Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Wrongfully being accused by brother and wife

330 replies

ForJoyousDog · 05/06/2024 08:18

I don't know what to do! My brother has POA for finances for my mother, which he has actioned and now deals with her banking. He and his wife are doing an audit of mum's spending since dad died in 2019. Mum became a recluse after his death, the mobility car had to be returned. I live 750 miles from mum, my brother 12 miles but to help mum I did her grocery shopping online using her debit card. This turned into birthday cards, gifts, hobby materials etc but everything with her authority to use her account and card. My brother and his wife have said that now my brother "has unrestricted access to mum's account and are working closely with the bank as there are suspicious payments that have come out of her account". I have done nothing wrong, certainly not used my mothers bank account as my own but the accusation has been going on since January, the messages I get are hateful, they are relishing trying to destroy me, my husband won't support me because he told me this would happen and he is angry as to how this makes him look. My mother has told my brother that I had authority to do any shopping etc using her card, but it is still going on. I'm not eating, sleeping and my relationship is suffering. What can I do to make this stop does anyone have any ideas please?

OP posts:
Theweepywillow · 06/06/2024 21:18

sandyhappypeople · 06/06/2024 18:52

there's another post from around february time linked further up the thread which is exactly the same as OPs, but it states that her mums card had accidentally been used to pay for something on OPs amazon account and her brother found it while going through her mums bank statements.

OP says she didn't realise and offered to pay it back + 'compensation' but she didn't want to have to give her brother a screenshot as proof of paying it back for some reason.. same as here, she doesn't seem to want to provide proof of what the money was being spent on, even though if it's all above board she should be able to.

Oh if that’s the op it does explain why she’s not evidenced the spends, it would be so easy, and why her husband is saying he won’t support her and knew this would happen. I really hope it’s not the case though. And she’s not been effectively stealing from her mother. That would be shocking.

Etoile41 · 06/06/2024 21:21

If your mother still has capacity, she can cancel the POA.

Ladybirdg1984 · 06/06/2024 23:20

It all depends on what your mother agreed to when the LPA was set up... however surely your brother should accept your mother's word in respect of agreed expenditure of her money for gifts etc (that you helped her to purchase as she had no other means to do so). Some appointed LPAs are questionable in my experience... 🤨 They can be revoked if not deemed to be acting in the donors best interests albeit the donor should be able to make this decision (if not it goes to court of protection to make the decision) x

Livelovebehappy · 06/06/2024 23:27

You’ve done nothing wrong OP. And your brother and sil are wasting their time doing what they’re doing, as your mum would have to report to the police and bank that she knew nothing about these purchases, which you say she admits she knew and was happy with you doing her shopping for her on her behalf. If your mum continues to support your version of events, and she has all her faculties, they can shout until they’re blue in the face, but nothing will come of it.

angelfacecuti75 · 06/06/2024 23:50

Get the text messages or whatever you can your mum sent you and search the online orders.

Dotcomma · 07/06/2024 01:48

I'd get some legal advice just so you know where you stand. As far as you're concerned you've done nothing wrong so you've nothing to hide.

Do you ever see your mum in person? Is she able to talk to you on the telephone?

Maybe he's peed off because his wife won't help and he's taking it out on you and mum. You can't control what your mum says about you but he's obviously not happy about it - that's not your problem.

If he wants to salvage your relationship he needs to let you have evidence to back up what he's saying and then you can prove that what he's saying is wrong. It would be interesting for you to see copies of bank statements so you can see if there's any anomalies - sums of money spent/withdrawn that look suspicious. He might just look at the bank statements and assume you're spending on yourself because it looks that way - you know different. Prove him wrong and keep notes about conversations/accusations - don't give him any evidence of transactions you've made on mum's behalf because you don't know what he might do with it - just make a list of all for yourself and your own records. Tell him to put everything in writing by email so you have a record/
paper trail.

Hope that helps.

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 08:18

The OP is worried
and so she should be

she bought herself and her husband presents on her mothers credit card

her mother has full capacity and has clearly
appointed her son as POA because she’s been concerned about the OP’s spending but hasn’t felt able to do anything about it. Her son is now on the case and doing a damn good job by the sounds of it

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 08:42

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 08:18

The OP is worried
and so she should be

she bought herself and her husband presents on her mothers credit card

her mother has full capacity and has clearly
appointed her son as POA because she’s been concerned about the OP’s spending but hasn’t felt able to do anything about it. Her son is now on the case and doing a damn good job by the sounds of it

What? 🤣

Her DM has written a letter to her own bank confirming that she authorised everything the OP purchased on her card. She has told OP’s brother already that she authorised all payments.

So where do you manage to get that her DM is concerned about OP’s spending and feels like she can’t say anything?

Are you on glue?

Or are you the SIL? You’re the SIL aren’t you? 😂

Lyraloo · 07/06/2024 09:21

OldPerson · 06/06/2024 17:58

What's the problem? It's a bank account with itemised payments. You can either justify spending your mother's money or you can't.

There's no "he says/ she says"

It's there in black and white.

I'd be suspicious of the vague "gifts"? Gifts to who for what?

