Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Why do you get all the knobs at Glastonbury?

1000 replies

mids2019 · 29/06/2025 06:14

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c33514nryy1o

Kneecap and now this.....There are some absolute fits playing at Glastonbury and I am sure there are some virtue signalling loons cheering this.

Hope turnpike throw the book at them.

Bobby Vylan of British duo Bob Vylan performs on the West Holts Stage

Police review footage of chants led by Glastonbury acts

The government condemned chants from rap duo Bob Vylan which were streamed live and called for "death" to the Israeli military.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c33514nryy1o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
TinklySnail · 29/06/2025 15:02

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 14:56

@Hadtodoanotherchange the UK public as a whole accountable for politicians whose views we may disagree with?? Absolutely not yet in my experience, Jews and Israelis are expected to accept that somehow just by existing we are the route of all evil and want every Palestinian dead. If we show any support for the only Jewish country in the world then we are no better than war mongering, baby killing mass murderers. You can fundamentally disagree with many aspects of a countries ruling party yet also be pro some aspects of their decision making. The 2 are not incompatible or binary.

The thing is though, very few people seem to be rationally critical when it comes to what Israel is doing.
I see very few people who “support” Israel who actually say they don’t support all actions. Many people on these threads seem to suggest Israel’s actions are justified and proportional.
It’s odd, because I just cannot fathom why. It’s fine to be critical of a government, it normal in a society to not agree with every single policy but why are more people with ties to Israel not outraged?
Why is the response so often to minimise the destruction the IDF has caused and scream Hamas Hamas Hamas rather than question has this gone too far? Is this justified? Are these measures appropriate?

Because Hamas are Islamic zealots and Islamic zealots are more of a threat to home turf than anything Jewish 🤷‍♀️

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 15:03

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:02

It’s funny you keep repeating things like “kneecap aren’t victims” at the same time showing you have no clue what society has been like for catholics in NI.
Ignorance isn’t an excuse.

Why is conflict in NI between Catholics and Protestants the fault of Israel?

They obviously do still have problems in NI but just because Kneecap are Irish that does not give them a "free card" to incite violence.

User135644 · 29/06/2025 15:05

Any venue still platforming these vile artists need boycotting.

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:07

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 15:03

Why is conflict in NI between Catholics and Protestants the fault of Israel?

They obviously do still have problems in NI but just because Kneecap are Irish that does not give them a "free card" to incite violence.

Edited

No one said it was the fault of Israel.

I’m simply debuting your comment which was denying the experiences of catholics in the UK and then minimising it because it only happened in NI.

From reading the thread it seems like you were the one to bring kneecap into it even though the topic wasn’t about them anyway and now you’re asking what they have to do with the conversation?

MissAndrey · 29/06/2025 15:07

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 14:48

The thread is getting sidetracked and drawn into wider political arguments from it's original purpose. The footage from Glastonbury has made me feel sick to my stomach.
I'm Jewish (have name changed again for obvious reasons) and can say that I don't feel safe to be visibly Jewish or even mention that I am Jewish in the UK. In fact I have a fundamental dread of what may be in store for British Jews. I am scared for the future and particularly my children's future. I am so relieved that so far none of them have wanted to go to Uni and pray that my youngest won't want to unless there is a fundamental shift in current behviours.
My daughter has been asked for her stance/views on Israel and Gov policy on a visit to a friends house by their parents, my sons have been abused for expressing support for our family in Israel.
So I question, do you judge ALL UK or British people by the decisions of the Government in power? Are the UK public as a whole accountable for politicians whose views we may disagree with?? Absolutely not yet in my experience, Jews and Israelis are expected to accept that somehow just by existing we are the route of all evil and want every Palestinian dead. If we show any support for the only Jewish country in the world then we are no better than war mongering, baby killing mass murderers. You can fundamentally disagree with many aspects of a countries ruling party yet also be pro some aspects of their decision making. The 2 are not incompatible or binary.
To hear 'popular' acts drawing in crowds and inciting the public to chant "death to the IDF" and "from the river etc" is chilling and terrifying. If the words had been changed to Death to the British Army, death to the west and such like, would people have sung along, cheering? I very much doubt it.
Whatever your views an army is there to protect their country. Literally their sworn duty.

