Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

How the hell did the Israeli's mange to cause the exploding pagers?

1000 replies

mids2019 · 17/09/2024 18:11

Just this is really ...how did they do it? Was this the secret service on steroids?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
amigafan2003 · 19/09/2024 13:12

EasterIssland · 19/09/2024 12:51

It’s an unsafe world for anyone. If governments start tampering devices to explode them without being in control where that device is and who is in possession of it … then we are in a really unsafe world as next time it could be mobile phones that are meant to be for another terrorist group but by mistake it ended up in innocent citizens hands.

Do you think that if Mossad had evidence that the pagers had ended up in a significant number of civilian hands that they would have still detonated them?

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:13

HelenHen · 19/09/2024 12:55

Who decides who the terrorist is?

The UK government clearly sets out its criteria in the link you have been directed to.

YoYoYoYo12345 · 19/09/2024 13:14

amigafan2003 · 19/09/2024 13:11

The international community - 26 countries in this case.

Fortunately the 26 member international community and not you @helen.....

YoYoYoYo12345 · 19/09/2024 13:17

This might help you Helen....

"The European Union designated Hizballah's military wing as a terrorist organization on 22 July 2013, following the March conviction that year of a Hizballah member in Cyprus, the July 2012 bus bombing in Bulgaria, and the group's intervention in Syria."

Hezbollah have operated for a long time causing death and destruction in various places.

HelenHen · 19/09/2024 13:17

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:05

The state of Israel is not illegal and the Israeli people are not illegal. I am not talking about illegal settlements in the WB.

Edited

Sorry, yes. I misread to think you were talking about the illegal settlers. I was not referring to Israel as a settlement and I definitely do not want my words to be read as that because it is not my belief. Sorry

HelenHen · 19/09/2024 13:18

amigafan2003 · 19/09/2024 13:12

Do you think that if Mossad had evidence that the pagers had ended up in a significant number of civilian hands that they would have still detonated them?

Edited

I believe they would, yes.

YoYoYoYo12345 · 19/09/2024 13:21

HelenHen · 19/09/2024 13:18

I believe they would, yes.

However, the intelligence out there shows that hezbollah members use them as a method of communication to avoid detection! They could use mobiles for communication of their terrorist activities but they chose pagers. Very few people actually use pagers anymore. The ones that went off stopped being manufactured over 10 years ago showing the market has declined drastically.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/09/2024 13:31

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:05

The state of Israel is not illegal and the Israeli people are not illegal. I am not talking about illegal settlements in the WB.

Edited

I am not talking about illegal settlements in the WB

Aren’t people who mention ‘settlers’ generally referring to those in the WB, or else to those Israelis who have extremist views and believe all the land is theirs?

Settlements and certain settlers on the WB are affecting how Israel is perceived for the worse, imo. As are certain ministers encouraging what appears to be lawlessness there.

When I think of ‘illegal settlements’ it is in
reference to those in the West Bank considered illegal under international law; and also referring to settlers who bully and harass Palestinians in the West Bank to get them off their land ( or, for example, go and poison their sheep or burn down their house or car, or kill them.)

Example of “illegal settlements” from Haaretz:

July

^Israel Erected 25 New Illegal Outposts in West Bank Since Gaza War Started
A new report from NGO Peace Now analyzes various actions by the Israeli government directed at deepening the annexation process, like advancing approvals for 8,721 new housing units and classifying about 9.3 square miles as state land^

Since the start of the war in Gaza, 25 illegal outposts have been erected throughout the West Bank, and the Israeli government has advanced approvals for of 8,721 new housing units, according to a new report from NGO Peace Now.

….

August

'They Came to Kill': After Israeli Settler Attack on Palestinian Village, Locals Fear There's No One to Save Them

Residents of the West Bank village of Jit, where Israeli settlers killed a 23-year-old man Thursday, say the onslaught was a well-planned attack that they worry will happen again

The quiet in the northern West Bank village of Jit was broken at around 7 P.M. Thursday. According to villagers, about a hundred masked people in black shirts approached from nearby settlements carrying M16 rifles, handguns, bars and stones. The terrified villagers barricaded themselves in their homes.

America Is Coming for Israel's Far-right Ministers Who Hail Settler Violence

The longer settler violence continues unabated, the graver the consequences will be, and the more justified international leaders appear in taking their own punitive measures

EasterIssland · 19/09/2024 13:31

amigafan2003 · 19/09/2024 13:12

Do you think that if Mossad had evidence that the pagers had ended up in a significant number of civilian hands that they would have still detonated them?

Edited

No idea as that’s not the case. But the geneva convention says that you can’t detonate them unless you’re 100% sure who has got them, same thing with the walkie talkies.