If you've spent money you're not entitled to spend, pay it back.

Sounds like brother stepped in because mum did not have enough money to pay a bill or there was a red flag in her finances?

Wow, you’re making a lot of assumptions there! From this and your other posts you clearly think this lady is guilty of fraud. Stop being so nasty.

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 11:01

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 08:42

What? 🤣

Her DM has written a letter to her own bank confirming that she authorised everything the OP purchased on her card. She has told OP’s brother already that she authorised all payments.

So where do you manage to get that her DM is concerned about OP’s spending and feels like she can’t say anything?

Are you on glue?

Or are you the SIL? You’re the SIL aren’t you? 😂

Edited

”are you on glue”

are you 14 years old in the 1990s? 😆

Rosscameasdoody · 07/06/2024 11:24

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 08:18

The OP is worried
and so she should be

she bought herself and her husband presents on her mothers credit card

her mother has full capacity and has clearly
appointed her son as POA because she’s been concerned about the OP’s spending but hasn’t felt able to do anything about it. Her son is now on the case and doing a damn good job by the sounds of it

If her mother has full capacity, and, as OP has stated, has confirmed she authorised the payments, why is the brother interfering ? Sounds to me as though he’s unclear as to what a lasting power of attorney is for, because even if the LPA has been registered to use immediately, her mother still has control while she has capacity.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/06/2024 11:34

My brother and his wife have said that now my brother has unrestricted access to mum's account and are working closely with the bank as there are suspicious payments that have come out of her account".

This is what makes me suspicious that the brother isn’t acting within the terms of the LPA. I have my mums’ LPA for both health and finanical affairs and mum still has capacity - the LPA was registered to be used with immediate effect so that things are easier as her condition affects her capacity. When that happens I will have to register the LPA with the bank, along with evidence that she no longer has the capacity to deal with her financial affairs before they will allow access without mums’ permission. Something doesn’t add up here.

cloddy01 · 07/06/2024 12:27

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 08:18

The OP is worried
and so she should be

she bought herself and her husband presents on her mothers credit card

her mother has full capacity and has clearly
appointed her son as POA because she’s been concerned about the OP’s spending but hasn’t felt able to do anything about it. Her son is now on the case and doing a damn good job by the sounds of it

Talk about assumptions! You seem to have made a firm judgement based on what exactly?

Changingplace · 07/06/2024 14:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 17:59

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 11:01

”are you on glue”

are you 14 years old in the 1990s? 😆

Ah so you are the SIL…😂

I clearly touched a nerve if that’s the best response you could come back with.

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 18:55

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 17:59

Ah so you are the SIL…😂

I clearly touched a nerve if that’s the best response you could come back with.

Yes i’m the SIL and I am on glue 😆

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 18:55

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 17:59

Ah so you are the SIL…😂

I clearly touched a nerve if that’s the best response you could come back with.

I could be the brother surely?

browneyes77 · 07/06/2024 19:53

crayfishyum · 07/06/2024 18:55

I could be the brother surely?

You could be yes.

Either way you’re a fan of fiction.

Seemingly making up stories as you go along, that aren’t remotely related to the things the OP has actually said.

Jadeleigh196 · 07/06/2024 21:47

Ignore @crayfishyum I've seen them on about 4 different threads today being deliberately obtuse and trying to wind people up. They must be leading a very miserable life.

GoldEagle · 07/06/2024 22:11

Seems to me your SIL may have a lot to do with these accusations being made by your brother.

diddl · 08/06/2024 10:07

GoldEagle · 07/06/2024 22:11

Seems to me your SIL may have a lot to do with these accusations being made by your brother.

Strange isn't it?

My husband has poa for his parents & honestly I have no interest at all in their finances!

sagittariusThroughandthrough · 08/06/2024 11:21

i may be wrong but from my understanding, anyone can nominate someone to be a POA at any point however they will only have the power in the case of lack of capacity. It would also depend if he has POA for finance, health or both.
if someone has dementia they may still have capacity, or they may have capacity about finances but not their health vice versa.
if your mum has capacity regarding her finance then it’s nothing to do with your brother if he was genuinely concerned he’d seek the advice of police/solictors.
just from now on tell your mum your sorry and can’t do the shopping due to this issue as harsh as that sounds, if your brother fails to provide her with what he wants then seek to revoke the poa from him as it’s neglected. Good luck

Underestimated4 · 08/06/2024 11:58

If POA only kicked in in Jan there’s nothing legally they can do.

Ask them to list the money they and unsure of and spend time working it out what it was

Theweepywillow · 08/06/2024 12:08

Underestimated4 · 08/06/2024 11:58

If POA only kicked in in Jan there’s nothing legally they can do.

Ask them to list the money they and unsure of and spend time working it out what it was

Of course they can, don’t be silly.

cloddy01 · 08/06/2024 13:11

Theweepywillow · 08/06/2024 12:08

Of course they can, don’t be silly.

I think the more apt point is they can't do anything at all if the mum agrees she authorised the payments!!! The poa doesn't mean they can over rule the mums wishes!!