Good heavens! What on earth????
I clicked on this thread as I was interested in the subject.....
Baddz - in answer to your question - I agree with some of the others - you should not need to be prescribed ADs as well as HRT for all the reasons given. Do try the HRT and give it a decent amount of time, and if necessary change type, before deciding you need something else. Many women need to try several before setlling on something that works for them, as well as changing dosage now and again as time goes by and as we go through menopause and our hormones settle. I think someone may also have suggested vaginal oestrogen as well as HRT for urethral and bladder problems (ie estriol cream or Vagifem) - but HRT alone may help initially. I use both - HRT and vaginal oestrogen - started with just vaginal oestrogen, then later started HRT instead, then even later resumed the vag oestrogen.
As for all the hoohah (however you spell this) - er who exactly do you think should post on here eliottsmam ? I am flabbergasted at the venom with which you attack another poster for providing helpful information to women who are trying to find out stuff to help them through this distressing time.
I mean we are all unqualified (well I imagine most of us) ie we are not medics but many have degrees, some have studied science to research level ie PhD. Are all these women unqualified lay people and therefore their comments should be dismissed? Some of us are very well read and are fortunate enough to be able to understand what we read and pick out the good science from the rubbish - and use this ability and knowledge to try to help others in the best possible way. How dreadful to shoot people down like this!
In terms of selective quotes - well of course we all post what we choose but recent review sources are the most likely to be the most up to date - eg the national (BMS) and international menopause societies (IMS), NICE, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG). If you go to these sites you will find proper science and no quackery nor biased judgements I would say.
Some posters provide helpful summaries to these - and of course it is important to provide links as well so that readers can look these up for themselves if they so wish. This is all extremely useful!!!
A good summary paper on women's health at menopause is this one from the International Menopause Society "The Prevention of Diseases after Menopause" in whic the role of HRT is discussed and reviewed, as well as lifestyle factors. www.imsociety.org/downloads/world_menopause_day_2014/white_paper/wmd_white_paper_english.pdf
Apologies for digressing OP but I felt I had to comment!