Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

News

Henry Nowak - just watched the video for the first time

1000 replies

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · Yesterday 06:57

I don’t understand how the officers could not tell he had been stabbed. He repeatedly says he can’t breathe and when he says he has been stabbed, they say, ‘I don’t think so mate.’ When he says it again they ask where and he says his face, they then roll him over so they can look at his face, and the video ends with the officer saying the handcuffed victim was likely going to be sick.

i completely understand the officers went there having been told a lie and you see the perpetrator on the video retelling the lie and claiming he’d been a victim of a racist assault, i just can’t understand how the officers didn’t recognise the guy on the floor was dying.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
TheHateUGive · Yesterday 15:10

CrispySquid · Yesterday 13:32

This is the crux of it. The police shouldn’t be making any assumptions at all or making moral judgements on who should be given immediate medical treatment or not. Even if it was cut and dry that hypothetical culprit X was a horrific racist or a rapist or started an altercation or assault or was suspected to have murdered someone, if they require urgent medical attention and are bleeding out, that should require upmost urgency and priority and they should not be handcuffed instead of receiving first aid and an ambulance being called. Atrocious behaviour by the police.

Yes! We don't ration NHS care by good or bad.

The reason why this type of thing happens to Black people is because people assume that Black people are bad so care less about things like getting them timely medical attention. It isn't because they are Black. It is because they think being Black means being bad.

In this case, these police officers thought that they get to be the deciders of about whether the victim is bad and how he should be treated as a result of their decision. That's totally outside their remit.

SnappyQuoter · Yesterday 15:10

Tessasanderson · Yesterday 15:05

This is different to what i had read. I though the attackers brother had called the police.

He did, and lied. But a neighbour also called and said someone had been stabbed. So the police had that information and chose to ignore it. Or it was never passed on… so the call handlers chose to ignore it. Hopefully that comes out in the independent report.

YourGoldSquid · Yesterday 15:12

Comeinsideforacupoftea · Yesterday 09:30

As another white female I have never felt one bit a second class citizen. Can you please clarify what real life experiences you have had exactly that make you feel this way?

Can you also clarify exactly what you think should be done in retaliation to this case?

I'm not female, but I imagine young Scottish girls being threatened to the point they had to defend themselves with a knife and then demonized as racists in the press is a good example?

Maybe white British girls being systematically sexually abused by minority men? And then being ignored by the government and the press? One even being talked to by the police about sharing their stories.

I suppose there may be others, but these are two that come to mind. And what's the common denominator? The white girls are the real criminals. Not the minority men who abused them.

Henry was a white boy. Murdered by an minority man. And yet again, the white British victim is treated as the abuser and criminal. In this case he is coldly left to bleed out and die as he is read his rights as an accused criminal.

At this point, claiming there is nothing wrong seems like either 1) willful ignorance or 2) incredible privileged to avoid areas and situations where this stuff happens.

In the US we ended up with Trump, in part because of similar attitudes. And it has gotten ugly. When privileged liberals tell working class people to ignore what is plainly before their eyes, and then accuse them of racism for noticing, you end up with Farage and Trump.

mindfulmoaning · Yesterday 15:12

The police have tried hard to lose their institutional racism label but it’s resulted in harm in another way. They just need to treats everyone equally and keep an open mind.

Glowingup · Yesterday 15:13

SnappyQuoter · Yesterday 15:10

He did, and lied. But a neighbour also called and said someone had been stabbed. So the police had that information and chose to ignore it. Or it was never passed on… so the call handlers chose to ignore it. Hopefully that comes out in the independent report.

Well no you don’t know that. Presumably it was dealt with by a different call handler and a separate dispatch would have been made. I doubt that if the police had been told there was report of a stabbing would just dismiss it. The call handler asked the brother three times if there were any weapons and he said no. He also asked if Henry had been injured and the brother said there was an injury to the face but nothing about the stabbing.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 15:13

Allisnotlost1 · Yesterday 15:09

I generally think it’s very important that politicians don’t comment on matters like this until proceedings are complete, because of the risk of shaping a narrative or undermining the independence of the judicial or other processes.

I’m prepared to believe it happens (though I can’t recall in the specific cases you named) because we’ve had some self serving politicians over the last few years. Braverman, for example, would have lapped up the opportunity to comment outside of process. But I don’t think that should set the precedent. We should want politics to follow process, not the other way around. It seems to me that the belief that process has followed politics is exactly what people are worried about in this case.

