Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

News

Henry Nowak - just watched the video for the first time

1000 replies

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · Yesterday 06:57

I don’t understand how the officers could not tell he had been stabbed. He repeatedly says he can’t breathe and when he says he has been stabbed, they say, ‘I don’t think so mate.’ When he says it again they ask where and he says his face, they then roll him over so they can look at his face, and the video ends with the officer saying the handcuffed victim was likely going to be sick.

i completely understand the officers went there having been told a lie and you see the perpetrator on the video retelling the lie and claiming he’d been a victim of a racist assault, i just can’t understand how the officers didn’t recognise the guy on the floor was dying.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Genevieva · Yesterday 09:42

prh47bridge · Yesterday 09:39

It does not trump the law. It is the law.

In general, it is illegal to carry a knife other than a folding pocket knife with a blade of 3 inches or less without good reason or lawful authority. However, it is not an offence if you have the knife for use at work, for religious reasons or as part of a national costume. So, for example, it is legal for someone wearing traditional Scottish Highland dress to carry a sgian dubh - a dagger with a blade typically 3.5 inches long tucked into the stocking.

I understand those who want to ban knives completely, but any Scotsman who wants to wear their traditional costume will disagree.

Some Sikh leaders were in the news recently condemning the crime and saying they wish to review the position of the religion on blades. There’s no need for a ceremonial kirpan to (a) be carried daily and (b) be sharp enough to cause harm. Many Sikhs just have a charm sized kirpan like a pendant on a necklace.

Imaginary86 · Yesterday 09:42

NoisyHiker · Yesterday 07:32

It is racism.

Henrys crime was being white. So he was automatically assumed to be guilty, because working class white = bad.

He was handcuffed on the floor while bleeding and begging for help, while his murderer wasn't even handcuffed at any point, even on his way to the police station.

I am not white, and this video has disgusted me. I also see that the government and police are going to lead us all in to a blood bath if they do not get a grip on this two tier treatment.

The government that will get in eventually if they don't, will make Reform look as left as Jeremy Corbyn.

100% this. It is racism. The fact his killer was never handcuffed is disgraceful. If it had been the other way around and Henry had rang the police to say a Sikh man was being racist to him I don’t think they would have even bothered to come out

Erin1975 · Yesterday 09:43

Notgonnalieaboutthis · Yesterday 09:27

I didn’t realise this either. I’m disgusted that people are allowed to carry a knife because of their culture and religion.
Why do cultural considerations trump the law and public safety?
I hope carrying these knives is soon banned. Totally unacceptable.

Groups of people get exemptions form many laws on religious grounds. Carrying a knife is only one. Followers of different religions are allowed to kill animals in an inhumane way, allow their children to die when they can be saved by doctors, assault babies with a razor blade and remove parts of their anatomy and I'm sure there are many more examples.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · Yesterday 09:44

TiredCatLady · Yesterday 09:10

How many times? He didn’t stab him with the Kirpan. He stabbed him with an eight inch knife which he was also carrying.

Banning the Kirpan wouldn’t have made an iota of difference because he was also carrying a significantly larger knife.

The onus the media is putting on the ceremonial knife is drawing attention away from what actually happened and what led to this awful tragedy.

He did stab him with a ceremonial kirpan. Read the judge's sentencing remarks. Amazingly, there is an exemption in law for the minority of Sikhs who feel they have to carry a large knife slung across their clothing, so it was perfectly legal for him to have it on display like that. As others have mentioned, this is not legal in other parts of the world and Sikhs have accepted it. I feel there's a strong case for the Sikh community here to agree this is not acceptable and urge Parliament to change the law. And if they don't Parliament should change the law anyway.

ExitPursuedByABare · Yesterday 09:44

And yet Christians could get into trouble for wearing a gold cross on a chain under their uniform.

Time for these religious weapons to be banned in the UK. Sorry Sikhs. (Or blunted).

RoboBoogie · Yesterday 09:44

CoralOP · Yesterday 09:41

What's disgusting about this is it happened last year. The mainstream media is only reporting on it now because too many people know about it.

People have been outraged on 'far right' 🙄 media channels for months while most people who watch BBC and ITV are walking around oblivious of this horrible crime. I think people need to watch more of the thousands of videos that are out there and they will be a lot more informed of the horrible crimes that are going on in thus country.

