FrenchFleurs Wed 23-Oct-13 07:01:06
It is YOUR ignorance that makes it apparent that you know nothing about tokophobia. If however you do happen to have this phobia, then please do let us know.
You make the assumption that everyone fear is the same and everyone fears the same things and they deal with it the same way.
I have read what Starlight has put and what she fears, many many times. I don't doubt that she has a genuine fear, genuine reason to fear nor do I doubt that she probably has tokophobic. Her fear is different to a lot of others, but it is still very obvious to me that her appalling experiences have caused her an enormous about of distress and had a lasting impact.
I do not always agree with her opinions on how to deal with fear, but I absolutely think she has a very important contribution to express which gives a perspective which is highly valuable and differs from what others express.
I did not for a second read starlights comment as suggesting women should not have a epidural. Indeed, if you read what she said, what she actually said was that planning your birth on having an epidural and then being denied that could cause PTSD. Exactly what you said. But you've jumped all over her unfairly.
She suggested various coping strategies, not just a reliance on pain relief and actually thats fair point.
You are projecting your own fears on to others, and that does help you or them. You have to listen to others, and what their fears are to understand and help each and every person as an individual. There is no 'right' way. There is definitely a wrong one though and that is to fail to listen.
I personally think that fear of childbirth is a deeply personal thing and manifests itself in completely different ways in different women. They are no 'better' or 'worse' than another. Just different. We all have different strategies on how to cope with that; what works for one person might not work in another. I am convinced that everyone woman's fear is incredibly unique and their triggers can range dramatically.
It is extremely foolish to disregard the idea of mind over matter when it comes to medicine. If you look at scientific research into drugs and the placebo effect, a placebo can be incredibly significant and massively beneficial. If hypnobirthing and breathing works for some; and it does seem to, why dismiss it? It might not be for you, but it doesn't mean it doesn't have value.