Much feeling sorry for yourself about things that might happen, no feeling sorry for the tens of thousands of Palestinian children who have already been slaughtered.

Lindos1 · 29/06/2025 15:07

@Hadtodoanotherchange
I'm not Jewish but this is exactly what I feel.
I can see it happening around me in my own life.
I just keep thinking of Jewish teenagers at some secondary schools/ unis here in the UK; I can imagine it must be an isolating experience to say the least.
In my opinion I would feel extremely concerned if I were Jewish & had children in the UK (I'm really sorry to say).

NiMaithLiomDeLuain · 29/06/2025 15:08

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 14:55

@NiMaithLiomDeLuain was saying that people need to look beyond their own neighbourhoods for saying they are unaware of the Irish being oppressed in the UK.

Turns out it's a problem specific to Northern Ireland. They could have just said that rather than trying to make out the Irish experience oppression in the UK generally.

Again, Kneecap aren't victims.

Well yes NI is in the UK, generally.

Irish Catholics who live in a place where 'All Taigs will be crucified' is painted are not victims of death threats, they are 'little Irish lads being picked on'. Who exactly are the victims then? Would you be as dismissive of Jews who live in an area where 'death to Jews' was spray painted, insist that they aren't victims or do you keep that especially for Irish people in the UK?

ginasevern · 29/06/2025 15:08

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 15:03

Why is conflict in NI between Catholics and Protestants the fault of Israel?

They obviously do still have problems in NI but just because Kneecap are Irish that does not give them a "free card" to incite violence.

Edited

Because the Jews are to blame to everything and have been for the last 2 thousand years. That's why they've been hounded, persecuted and gassed.

Ohyoudodoyou · 29/06/2025 15:10

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 14:48

The thread is getting sidetracked and drawn into wider political arguments from it's original purpose. The footage from Glastonbury has made me feel sick to my stomach.
I'm Jewish (have name changed again for obvious reasons) and can say that I don't feel safe to be visibly Jewish or even mention that I am Jewish in the UK. In fact I have a fundamental dread of what may be in store for British Jews. I am scared for the future and particularly my children's future. I am so relieved that so far none of them have wanted to go to Uni and pray that my youngest won't want to unless there is a fundamental shift in current behviours.
My daughter has been asked for her stance/views on Israel and Gov policy on a visit to a friends house by their parents, my sons have been abused for expressing support for our family in Israel.
So I question, do you judge ALL UK or British people by the decisions of the Government in power? Are the UK public as a whole accountable for politicians whose views we may disagree with?? Absolutely not yet in my experience, Jews and Israelis are expected to accept that somehow just by existing we are the route of all evil and want every Palestinian dead. If we show any support for the only Jewish country in the world then we are no better than war mongering, baby killing mass murderers. You can fundamentally disagree with many aspects of a countries ruling party yet also be pro some aspects of their decision making. The 2 are not incompatible or binary.
To hear 'popular' acts drawing in crowds and inciting the public to chant "death to the IDF" and "from the river etc" is chilling and terrifying. If the words had been changed to Death to the British Army, death to the west and such like, would people have sung along, cheering? I very much doubt it.
Whatever your views an army is there to protect their country. Literally their sworn duty.

I am so angry at seeing responses on X and FB applauding kneecap and Vylan each time this happens it makes me even more certain this is anti-Jewish rhetoric. I’ve seen musicians I follow ) and they are older men ‘left’ leaning. I’ve just seen one man, someone who’s always calling other men ‘gammon’, threatening violence on in the streets of London if Vylan is arrested. These men are salivating over this, I’m a socialist and I’m bitterly disappointed in their views. I condemn the IDF soldiers putting names in bombs and I condem Hamas for putting their HQ and weapons in civilian settings. I am sickened to think people I like and have admired have become so rabid over the Middle East that they will allow a culture to flourish where women and children (and men) have become too scared to say they are Jewish in the UK. We were a better country than this.