I heard about this crime months ago and I am very mainstream newsmedia focused- such as BBC, Independent and Guardian news websites

EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:44

askmenow · Yesterday 09:38

This ☝! I am just so incredibly sad we have come to this, I cant even find the words I feel so sick..

Surely anyone anyone with ANY empathy would have looked at the chap on the floor and released him from his cuffs when he said 9 times.....NINE times ,he couldn't breathe!

Above all the police officers role should have been to quickly assess and PRESERVE LIFE! First and foremost.
At that point whether the collapsed person was the perp or the victim wouldn't matter. You don't mess around when someone tell you they cant breathe.

ABC....Airways, Breathing, Circulation.

How the hell are we training our police officers? If this had been a brown man, there would be riots in the streets.

Handcuffing an 18 year old stabbed in the chest as he pleads is unbearable to consider.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 09:45

Genevieva · Yesterday 09:29

I think the analogy being made is the introduction of community policing by the back door, where police are overly concerned about identity labels. Lady Justice should always be blind. That means the police should carry out their duties without fear or favour. In particular without fear of accusations of racism, transphobia or any other equivalent.

You people are shameless.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:45

RoboBoogie · Yesterday 09:44

I heard about this crime months ago and I am very mainstream newsmedia focused- such as BBC, Independent and Guardian news websites

What did you hear?

TwoPercentForLookingInTheMirrorTwice · Yesterday 09:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

senua · Yesterday 09:45

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 09:39

Shameless disrespect.

Why is it "shameless disrespect" to point out a pattern of Police behaviour?

CoralOP · Yesterday 09:45

RoboBoogie · Yesterday 09:44

I heard about this crime months ago and I am very mainstream newsmedia focused- such as BBC, Independent and Guardian news websites

It's literally all over the news channels today, in papers, people finally talking about it on here, there was none of this on the regular news channels when it actually happened.

PistolPacker · Yesterday 09:46

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · Yesterday 09:36

When was the last time you were stopped and searched as part of a routine/random check?

Aside from at the airport I don't believe I have been. You can pretend that's to do with my "white privilege" if you want. Unless you're going to come back and claim EVERY non-white person has been subjected to a stop and search?
If not I'm just like a Black 40-something who hasn't been either.

CaesarAugusta · Yesterday 09:47

CoralOP · Yesterday 09:41

What's disgusting about this is it happened last year. The mainstream media is only reporting on it now because too many people know about it.

People have been outraged on 'far right' 🙄 media channels for months while most people who watch BBC and ITV are walking around oblivious of this horrible crime. I think people need to watch more of the thousands of videos that are out there and they will be a lot more informed of the horrible crimes that are going on in thus country.

Not really. Once someone was charged, news organisations were very hamstrung in terms of what they were allowed to report until the trial opened. There were plenty of reports of that.

askmenow · Yesterday 09:48

Notgonnalieaboutthis · Yesterday 09:32

I don’t understand this either. It’s a harrowing story.

Apparently the murderers brother called the police, AFTER the murderers mother had taken the knife and hidden it.

Which is why she is in custody and I hope they throw the book at her. The brother should be jailed for lying to the police and the mother given a jail term aswell.

Given she has dual citizenship, then after her release, deported to her country of birth.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 09:49

senua · Yesterday 09:45

Why is it "shameless disrespect" to point out a pattern of Police behaviour?

Go. Away.

Dollymylove · Yesterday 09:49

MaturingCheeseball · Yesterday 08:40

Can anyone explain if the police that resigned will get off scot free - simply by quitting? I made a formal complaint about medical incompetence to a health authority, and they replied that Dr X had left so that was the end of that.

They should be done for gross negligence manslaughter

Womblesgash · Yesterday 09:50

Imaginary86 · Yesterday 09:42

100% this. It is racism. The fact his killer was never handcuffed is disgraceful. If it had been the other way around and Henry had rang the police to say a Sikh man was being racist to him I don’t think they would have even bothered to come out

Is it any wonder though the Officers acted in a racist way as you've called it?

Yes those Officers were grossly negligent but for years Police forces and officers have been told by everyone they ARE racist, they stop search too many non-white people, they pull over non-white people in vehicles too much for no reason whatsoever, they don't investigate race incidents properly in comparison to other crimes etc..

MelanzaneParmigiana · Yesterday 09:51

EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:45

What did you hear?

