Glad to see it's not just me. Like @NatalieH2220 I think I am wedded to my choices so finding it hard to agree to any others.
Our criteria is nothing too common or traditional but also nothing too 'out there'. That is a very small list! There is a name we both like but it is so unusual that I worry about commiting to it. It is quite long, though the shortened version only has 4 letters. I worry that he will hate us for saddling him with an unusual name (only 4 called it in 2018!), he will never buy anything with his name on it etc etc.
I might be overthinking it...