Mistress
You say reactionary, I say pragmatic. Potayto, potarto.
I think secular, feminist Muslims (especially the one I saw ripping an utter arsehole of an Iman to bits with her Tongue Of Steely Logic on Egyptian telly) deserve an EU state funded stadium tour. With Maz Jobrani and the rest of the Axis of Evil crew opening and closing for them. To widen the appeal. Becuase they could do with popular exposure and "non stoney ground", Muslim and not Muslim, can only benefit from the abundant seeds on offer.
But the bums on seats will not be my "stoney ground" opposites. (Not unless they are there with the sole intent to be wilfully offended, heckle or compile their spreadsheet as per who is letting the side down by laughing or nodding). The bums on seats looking to engage with the content will be the ones who aren't firmly wedded to a fixed set of beliefs. Which means it is highly unlikely they were ever part of the issue we are looking to fix. So as a solution to the current issue it fails becuase it is aimed at preaching to the choir and the people considering applying for the choir.
I'm a teacher. I am very pro education. But Education ! is all too often glibly wafted about as the solution to all ills. Except when you ask who, when, where, why, what, which, how ?... it all gets a bit woolly and vague.
Woolly and Vague is not exactly a killer Ed-Solution with a strong evidence base to support it.
So no. When people waggle Education ! as a solution to this specific set of events (horrifying attacks, media silence, gov. minimising/victim blaming) I get "reactionary" about where limited resources and energies should be diverted. Particularly given that due to my own long standing experience as an immigrant I highly doubt any state funded education in this sphere is ever going to make the tiniest dent on the mindset of anybody with strongly held beliefs.
Education ! Will not persuade Germans, Swedes and Finns that the females amoung them are safe to go to and from work, school and the shops. Nor will it make any real impact on reducing growing anger.
Education ! Will not cut the hay making far right's knees from under them by demonstrating the state's ability to take back control of the streets 24/7 and restore confidence that order has been restored.
Education ! Will do jack shit to avoid yet more victims being created in the short to medium term. And the tolerance for more victims being created could not be any lower.
Education ! Will do nothing to help the victims who have already been created. Especially when they get to compare their physical and emotional scars to the threat of "reprisals by textbook !"
All the above need solutions, yesterday. They will all require more funds and resources than we actually have. If we ignore them we are fucked.
But if anybody thinks I'm wrong and Education ! will work on the problem people, at a pace that meets our needs, and is worth diverting funds to, they have the perfect opportunity to demonstrate just how wrong I am. My feminism is as deeply embedded in me as your average "problematic" Muslim male's mysogeny is in him.
Tell me how you would educate the feminist out of me. Because that is the scale and type of volte-face we are talking about. That is the aim the education is going to have to have, in order to have any real impact outside the classroom, on the people actually being/condoning a problem, in the time frames we have available.
If the chosen stratagies won't work on me, they won't work on my patriarchy loving opposite.
The fact that I am in the right and he is in the wrong does not mean we have special "woolly and vague" Education ! kryptonite that will smite his misogeny out of him when we (metaphorically) bop him on the head with a specially designed tick box sheet.
If state funded, it will have tick boxes. Magic, or otherwise.