pudding - rule 7, remember, if you're making the effort to go over to his town, then the least he could do is check his messages and tell you where and when to meet. You're right to bin him off.
I agree on the paid vs free sites. I've just done a bit of comparing, and I receive an average of just over 2 views per day on match, compared to about 18 a day on pof. Plus - women on match just don't seem to send or reply to messages (partly because many aren't paid up members so can't) whereas I get a bunch on pof, they're just all from women who look scary and/or can't spell.
Match.com also skew the views a lot so when a subscription is about to expire in the next day or so, or has just expired, suddenly you get a load of views to get you to subscribe again..
Eharmony -I've never heard a good word said about it, everyone seems to think it's a waste of money.