Please or to access all these features

Cancer

Find advice & support if you or someone you know has been diagnosed with cancer

Consultant putting Mum off investigations

67 replies

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 08:00

Is this usual?

Mum had a positive FIT test and referral to a gastro consultant.

He wasnt particularly nice anyway and was pretty blunt. He said about investigations but then asked if there was any point, as if it is cancer she isnt fit for surgery anyway due to other issues.

We said well theres pros and cons of knowing at least.

Then he started going on about how aggressive and risky colonoscopies are, how aggressive the prep is. She could end up with a stoma, internal bleeding, the prep is awful and she'd struggle etc.

She ended up opting for a virtual CT colonoscopy in the end which he wasnt happy about. Again asked what the point would be, if theres poo in the way it wouldnt show anything. I said surely some prep is given for that and he said no.

It genuinely felt like a "well youre old, if its cancer we wont do anything so why waste time" 😔

OP posts:
SootylovesSue · 12/11/2026 08:01

How old is your mum and how frail is she?

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 08:02

What are the conditions that stop her having surgery?

SpamIAm · 12/11/2026 08:05

If they aren’t able to treat then it seems reasonable to point out that the potential harm caused by investigations will be for no benefit.

Iknownotreasonable · 12/11/2026 08:05

If she has other issues that make treatment impossible, then he's just trying to save her going through invasive investigations that won't physically benefit her and have their own risks. As you say, though, the psychological benefits of knowing one way or the other are also important.

SootylovesSue · 12/11/2026 08:05

Can see why they might not want to do a colonoscopy (prep and procedure are tough going), but I don't think a CT colonoscopy is unreasonable. Even if your is mum not fit for surgery or chemo at least you would know cause which would help with symptom management/planning IF a cancer was found.

Dearg · 12/11/2026 08:10

He sounds as if he has a terrible bedside manner.

I agree with the pp, that a CT scan is a good option , if your mum is not robust enough for the prep .

My own mum did have the prep and colonoscopy, and she actually never recovered from that. It is absolutely brutal, and more so if your mum, like mine, has any mobility issues whereby she struggles to run to the wc.

But , ultimately, if the consultant feels he is unable to treat, he may also feel the need to use his resources for cases where he can treat.

pinkdelight · 12/11/2026 08:12

It'd be significant to know how old she is. My dad was 82 and didn't want any investigations when he was in a similar situation. My aunt was the same. Some doctors go the other way and do procedures on people who then spend their last days in suffering that could have been avoided. Your mother has made her choice and hopefully the colonoscopy will be worth it to her for the knowledge, if it reveals something. But they can be grim even when younger/in better health, so he's right to set out the risks. Sounds like his bedside manner was sorely lacking, which definitely doesn't help. I hope it goes as well as possible.

CrustyBread1977 · 12/11/2026 08:15

My mum’s consultant suggested all manner of treatment which, with hindsight, was pointless. She endured rounds of chemo and the side effects, and only later did we learn that her type of cancer doesn’t respond well to chemo.

The last year of her life was stressful and miserable. If we had the time over again I would encourage her to refuse high-risk invasive treatment.

It’s so hard to know what to do in the moment. Maybe get a second opinion? Mum’s consultant was overly optimistic; it sounds like yours is the opposite - is there a middle ground?

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 08:18

As someone whose elderly mother got complications after a colonoscopy (don't want to be more specific or put anyone else off getting one), I think the consultant raised some valid points if your mum is not well enough for surgery if they discovered something. My mother was in the same position and I regret her having a colonoscopy and wish I spoke up about - what's the point?

Sounds like the consultant needs to work on his people skills, but the main message he was saying shouldn't be discarded because he was too blunt in his delivery.

Edited to add: my mum did end up with a stoma. This isn't normal, it was as a result of complications but still - it is always worth thinking about will an invasive procedure actually benefit the patient when weighing up potential risk versus benefits.

stackhead · 12/11/2026 08:34

Its hard to separate your personal feelings from this as shes your mum, but really sometimes it should be the case for "whats the point".

Is it necessary to subject the individual to invasive and potential harmful investigations - to what end.

Watching my own elderly relatives go through their own investigations I do quite often wonder myself.

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:00

Shes 74, not massively frail as such but does have mobility issues. She has circulation problems but no serious conditions, shes not taking umpteen meds a day type thing just some blood pressure meds and painkillers.

I think for us the point of the investigation would be to get an answer so she can either be relieved, or pragmatic about it. And the rather jarring point about wasting resources on her is a bit irrelevant at this stage given they dont know what resources she'll need, which investigations would help shed light on.

I have heard the prep is brutal, have also heard people say its nowhere near as bad as people make out. Young and elderly. My FIL has had it at least 4 times and he has heart and kidney failure and about 2 sheets of A4 of conditions (I wonder what the difference could possibly be between them 🙄)

re: personal feelings - its my mum that would want to know what shes dealing with, or not.

It just felt really off. Especially now I have done a bit of research and have seen prep/colonoscopies, while harsher on older people, are still generally low risk.

He got quite angry with me at one point when I was asking for clear reasons for why he was so against investigations IF she is actually fit for those - and he didnt refute this - he just kept saying whats the point and wasnt listening when she told him why.

OP posts:
LovelaceBiggWither · 12/11/2026 09:03

My DH is 73 and routinely has colonoscopies because of a family history of bowel cancer. He's on more meds than your mum too. The prep is less brutal than it used to be. I'd be asking for a second opinion.

Freemefromic · 12/11/2026 09:08

This is totally unacceptable. Contact PALS and tell them exactly what happened at that appointment. Tell them your mum wants to see a different consultant.

Do not be fobbed off.

Longtermmuser · 12/11/2026 09:08

I would ask for a 2nd opinion OP. That is shocking. I thought you were going to say she was 90 with serious health conditions.

Purplecatshopaholic · 12/11/2026 09:18

Hmm, his manner could do with improving! I think a second opinion is what’s needed here, so you can make informed choices. I don’t disagree necessarily with what he’s saying, but how he says it could be better - his arrogance seems to be driving his approach, and frankly it’s up to your mum what she is willing to put herself through, not up to him to play god..

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:19

The other thing that doesn't sit right is I suggested maybe we could go away and have a chat about which investigations, if any etc. and get back to him that day. He asked "but why"

I said just to get her head around it all in a different setting than a 15 min appointment, and he smirked and said but why again. So she felt pressured 😔

He said that a lot.... "but....why?" he actually shushed me at one point for just asking if he could tell her what the specific risks were. Knob 🙄

Ill call her later and see if she wants another opinion.

OP posts:
Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:27

I didn't say something possibly relevant, this was a routine fit test. She's had no symptoms at all. He went through a list and the only one she has occasionally is constipation, but i know she doesn't drink as much as she should regularly. So i know there is actually high chance its nothing very serious so i suppose to give him some credit he might be thinking along those lines. It would have helped if he actually said that though.

That was another odd thing though, she said is it worth just doing another fit in a couple of months maybe as a starting point in case its piles or whatever. "But why?"

OP posts:
Freemefromic · 12/11/2026 09:36

Honestly @Peevedoff , you definitely need to speak to PALS about this consultation.

OrlandointheWilderness · 12/11/2026 09:40

Tbh on your first post I was thinking maybe if she is frail and elderly he had logic, a shit bedside manner but logic. Then I saw your update - your mum isn’t particularly elderly and with no significant health issues!! I’d ask for a second opinion and log this with PALS.

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:42

Appreciate all messages theyre all helpful and I agree with parts of every one, but especially the ones saying this sounds off. I thought it was just me being sensitive.

His bedside mamner was atrocious but I get they have to disconnect, tbf thats not whats bothered me, there was a definite underlying tone of "youre old, why bother"

OP posts:
Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:44

Although being shushed pissed me right off. Anyone who knows me IRL knows I DO NOt tolerate being shushed 😂 he put his finger on his lip ffs 😂 got to laugh

OP posts:
Restlessdreams1994 · 12/11/2026 09:45

You are right that some people will find the prep and the procedure pretty brutal and/or have complications while others will sail through. The problem is, nobody knows in advance where on this spectrum your mum will be. It’s always a roll of the dice.

I think having the CT and a repeat FIT is a reasonable option. If both are normal and she’s not having any other symptoms then she’s most likely avoided an unnecessary colonoscopy.

coralneon · 12/11/2026 09:48

Another one who thought you were going to say 90 and incredibly frail and elderly. 74 is not even old these days ! I would be complaining that’s terrible ! Can she have pill cam ? I’ve had that for my Crohn’s disease.

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 10:10

Okay, he has an appalling bedside manner

Bearing in mind, and going through the weird psychological loops you have to go through with these situations… I wonder if he was trying to spare your mum the unpleasantness of the colonoscopy, and I wonder if he’s also one of these people who knows how much unnecessary nonsense happens in these situations… obviously he’s not allowed to say that.

A CT scan will show if there’s any polyp and that’s the likeliest cause… isn’t it?
We’ve been round the houses with mum on this several times. She now absolutely refuses to have any colonoscopies. Although given her age, they would probably do an enema and everything under sedation now. I actually asked her to go private and do that last time. I told her I’d pay for it if I had to. She was over 80 at that time, though.

Anyway, doctors are far too quick to do colonoscopies I think he’s actually done a favour by going for the CT scan first. But he hasn’t explained why. It’s possible that he’s not really supposed to do that favour.

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 10:17

I read an interesting article recently that resonated with me.

Although it's about aggressive cancer treatment which may well not be relevant to OP's mum, I thought it also had implications re weighing up horrible treatments that old people undergo and whether it actually is "worth it" if they are frail anyway. Every case will be different, of course.

‘Cancer treatment killed my mum’ — by a top oncologist
Chemotherapy, radiotherapy and surgery left Dr James Wilson’s mother, a retired nurse, frail and housebound before her death. Radical cancer care isn’t right for everyone, he says. Now his views have gone viral

www.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/aggressive-cancer-treatment-killed-my-mum-xdch9wdx0