ThisOldThang · 19/09/2024 13:31

YoYoYoYo12345 · 19/09/2024 13:21

However, the intelligence out there shows that hezbollah members use them as a method of communication to avoid detection! They could use mobiles for communication of their terrorist activities but they chose pagers. Very few people actually use pagers anymore. The ones that went off stopped being manufactured over 10 years ago showing the market has declined drastically.

I think you may have confused two stories. The two-way radios were manufactured in Japan, but they haven't been produced for 10 years. The pagers are still manufactured in Taiwan.

Cillianlikegillian · 19/09/2024 13:33

1dayatatime · 19/09/2024 12:58

@Cillianlikegillian

"It's the others who are being destroyed that people have huge problems with - the children and the other innocent victims.

It's not ok to say, well this is all Hamas' fault, as Israel's bombs are dropped on families. Yes it is their fault but it's Israel's too then.

It's an impossible situation, I do know that, but to say people object to Israel dealing with terrorists is a disingenuous take on this. That's not the objection."

I agree with you but hasn't this been the same in every war or terrorism throughout history?

Either from one end of the spectrum of getting caught in the crossfire of a firefight or to the other of the spectrum being a civilian the bombing of Hiroshima. In every conflict there will be civilian casualties on the other side and whilst efforts are made to reduce them they will inevitably occur.

Taking Japan as an example the war was against the Japanese Government but it would have been impossible to win if any military action that could cause civilian casualties was forbidden.

@1dayatatime
The killing of thousands upon thousands of children is unjustifiable.

Hiroshima is mostly seen as a war crime today.

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:40

ScrollingLeaves · 19/09/2024 13:31

I am not talking about illegal settlements in the WB

Aren’t people who mention ‘settlers’ generally referring to those in the WB, or else to those Israelis who have extremist views and believe all the land is theirs?

Settlements and certain settlers on the WB are affecting how Israel is perceived for the worse, imo. As are certain ministers encouraging what appears to be lawlessness there.

When I think of ‘illegal settlements’ it is in
reference to those in the West Bank considered illegal under international law; and also referring to settlers who bully and harass Palestinians in the West Bank to get them off their land ( or, for example, go and poison their sheep or burn down their house or car, or kill them.)

Example of “illegal settlements” from Haaretz:

July

^Israel Erected 25 New Illegal Outposts in West Bank Since Gaza War Started
A new report from NGO Peace Now analyzes various actions by the Israeli government directed at deepening the annexation process, like advancing approvals for 8,721 new housing units and classifying about 9.3 square miles as state land^

Since the start of the war in Gaza, 25 illegal outposts have been erected throughout the West Bank, and the Israeli government has advanced approvals for of 8,721 new housing units, according to a new report from NGO Peace Now.

….

August

'They Came to Kill': After Israeli Settler Attack on Palestinian Village, Locals Fear There's No One to Save Them

Residents of the West Bank village of Jit, where Israeli settlers killed a 23-year-old man Thursday, say the onslaught was a well-planned attack that they worry will happen again

The quiet in the northern West Bank village of Jit was broken at around 7 P.M. Thursday. According to villagers, about a hundred masked people in black shirts approached from nearby settlements carrying M16 rifles, handguns, bars and stones. The terrified villagers barricaded themselves in their homes.

America Is Coming for Israel's Far-right Ministers Who Hail Settler Violence

The longer settler violence continues unabated, the graver the consequences will be, and the more justified international leaders appear in taking their own punitive measures

Not when they refer to the founding of the state of Israel.

Auvergne63 · 19/09/2024 13:50

DuskyBlueDepartingLight · 19/09/2024 12:55

@Auvergne63

So you've declined to say how the Nazis were defeated.

You're not the only person with links to the WWs. I'm not really sure why you think this makes you an authority?

Most MN users will have studied the WWs at school (as a minimum). Again, I'm not really sure why you think this makes you an authority?

Your 'eye for an eye dig' was directly misquoting Judaism & demonstrates your lack of knowledge about Judaism. You're not the only person on this thread to have done this.

Secondary school RE is not particularly advanced. I'd imagine that you don't routinely tell people of the other faiths you cited that you know best?

No nasty undertones, just highlighting the constant campaign of misinformation, demonization & delegitimisation of Israel on CITME. Not to mention the frequently deleted hate speech against Jews.

Anti Zionism is antisemitism. None so blind as those that will not see.

Interesting that no one has responded to the question above in good faith.

Would love to hear your thoughts?