Khan commented. But what is evident is the public react after the event.

PocketSand · Yesterday 15:14

@Glowingup didn’t the judge say that the father had been lied to and didn’t realise that his son had fatally stabbed Henry?

BackToLurk · Yesterday 15:16

Glowingup · Yesterday 15:09

Although tbf allowed his son to tell a load of lies on the phone and didn’t immediately tell the police that Henry had in fact been stabbed.

His father didn't know. From the judge's remarks " You joined your brother in relating these lies to the police. By then your mother and father were at the scene. Gurpreet explained that no weapons had been involved or were present. In fact, whilst he was talking to the call operator, you told your mother to take the murder weapon, sheath and belt away which she did. You did not tell your father what had really happened."

Glowingup · Yesterday 15:17

PocketSand · Yesterday 15:14

@Glowingup didn’t the judge say that the father had been lied to and didn’t realise that his son had fatally stabbed Henry?

Oh sorry I didn’t realise that. I assumed the parents knew. I wonder if the brother knew as well as it strikes me as odd as he was so adamant that the police should attend immediately. Surely it would have been very quickly obvious that the victim had been stabbed? It could be that none of the family realised as they didn’t witness the attack.

OneLoyalLurker · Yesterday 15:18

within 3 minutes of police checking he got medical help. his murderer obviously delayed calling the police which led to him not getting help in time. The way people are already making this about race ,hate and 2 tier policing is disgusting. Many wouldn't care about Henry or grooming gangs if the perps were white. Where is the humanity.

frindolion · Yesterday 15:18

This is what Labour politicians are contributing

What’s very galling is that the likes of Reform, Restore, and the far-right decided to politicise people’s pain, attacking the Sikh community for wearing the kirpan and wanting it banned, even though the kirpan was not used in this violent attack.

Identity politics AGAIN. No community should be allowed to wear deadly weapons it is insanity. I am embarrassed for that MP for Sloug Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi, who I presume is from the very same community. What a shit show. Labour leading us directly into the arms of Reform.

Glowingup · Yesterday 15:20

OneLoyalLurker · Yesterday 15:18

within 3 minutes of police checking he got medical help. his murderer obviously delayed calling the police which led to him not getting help in time. The way people are already making this about race ,hate and 2 tier policing is disgusting. Many wouldn't care about Henry or grooming gangs if the perps were white. Where is the humanity.

Yes it struck me that the call to the police was very lengthy and it was only right at the end that the police arrived. Really awful that he was lying on the ground all this time.

frindolion · Yesterday 15:20

OneLoyalLurker · Yesterday 15:18

within 3 minutes of police checking he got medical help. his murderer obviously delayed calling the police which led to him not getting help in time. The way people are already making this about race ,hate and 2 tier policing is disgusting. Many wouldn't care about Henry or grooming gangs if the perps were white. Where is the humanity.

Where is the humanity
Oh the irony.

@Glowingup the mum knew and is on trial herself for aiding a murderer.

YourGoldSquid · Yesterday 15:21

reesewithoutaspoon · Yesterday 13:26

I watched the body cam. How did none of the officers realise how critical he was. Just look at the colour of his hands when they handcuffed him. They were white/grey. You could see he was in severe shock

They didn't realize because they didn't care. He was a white boy. And white boys are always racist and deserve what's coming to them.

A colleague of mine was talking about this case yesterday. He actually said that Henry was "Kirked" and that the world was better off without one more racist.

All the talk of police training etc... is obfuscation of the real and obvious issue.

Glowingup · Yesterday 15:23

frindolion · Yesterday 15:20

Where is the humanity
Oh the irony.

@Glowingup the mum knew and is on trial herself for aiding a murderer.

Then it’s a disgrace that she didn’t say anything when her son was lying to the operator saying “weapons? I don’t even know what sort of weapons there would be”. On the call, the brother says the mother and father are at the scene. But I do find it odd that the mother knew but the father did not.

frindolion · Yesterday 15:23

YourGoldSquid · Yesterday 15:21

They didn't realize because they didn't care. He was a white boy. And white boys are always racist and deserve what's coming to them.

A colleague of mine was talking about this case yesterday. He actually said that Henry was "Kirked" and that the world was better off without one more racist.