EasternStandard · 29/06/2025 15:10

Mintsj · 29/06/2025 14:56

Hamas, a terrorist group funded by Iran. Some of the scariest fucks in the entire world. But let’s wear the flag and chant about them like they are the good guys?

I don’t want Palestinian civilians starved or killed. But let’s not pretend that Palestine is the land of milk and honey governed by Jesus. Iran and Hamas are not our friends. Again, I want Israel to stop what they’re starving and killing. I just don’t want to get into bed with terrorists and Iran in the process.

Absolutely. And agree with @ginasevern

2024onwardsandup · 29/06/2025 15:11

Pleaseshutthefuckup · 29/06/2025 15:02

And this is what is really the most concerning.

I now can't debate the subject with people I know because of this simplicity of fucking mind. It is prevalent.

They’re also the same dickheads who lined J K Rowling up with Putin and Musk. Morons the lot of them.

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 15:11

@Zombiefluff I don't think it was your intention but you are literally making my point for me!
Why should I as a British Jew have to be accountable for Netanyahu et al? Why do I have to endorse or condemn resolutely?tTo conflate being Jewish with being responsible for all Israel Gov actions is just another veiled form of anti semitism now widely countenance as anti zionist views!
I do not know what religion or political persuasion you may or may not hold but I wouldn't expect you to stand-by, explain or answer for all the decisions of whatever governing or religious majority of the country you live in!

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 15:13

MissAndrey · 29/06/2025 15:07

Much feeling sorry for yourself about things that might happen, no feeling sorry for the tens of thousands of Palestinian children who have already been slaughtered.

and hear you are putting words in my mouth? Have you bothered to ask? At any point in my post did I say I don't feel sorry for Palestinian people?? I can hold more than one belief at the same time. I wish the same could be said for so many others commenting!!

MissAndrey · 29/06/2025 15:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 15:14

NiMaithLiomDeLuain · 29/06/2025 15:08

Well yes NI is in the UK, generally.

Irish Catholics who live in a place where 'All Taigs will be crucified' is painted are not victims of death threats, they are 'little Irish lads being picked on'. Who exactly are the victims then? Would you be as dismissive of Jews who live in an area where 'death to Jews' was spray painted, insist that they aren't victims or do you keep that especially for Irish people in the UK?

It's a very specific part of the UK and I think you were being disingenuous to allow people to think you were referring to the UK generally.

You can keep repeating yourself forever but Kneecap aren't the victims in this scenario. Just because they came from a troubled area does not absolve them of any responsibility.

They aren't even claiming victimhood for themselves, you are!

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:16

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 15:11

@Zombiefluff I don't think it was your intention but you are literally making my point for me!
Why should I as a British Jew have to be accountable for Netanyahu et al? Why do I have to endorse or condemn resolutely?tTo conflate being Jewish with being responsible for all Israel Gov actions is just another veiled form of anti semitism now widely countenance as anti zionist views!
I do not know what religion or political persuasion you may or may not hold but I wouldn't expect you to stand-by, explain or answer for all the decisions of whatever governing or religious majority of the country you live in!

Why should I as a British Jew have to be accountable for Netanyahu et al?

Where did I say you were responsible?
Or even suggest it?

I do think people who claim support for Israel while showing no criticism for the actions of the IDF are responsible though.

To conflate being Jewish with being responsible for all Israel Gov actions is just another veiled form of anti semitism

I haven’t done that.

SharonEllis · 29/06/2025 15:16

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 14:56

@Hadtodoanotherchange the UK public as a whole accountable for politicians whose views we may disagree with?? Absolutely not yet in my experience, Jews and Israelis are expected to accept that somehow just by existing we are the route of all evil and want every Palestinian dead. If we show any support for the only Jewish country in the world then we are no better than war mongering, baby killing mass murderers. You can fundamentally disagree with many aspects of a countries ruling party yet also be pro some aspects of their decision making. The 2 are not incompatible or binary.

