Fairy - that is your experience but as you probably have seen others have really found her stuff (not just routines worthwhile). As a coincidence, look what Pena (from Singapore I gather from other threads) wrote today under the Sleep : 7 months old not sleeping enough :
By pena on Wednesday, 6 February, 2002 8:03:35 AM
"Its already a daunting experience to be a first time mum, but to then decide to take the GF path...quite over whelming I found in the first 6 weeks - at some point, I seriously considered burning the book, of course, now I swear by GF. "
And this is something else that was written very recently by another mum :
"In the Gina Ford debates, what strikes me are the vehement anti-GF brigade. Noone who is pro GF has ever expressed the kind of closed mind that some of the antiGF folks have. The antis go on about how dogmatic GF is when in fact they are being far more dogmatic in their "Don't go down the GF route" stance. I have never heard a pro Gina mum say GF is the ONLY way to go , whereas the antis seem to say "GF is definately NOT the way to go" ! And that is without trying her routines. It seems from what I have read so far many Gina converts started out following current ideas about baby-led feeding and sleeping routines.
As I have said before, I had not heard of her routines until enlightened by yourself and others on Mumsnet."
Just thought these 2 mums were quite representative of the mums who use GF's book. We like her stuff, it's worked for us (and sometimes some of it was hard work)... and yes she may have made some money by writing a book that is common sense (BTW a lot of anti GF think she is mad or just about, so to them it isn't common sense anyway)... but what do you all think Delia Smith makes money on ???? She didn't invent anything ! She just shares her extensive experience with how to book which sells millions !