newtothenet and Lucy me three.
My DD is 2.6, and as I posted earlier has just started to have meltdowns on an epic scale and I totally recognise the "I want this" no "I want the opposite of this", flipping from one to the other every 10sec with anger increasing all the time.
For us I am now totally convinced that there are a mix of factors at play, and I think only two are easily modifiable. My DD is teething her last big teeth. She has never been an obvious teether, and I think the epic meltdowns come when she is in pain.
Also, getting the amount of sleep right I think has a huge influence. She is I think in the process of dropping her nap, but isn't quite ready for it yet. So again tiredness I think plays a massive part.
Today I have given her ibuprofen every 4 hours and let her nap for as long as she wanted. She has been a delight.
However, I think a big chunk of her behaviour is just about being two and having a whole heap of big emotions that she doesn't know how to handle yet and a growing need to be more in control.
As you will see on this thread the various tactics we all employ are at best hit and miss, and I agree sometimes I try things just to feel like I am doing something.
I do know what doesn't work for us. Offering choice doesn't work for us generally, and using physical force to get clothes on/off doesn't work for us either.
Two tactics that have had a bit of an impact. Firstly being stricter. When she is being naughty I now use a much more forceful tone of voice (she calls it scary mummy), it does make her think twice, sometimes. Hitting and dangerous behaviour and she has time out in her room with no further warnings.
Secondly, I go to the final natural consequence much faster, skipping the hours of persuading and cajoling. So, if she won't put her shoes/coat on, she goes out with none on. If she won't come out, I go without her. I am much more business like in my approach but I know that feeling of dread. Like living with a timebomb.