It was all over X
Thanks to Elon Musk there is still some exposure to ignored by the Biased Broadcasting Corporation,

EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:51

RoboBoogie · Yesterday 09:34

The judge's comments below explain that he is legally allowed to carry a knife up to 9 inches long as part of being in the Nihang order of Sikhs.

  1. You were sober but were carrying a large Sikh dagger in a sheath attached to a belt over the outside of your clothing. It is a strict requirement of the Sikh faith to have a knife, called a kirpan, at all times. Generally, this will be a small knife, hidden from view, often on a length of cord and worn around the neck. You had that but, in addition, the large dagger in a sheath. You are a member of an order of Sikhs called the Nihang who have a tradition of having a second knife, or kirpan and that is often fully visible, believing that the guru will look favourably on that. You observed that tradition in your everyday life, at work and in public. However, it was not a strict requirement; that is borne out by the fact that neither your brother nor father who arrived on the scene after you had stabbed Henry were so dressed. According to Professor Gurnam Singh, Professor of Sociology and an expert in the field: “Over the last 30 years, there has been a trend towards younger people wearing a kirpan with pride, in a desire to express their cultural identity. They see it as an act of resistance to being denied the ability otherwise to display their identity.”
  2. The privilege extended to practising Sikhs of being allowed to be in public with a bladed article and, particularly in respect of the large dagger, a highly dangerous weapon, easily accessible to the wearer, brings with it huge responsibility.
  3. It is a fundamental principle of Sikhism that any kirpan is worn as a symbol of religious faith and is never to be carried for an offensive purpose. The legal approach to the carrying of such a knife, as long as the blade length does not exceed 9 inches, is that an offence of Having a Bladed Article in a public place will not be prosecuted; there has been an acceptance that its possession in those circumstances, can amount to a good religious and, therefore, legal reason for having it. The blade of the knife will not be on display; either it is under clothing or, alternatively, in a sheath. For both, it is a religious and, consequently, legal requirement that a kirpan should only be used offensively as a last resort, which would include its use in legal self-defence. In other words, only if use is necessary and, if so, reasonable in the circumstances. It is obvious that for use to be reasonable, any perceived threat justifying its use would only be in circumstances of great seriousness and urgency.

I’m surprised at this.

selfloveandselfrespect · Yesterday 09:51

RoboBoogie · Yesterday 08:54

Ok, but if he hadn't been 'lawfully' allowed to carry a knife then perhaps Henry Nowak would still be alive ?

Henry was killed with an ordinary knife not the Kirpan.

MelanzaneParmigiana · Yesterday 09:52

askmenow · Yesterday 09:48

Apparently the murderers brother called the police, AFTER the murderers mother had taken the knife and hidden it.

Which is why she is in custody and I hope they throw the book at her. The brother should be jailed for lying to the police and the mother given a jail term aswell.

Given she has dual citizenship, then after her release, deported to her country of birth.

Completely agree but of course it won’t happen.

Vinvertebrate · Yesterday 09:52

Even Starmer’s statement about this has my fucking blood boiling. “He was a lovely lad who definitely didn’t do the racism of which he was accused”. Fucks sake, as if that’s the first thing to worry about or remember, now he’s died in agony surrounded by indifferent fuckwits, and his family are devastated. It’s almost implying that our actual PM - supposedly one of the grown-ups - thinks the death would have been understandable if the victim had actually said hurty words to a POC.

And the reporting is woeful. The judgment explains that the brothers were chatting in Punjabi, in front of the police, about how they’d be in deep shit if there was video footage of the incident (ie because they’d just lied their arses off). Why is this not reported (because it would prove they were lying about the racism?) Why are the colluding family members not being charged?

The Sikh community as a whole does absolute wonders for a charity I volunteer with, and it’s notable that there have been so few knife-related incidents, but since we cannot trust any police force to act without fear or favour, the religious exception absolutely needs to go.

Glowingup · Yesterday 09:53

BridgetJonesV2 · Yesterday 09:26

As a white female, most of the time I feel a second class citizen in this country.

We've allowed minority religions and minority races to hold all the cards. The Police/Government are too afraid to stand up for the majority and now look where we are.

How that boy died is INEXCUSABLE. We have to learn from it. I cried watching his family on the news last night, how will they ever learn to live with such loss.

Edited

Yup the Rights for Whites are out in force

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.