The thing is though, very few people seem to be rationally critical when it comes to what Israel is doing.
I see very few people who “support” Israel who actually say they don’t support all actions. Many people on these threads seem to suggest Israel’s actions are justified and proportional.
It’s odd, because I just cannot fathom why. It’s fine to be critical of a government, it normal in a society to not agree with every single policy but why are more people with ties to Israel not outraged?
Why is the response so often to minimise the destruction the IDF has caused and scream Hamas Hamas Hamas rather than question has this gone too far? Is this justified? Are these measures appropriate?

I have no idea how you can say this. Loads of us who are broadly pro Israel are very critical of the Israeli government in various ways and say so often enough But there is very little space for a discussion in good faith because we just spend so much time correcting egregious lies, hyperbole and propaganda and pushing back on open and thinly disguised racism. If someone istalking BS I can criticise it. I don't have to accompany it with chapter and verse on my views of Netanyahu to make my criticism or correction valid. What is hilarious is when people claim to know what I think because I have expressed some support for Israel against the genocidal cult that is trying to destroy it.

SharonEllis · 29/06/2025 15:17

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:16

Why should I as a British Jew have to be accountable for Netanyahu et al?

Where did I say you were responsible?
Or even suggest it?

I do think people who claim support for Israel while showing no criticism for the actions of the IDF are responsible though.

To conflate being Jewish with being responsible for all Israel Gov actions is just another veiled form of anti semitism

I haven’t done that.

I do think people who claim support for Israel while showing no criticism for the actions of the IDF are responsible though.

Responsible for what exactly?

SharonEllis · 29/06/2025 15:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This is just open racism.

Hadtodoanotherchange · 29/06/2025 15:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

damned if we do and damned if we don't! 🤷🏻‍♀️
I wouldn't dream of telling a Black person that what they are experiencing isn't racist if they told me it was but as a British Jew, I'm told that if I say something is antisemitic I'm conflating it with anti zionism automatically

quantumbutterfly · 29/06/2025 15:20

Pleaseshutthefuckup · 29/06/2025 15:02

And this is what is really the most concerning.

I now can't debate the subject with people I know because of this simplicity of fucking mind. It is prevalent.

A lot of forced teaming and exploitation of other grievance is going on, it's sinister and familiar.

NiMaithLiomDeLuain · 29/06/2025 15:20

Twiglets1 · 29/06/2025 15:14

It's a very specific part of the UK and I think you were being disingenuous to allow people to think you were referring to the UK generally.

You can keep repeating yourself forever but Kneecap aren't the victims in this scenario. Just because they came from a troubled area does not absolve them of any responsibility.

They aren't even claiming victimhood for themselves, you are!

Yeah a very specific part that the rest of the UK doesn't give a shit about. A part where 'All Taigs will be crucified' is a common refrain but gets no headlines, no comment from Starmer whose schedule is so empty he can comment on a music festivals line up, no empathy for those victims, in fact they aren't even seen as victims at all while the same people howl with indignation about 'death' to a foreign military. So much for looking after UK citizens first, it's fucked up that people care more about Israels military than they do their own people.

The Met have absolved them of all responsibility, they are not charged with anything.

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:20

SharonEllis · 29/06/2025 15:17

I do think people who claim support for Israel while showing no criticism for the actions of the IDF are responsible though.

Responsible for what exactly?

For what actions of who they support.

Zombiefluff · 29/06/2025 15:24

SharonEllis · 29/06/2025 15:19

This is just open racism.

It’s quite literally nothing like racism.

It’s just reality that if you constantly tell people that being critical of the actions of the Israeli state is antisemitism they will assume you are saying the Israeli state speaks for all Jewish people.
Otherwise how can criticising the actions of a state be deemed as antisemitic?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread