiful wife who I have loved since I met her, and who loves me back. She is affectionate, attentive and kind. But we have been spending less time together since we got married due to demands with her job, and we have drifted. We have also moved to a different city where we have very few friends and as a result I’ve found myself alone a lot and feeling bored, restless and isolated. In response to this, I made contact with another woman online around 9 months ago, and we began having a fairly intense ‘online’ relationship which involved almost constant online contact, mostly of a very sexual nature. We went months without ever meeting face to face, and even some months where we didn’t talk at all. I knew what I was doing was wrong and the guilt got the better of me. I told my wife what I’d done. She was obviously hurt but appreciated my honesty and seemed to get over it within a few days. I promised I had ended the contact with the other woman, and I had. Then after a couple of months I stupidly re-established contact. I was feeling lonely and unhappy and it led me to become incredibly self-involved and selfish. I was angry about situations with my wife involving her frequent absence due to work demands and felt taken for granted and emotionally abandoned. I was also struggling with the contempt shown by her homophobic parents about our relationship, which put strain on our relationship and I blamed my wife, even though it wasn’t her fault. I felt resentful and found myself again tempted to look elsewhere for validation. I hate myself for saying it but I craved attention. I love my wife so much. She is the perfect match for me, despite the (fairly minor) problems we’ve been having. But ever since we first met I’ve craved time to explore my sexuality and experience sex with other partners outside the constraints of a relationship. This is something I have never experienced having been in a string of committed monogamous relationships since the age of 14 ( I am now almost 30). I have been open about these feelings with my wife, but it’s understandably difficult for her as she doesn’t share the same desires and has had multiple partners in the past and grown bored of it. This feeling was compounded when we got married. Our wedding was wonderful in so many ways and the feeling of bonding and union that followed was profound. But I couldn’t help feeling that I had committed to something that I didn’t fully understand or necessarily agree with. Are humans ever truly monogamous? Do we truly stop seeing or seeking fulfilment from other people, even when we are deeply in love with one person in particular, even after we marry them? Does desire for others disappear simply because we have promised loyalty to one person only? This hasn’t been my experience. I have always considered myself to be monogamous and staying faithful has always come easily to me. But as I get older, the urge for self-exploration has grown and I’ve begun to think differently about it. These feelings and urges started to overwhelm me, to the point where I found it virtually impossible, despite countless failed attempts, to cut off all contact with the other woman. Eventually the messaging led to meeting in person, which then led to sex. I know, how depressingly predictable. We have now had sex several times and the guilt of it is consuming me. Where the comparatively innocent text messaging phase offered me a certain amount of enjoyment and I must selfishly admit, a much needed ego boost, the development of the relationship has turned into something altogether darker and far more shameful. I can’t understand how it got to this point, and I’m terrified because I am becoming emotionally involved with the other woman and I know she has very strong feelings for me. I feel responsible for her happiness and don’t want to hurt her. Although she has given me a great deal of sexual gratification, I will never love her and can’t imagine ever leaving my wife, who is the love of my life. I feel so utterly stupid and can’t believe I have got myself into this situation. My relationship is deemed by others to be the ideal relationship, and I have always been overcome by so much pride and gratitude for having such a wonderful and strong relationship with someone so amazing. How can I ever thought I needed more? How could I ever have jeopardised that? What in me is missing? Why did I do this? I can’t stop asking myself why. I have made a decision to seek counselling to help me work through my issues and understand better why I have done this. There is obviously part of me that is unfulfilled and I have been using sex as means by which to entertain and reassure myself. It gave me a sense of self-worth, and I have always relied on the attention and love of women to give me this. But now I have no self-worth, only disgust and self-hatred. I have decided that I can’t tell my wife what I have done. I have confided in a friend who has agreed that the most constructive way forward would be to end the affair immediately and focus on my marriage. Do everything I can to reconnect with my wife and make sure nothing like this ever happens again. In the meantime, I need to learn to deal with the horrible, all consuming guilt and self-disgust I have brought upon myself. I cannot cause my wife the pain it would cause if I told her what I’d done. I won’t serve any good purpose. All I want to do is put this behind me. Accept it as a terrible mistake and one of life’s big lessons, and learn from it. The thought of cheating on her again sickens me. But if a time arrives where I find myself tempted to stray again, I will have to accept that it is an ongoing pattern of behaviour and will be forced to discuss it with my wife and be totally honest and transparent with her. If that happens I won’t be unable to put it down to just being a one-off ‘terrible mistake.’ Everyone is capable of making mistakes. Even good people make mistakes. But to make the same mistakes again and again is reprehensible, especially when they result in someone else’s pain, and I want to do everything in my power to make sure this doesn’t happen again. I feel so utterly powerless now. I feel like my self-control has been tested to the limit and I’ve felt powerless to resist the temptation of this other woman, even though I know that, as humans, we are capable of mastering our temptation and regulating our behaviour. I can’t deny that I have found the other woman extremely exciting and have been utterly seduced by her. But I know it’s lust and not love and will never compare to what I have with my wife. I am not trying to assuage my guilt by not telling her. I will feel sick to the stomach with guilt whether I tell her or not and will punish myself for a long time to come I’m sure. But I have the opportunity to shield her from pain and suffering. And if I can, I will, whilst allowing myself to feel all the misery of remorse that I so deserve, and deal with it alone, with the help of a counsellor and close friends. I realise that life is testing me in a way I have never experienced before. And all I want to do is recognise the magnitude of my wrongdoing and work to better myself for the future. My friend tells me that punishing myself forever with serve no one, and that instead I have to find a way to move on from this, and learn from it. I am not a perfect person. I am selfish and flawed. But I am a good person too and I know I can be better. I’m hoping there’s someone out there who can relate?

OP posts:
Crispbutty · 06/03/2018 12:51

Get you head out of your arse. You sound like a self indulgent twat and your poor wife deserves soooooo much better.

Eh

Adora10 · 06/03/2018 12:52

Please leave your wife, you clearly do not love her; you are repeatedly seeking out sex with other women; you clearly want to be a single man so do the right thing, make yourself that way so you can shag all you want without any guilt.

What you are doing to your wife is awful, truly awful, if you're as good a person as you say then please leave her to be with a partner that can actually love her how she deserves.

whifflesqueak · 06/03/2018 12:54

I think the poster is a woman in a same sex relationship, adora.

But yes. Awful and self indulgent. All me me me.

user1483387154 · 06/03/2018 12:55

You are a twat who treats his wife like shit. She deserves better than you and you do not deserve forgiveness

Adora10 · 06/03/2018 12:55

And you are not telling your wife for the second time because you fear losing your cushy comfortable perfect couple on the outside lifestyle, simple as that, if you cared about hurting her you'd not be in this position in the first place. Time to move on from this woman and let her be happy.

Xnic · 06/03/2018 12:58

So much self indulgence, when in essence, you have just shagged around behind your wife’s back. Stop romanticising the situation, tell your wife and allow her to make the decision to leave your sorry arse.

Willswife · 06/03/2018 13:02

Crispbutty has covered what needs to happen perfectly.

hellsbellsmelons · 06/03/2018 13:04

Stop shielding her from anything.
Let her go.
Let her find someone that won't do this to her.
She deserves that - surely!?

Moominfan · 06/03/2018 13:05

Tell your wife and let her make her own choices. Mistake once repeatedly nope. Go be single and stop dragging her into your indecisiveness

PNGirl · 06/03/2018 13:06

Are humans ever truly monogamous? Do we truly stop seeing or seeking fulfilment from other people, even when we are deeply in love with one person in particular, even after we marry them? Does desire for others disappear simply because we have promised loyalty to one person only? This hasn’t been my experience.

Yes. And if you don't believe that this is not only possible but is the foundation of marriage vows why the hell did you get married?

Crispbutty · 06/03/2018 13:12

As for... She was obviously hurt but appreciated my honesty and seemed to get over it within a few days.

You realllllly think so? You are deluded. Poor wife.

MoodyTwo · 06/03/2018 13:13

Wow... the fact that you have done it twice means you will do it again and it's not just an accident. I count the first texting as an affair too!
Tell your wife so she can make the decision... it's not up to you to 'shield' her, she needs to know.

tygr · 06/03/2018 13:15

OP is female.

Cricrichan · 06/03/2018 13:35

Wtf? I stopped reading the drivel you wrote half way through.

Leave your wife then you can explore sexually to your heart's content.

Hoppinggreen · 06/03/2018 13:38

Male/female either way still a cheating arsehole who still believes they did no wrong
OP you actually shouldn’t forgive yourself and neither should your wife. She deserves much betted

BelindasRedPlasticHandcuffs · 06/03/2018 13:41

Are humans ever truly monogamous?

Yes. Stop blaming evolution for your fucked up behaviour. You have a brain. Engage it.

Does desire for others disappear simply because we have promised loyalty to one person only?

Desire is irrelevant. Cheating isn't about desire. It's about you being a selfish dick. You didn't just desire someone and then magically appear in her knickers, you conducted a sustained emotionally relationship and then had sex with her!

I will never love her and can’t imagine ever leaving my wife,

Get over yourself and let her find someone that gives a shit about her.

I have decided that I can’t tell my wife what I have done.

You're a coward.

I won’t serve any good purpose.

It would allow your wife to make an educated decision about whether or not she actually knows the woman she's married to and whether she wants to stay in that marriage.

But to make the same mistakes again and again is reprehensible,

Yes, in this case it absolutely is.

I will feel sick to the stomach with guilt whether I tell her or not and will punish myself for a long time to come I’m sure.

Awwww poor love Hmm

But I have the opportunity to shield her from pain and suffering.

Barn door. Horse.

. I realise that life is testing me in a way I have never experienced before.

Life isn't doing a damned thing, it's ALL you.

**
But I am a good person too and I know I can be better.

Get the fuck over yourself. Seriously. Good people don't repeatedly betray the people they love. The entire self indulgent post is all about you and how shitty you feel. You don't want to hurt your wife? Then DON'T CHEAT ON HER. Oh, wait, ship has sailed.

Your poor wife that is going to have her heart broken by your actions, not the fact you told her.

If you want to fuck around then have the decency to let your wife decide whether she wants to be part of that. I don't for a second believe you're going to be faithful to her in the future.

hellsbellsmelons · 06/03/2018 13:47

you clearly want to be a single man
Who said OP was male?
Either way - NOT OK!!!

Irishtwinmumma · 06/03/2018 13:52

Your wife deserves better than you! If you love her and want her to be happy, let her find someone who will cherish her

yetmorecrap · 06/03/2018 13:53

If your wife ‘got over this ‘ in a few days, chances are she may well be doing the same and won’t be as devastated as you think , I found it totally devastating . Get your head out your backside and have an honest discussion. If you do genuinely love her then she deserves to make her own choices

NeilTheSloth · 06/03/2018 13:57

Exactly hellsbells especially with the line:

I was also struggling with the contempt shown by her homophobic parents about our relationship

But it’s obvious that many of the replies are acting on the basis she is a man. Doesn’t matter either way of course, but the assumption is there.

PeppermintPasty · 06/03/2018 14:02

Your wife should leave you for failing to use paragraphs, never mind all the rest of the self indulgent bollocks.

WednesdayAddams2525 · 06/03/2018 14:19

Well, from my personal experience trust can be built back up, and you can have a strong relationship after infidelity if you both want to.

That being said...

The amount of effort required to fix something as disrespectful as what you have described would be monumental. And the amount of forgiveness from your wife. And you would have to be honest and tell her EVERYTHING, if not for yourself then for her. She doesn't deserve to be kept in the dark. She will respect you more if you tell her. And at least that way she knows everything and if she still decides to forgive you then she knows exactly what it is she is forgiving, not just parts you want to tell.

It sounds to me that you aren't committed to this relationship the way you indicated you would be. I suspect you won't be able to keep these feelings at bay and they will resurface. But hey, I don't know you and I could be totally wrong. Either way it's not fair to your wife for you to be having sex with someone else. It's just not on, no matter how you justify it and which way you look at it. It's just a no.

Bite the bullet and tell her everything. No matter what happens at least she won't be in the dark.

I don't envy you, but without meaning to sound cruel, you really have made your bed and it's time you took a bit of responsibility.

These things can be the making of us, it just depends on what happens from here.

WednesdayAddams2525 · 06/03/2018 15:04

Looking through these replies @BelindasRedPlasticHandcuffs has got it spot on. You truly are a coward if you don't tell your wife. And you control desire.

I think many people are attractive but I don't desire them. Because that's inappropriate. It's one thing to think someone is fit, another to be having sex with them. You are the one who chooses how much or little you invest in someone.

We may not choose who we are attracted to, but we get to choose how far those feelings and actions go.

Gazelda · 06/03/2018 15:12

Unless I'm reading this wrong, you haven't actually ended the affair? So how can you forgive yourself for doing something you know is hurtful to your wife but you continue anyway?

You obviously don't want To be monogamous, and you want MN to tell you that's OK. It's your wife's consent that you need. But if I were her I'd be telling you to fuck off out of my life.

Fionne · 06/03/2018 15:14

Jesus. What a load of self indulgent nonsense.