FWIW, my tuppenceworth on the parenting thing is that if you are basically reasonably well balanced caring parent you are not going to go too far wrong - there can't possibly be one way of bringing up a baby and when it comes to personality, at least you're related to your baby, so you might have an inkling about where its coming from and what might help.
When you read these articles taking into account all the nuances, they're not actually advocating radically different things - Penelope Leach doesn't actually say you should never leave a baby to cry, just that you shouldn't do it regularly for long periods of time. And I'm sure GF doesn't say leave your baby screaming its head off for hours on end. I suppose we took a more PL than GF line with ours (and PL certainly writes much better), but actually by the time we got to DS we were just making it up as we went along anyway.
Anway - totally agree with ZW and our own wise LadyT, its actually the judgy tone that's the problem.
WG - Glad you are taking the end of BF well. I was flummoxed and a bit upset when DD (and later DS) both just decided they didn't fancy it anymore, would have liked it a bit less sudden!
Aubi that story of the encounter with "Nick" is just hilarious!
Rubes - I like your pragmatic take on facebook! Its all a bit stalkerish otherwise. I don't think we have been facebook friends, so I won't be offended
katie - talking of facebook stalking, I think we know someone in common. Again, I don't think we're FB friends, but I "know" who you are from the page and I think we both know LK? I used to know her from the gym, but she would be horrified at the sight of me now...And that sounds like you are going great guns on the non-smoking