All the talk of police training etc... is obfuscation of the real and obvious issue.

What's kirked.

The real test here is what happens if you report this colleague to HR? Nothing for precisely the reasons people are pointing out on this thread. It would be seen as politically incorrect or culturally sensitive.

HPSauce78 · Yesterday 15:25

As a black woman married to a white man I’ve seen first hand exactly how the police behave when someone uses the “ race card “ and I hate that word against a white person in particular a white male

police are so fucking scared of being called racist they can’t do they can’t do their job but more likely they don’t want to do there job

both those officers should be in court on some kind of charges
and they should be sacked and no pension

I believe from what I read the female officer already resigned a few months ago

Honestly I watched that video and my heart broke a bit

I really hope out of this awful awful murder we won’t have the usual “lesson have been learned” bullshit but more that the fucking rule book on racism gets thrown out the bloody window

OneStarAwake · Yesterday 15:26

frindolion · Yesterday 15:18

This is what Labour politicians are contributing

What’s very galling is that the likes of Reform, Restore, and the far-right decided to politicise people’s pain, attacking the Sikh community for wearing the kirpan and wanting it banned, even though the kirpan was not used in this violent attack.

Identity politics AGAIN. No community should be allowed to wear deadly weapons it is insanity. I am embarrassed for that MP for Sloug Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi, who I presume is from the very same community. What a shit show. Labour leading us directly into the arms of Reform.

Stephen Pollard wrote something very similar in the Telegraph yesterday. He is a Tory supporter.

PocketSand · Yesterday 15:26

The judge’s statement made it clear that the stab wound to the chest was fatal. Immediate paramedic help would not have saved his life. This is why the family don’t waste emotional energy blaming the police and hold the killer 100% responsible.

TheHateUGive · Yesterday 15:28

frindolion · Yesterday 15:23

What's kirked.

The real test here is what happens if you report this colleague to HR? Nothing for precisely the reasons people are pointing out on this thread. It would be seen as politically incorrect or culturally sensitive.

They are comparing this white guy getit g killed by an Indian Sikh man to Charlie Kirk who afaik, was killed by another white man... odd folk.here.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · Yesterday 15:28

OneLoyalLurker · Yesterday 15:18

within 3 minutes of police checking he got medical help. his murderer obviously delayed calling the police which led to him not getting help in time. The way people are already making this about race ,hate and 2 tier policing is disgusting. Many wouldn't care about Henry or grooming gangs if the perps were white. Where is the humanity.

The perpetrator made it about race.

Allisnotlost1 · Yesterday 15:28

EasternStandard · Yesterday 15:13

Khan commented. But what is evident is the public react after the event.

Khan commented on what? The public can react whenever they want, they don’t have any specific duty or responsibility.

PenelopePinkerton · Yesterday 15:31

OneLoyalLurker · Yesterday 15:18

within 3 minutes of police checking he got medical help. his murderer obviously delayed calling the police which led to him not getting help in time. The way people are already making this about race ,hate and 2 tier policing is disgusting. Many wouldn't care about Henry or grooming gangs if the perps were white. Where is the humanity.

Eh? The trial indicated it was a racially motivated attack. 3 minutes is also a long time if you are bleeding out.

TheHateUGive · Yesterday 15:31

PocketSand · Yesterday 15:26

The judge’s statement made it clear that the stab wound to the chest was fatal. Immediate paramedic help would not have saved his life. This is why the family don’t waste emotional energy blaming the police and hold the killer 100% responsible.

Why is that relevant? The man would have had a chance and died with dignity.

About jeez, 20 odd years ago now (can't believe it is that long), my 18 year old.cousin was stabbed in the heart. He died. A helicopter came and they performed open heart surgery in the street.and revived him. He had a baby on the way at the time.

He lived. He was left severely brain damaged but has quality of life and some independence. His communication has actualy improved over the last few years.

OneStarAwake · Yesterday 15:31

YourGoldSquid · Yesterday 15:21

They didn't realize because they didn't care. He was a white boy. And white boys are always racist and deserve what's coming to them.

A colleague of mine was talking about this case yesterday. He actually said that Henry was "Kirked" and that the world was better off without one more racist.

All the talk of police training etc... is obfuscation of the real and obvious issue.

I hope you reported your colleague.
Most employers would not tolerate that being said in the workplace.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.