daisy I can understand how you feel about baby signing and I am just surprised that someone did not say what you said before now
IMO (I hate typing that, it always makes my think that I am saying it in a right proper posh voice and a stuck up face, which i am Not!) Anyway, IMO, signing helps babies to communicate before they are able to verbalise thier needs.
If you LOs are early talkers then you just would't need it. But how dod you know, with your PFB if they are early talkers or not. So I figure give it a go.
The golden rule is 'Never Sign in Silence' so, I would figure, whichever they are able for first they will do. If they are talking then pos don't worry yourself to continue, but if they sign thn you know that they are able to communicate with out having the capabilities to talk. Which I think is kinda clever.
Wow, at your babe with the 'num num num' What a clever thing!!
I know people think they don't understand but they are totally taking in more than they appear to be.
Ooh, another thing about signing, my fave.
If they are not early talkers and they want something but can't tell you then signing can help. My fave story is when DD was just over a year (cos she was defo walking but not talking). She was ill, I gave her medicine upstairs then brought her and it downsatirs. I set the medicine on the mantlepiece.
She made her way over and was desperately reaching and starting to moan for something on the mantlepiece. I began to say 'sorry darling, I know it is tasty but you can't have anymore'
She then pulled her hand down her hair.
She didn't want the medicine, she wanted the brush that was sitting right next to teh bottle.
I had not taught her that sign, she figured it out herself.
If I had not been teaching her to sign, it would not have occured to her to try and we would both have been upset and frustrated.
For those who hear that it hinders speach, my other fave story is, using the DVD, DD learned to sign 'where'.
One of the first things she then communicated verbally was juice,
but, as she said juice, she signed 'where'
thereby creating a sentence that we could understand.
I think that is dead clever too Not only was she starting to speak but she was starting to communicate her needs in whole sentences.
That doesn't seem like it hindered DD any, to me.
Oops, daisy you got me on my high horse again
It is not for everyone, but then neither is BF or real nappies or, for me, formula (bleagh) but I do think it is a fun thing to do anyway whether you continue with it or place any great emphasis is up to you.
DD and I still sign cos I think it would be a great skill for her to grow up with, I mean how many people, who are not deaf, can sign fluently? I would love to give that skill to my DD and to learn it myself!