Read my post again. You are deliberately misunderstanding what I wrote.
You also assume a lot about me. Who said I studied or taught in the UK ?
Eye for an eye is found in all Abrahamic faiths. So no, I wasn't misquoting it. I didn't quote all of it; that's it.
I also find you accusatory tone unwelcome to say the least.

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 13:52

HelenHen · 19/09/2024 12:41

I see a lot of baseless allegations here. If you have specific examples of antisemitism on this thread, or of people celebrating Jewish deaths or wanting to destroy Israel, please report these posts. They are very serious allegations and must be reported... mumsnet will delete them.

As for berets question... it is nonsensical because it demands the reader to accept that Israel is the good guy and all others are terrorists. That in itself is the whole debate on this board. To demand that people ignore the lies in the post and the reality of the situation... well that is why people aren't answering and will not answer. The 'question' is entirely one sided and repeatedly refers to 'little collateral damage', which is just inflammatory and deserves no response.

Exactly. The question completely ignores the ongoing occupation and terrorisation of Palestinians and the theft and destruction of Palestinian land and infrastructure. If a person wants a question answered in good faith then the question should be asked in good faith. This one was not.

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:59

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 13:52

Exactly. The question completely ignores the ongoing occupation and terrorisation of Palestinians and the theft and destruction of Palestinian land and infrastructure. If a person wants a question answered in good faith then the question should be asked in good faith. This one was not.

And yet the question was thoughtfully written & legitimate, and you refuse to answer it. OK.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2024 14:01

@Cillianlikegillian

"The killing of thousands upon thousands of children is unjustifiable.

Hiroshima is mostly seen as a war crime today."

I agree that the killing of even one innocent child in any conflict is abhorrent but the combatants on either side will always end up describing it as regrettable and unfortunate collateral damage in order to kill combatants on the other side.

For example if one side destroyed an opposing army of say 2000 soldiers but one innocent child is killed then can that ever be justified.

As for the bombing of Hiroshima being described as a war crime then that would pretty much make any military action taken anywhere where civilian casualties occurred in pretty much every conflict in history a war crime.

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 14:02

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 13:59

And yet the question was thoughtfully written & legitimate, and you refuse to answer it. OK.

I don't think it was legitimate. If the poster wants to frame it in a most balanced way I'm sure people will take the time to answer it.

justasking111 · 19/09/2024 14:04

I wonder what the pager team have thought up next?

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 14:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

1dayatatime · 19/09/2024 14:08

justasking111 · 19/09/2024 14:04

I wonder what the pager team have thought up next?

No idea but I certainly wouldn't want to be working in the IT department of Hezbollah right now and their helpline will certainly be experiencing "higher than average call times ".

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 14:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a ridiculous and offensive accusation. This has nothing to do with the religion of the person writing it, it's to do with their framing of the Israeli/Palestinian situation.

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 14:17

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 14:11

What a ridiculous and offensive accusation. This has nothing to do with the religion of the person writing it, it's to do with their framing of the Israeli/Palestinian situation.

Their framing came from their position as a Jewish person. Its concerning that you consider that grounds for dismissing their question.

Lalaloveya · 19/09/2024 14:24

SharonEllis · 19/09/2024 14:17

Their framing came from their position as a Jewish person. Its concerning that you consider that grounds for dismissing their question.

If they ever want to acknowledge the wrongs perpetuated by Israel against Palestine and Palestinians, and have a balanced discussion about it the situation, I look forward to it.

Given your disgusting accusations against me I'm not going to continue this with you. Cheerio.

Cillianlikegillian · 19/09/2024 14:29

1dayatatime · 19/09/2024 14:01

@Cillianlikegillian

"The killing of thousands upon thousands of children is unjustifiable.

Hiroshima is mostly seen as a war crime today."

I agree that the killing of even one innocent child in any conflict is abhorrent but the combatants on either side will always end up describing it as regrettable and unfortunate collateral damage in order to kill combatants on the other side.

For example if one side destroyed an opposing army of say 2000 soldiers but one innocent child is killed then can that ever be justified.

As for the bombing of Hiroshima being described as a war crime then that would pretty much make any military action taken anywhere where civilian casualties occurred in pretty much every conflict in history a war crime.

It just sounds like you are trying to justify the unjustifiable @1dayatatime.

YoYoYoYo12345 · 19/09/2024 14:36

Cillianlikegillian · 19/09/2024 13:33

@1dayatatime
The killing of thousands upon thousands of children is unjustifiable.

Hiroshima is mostly seen as a war crime today.

Thanks Hirosima meant that the Japanese stopped fighting. How many more would have died if the war with Japan went on longer.

My dad's uncle was a Japanese prisoner of war. War is awful, however, no one should just not fight back.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread