Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Why "choose" to bottle feed???

732 replies

Difers · 13/07/2007 21:08

I am a breastfeeding mum and I meet lots of mums who said they tried to breastfeed but weren't able to which I can totally understand but My mother-in-law said she "chose" to bottlefeed and didn't bother even trying...

So I am wondering, given the benefits of breastfeeding, why would anyone "choose" to bottlefeed??

OP posts:
MotherFunk · 14/07/2007 16:16

Message withdrawn

fannyannie · 14/07/2007 16:18

if we want some more "anecdotal" evidence I was bf my older brother ff. I'm a short ar*e who catches everything going (think I stopped growing when I was about 11yrs old - up until then I'd been one of the tallest in my year at school ), he's 6ft 2 and hardly ever ill.

Oh and DS3 who was exclusively BF for 3 weeks, and now had 4 weeks of mixfeeding has just got his first stinking cold

tiktok · 14/07/2007 16:35

23balloons - the link I sent you was to a page full of academic papers from peer reviewed journals, mostly written by doctors or other expert researchers. The disclaimer you see is a US cover-your-backside thing for the whole website, to prevent them from being sued by someone.

CHOCOLATEPEANUT · 14/07/2007 16:44

By the time I had dd (36) most of my faimily and friends had all had babies and I watched them and and it kinda helped me make up my mind (half of them BF and half bottlefed)

As it was I had a terrible pregnancy and by the time she was born felt my body had nothing to give.

For me I needed to know that she was getting enough milk and that she would be settled and contented and get into a good sleeping routine.She did and at nearly 4 shes never been ill (though I appreciate theres time yet) but I have not seen any negatives.

BTW my sister and I both had the bottle. She had all the childhood illnesses and I had none.

tiktok · 14/07/2007 16:44

MotherFunk, you ask: "And if your baby is losing weight due to not getting enough breastmilk, surely you would agree that it is in the best interests to switch to bottle, regardless of how society views you?"

A further option would be to ensure the baby gets more breastmilk, surely....switching to formula is not the sole option.

Many women switch to formula in this situation, and are very sad and disappointed - regardless of what other people think of them (often, other people are urging them to switch to formula anyway). They are unaware - as you seem to be, too - that it is possible to fix the breastfeeding so the baby gains weight and thrives, with either no formula at all, or else only some formula given temporarily.

MotherFunk · 14/07/2007 16:51

Message withdrawn

beansontoast · 14/07/2007 16:57

may be...in answer to the OP...it's because there appears to be 'very little in it' to the average jo on the street.

so for that reason people think about what type of feeding would most suit their lives,choices,preferences,sensibilitues,experiences etc...and make their decision based on that.

oxocube · 14/07/2007 17:00

My SIL is expecting her first baby and has already decided to bottle feed. She finds the idea of breast feeding horrible, has just finished paying for her boob job and doesn't want to spoil them and wants absolute routine for her dd. I'm opposite and hauled my tits out on any occassion, am still co-sleeping with a 5 year old and wish my boobs were nice and gravity defying like hers! We are both nice people -neither of us is right or wrong, just different

tiktok · 14/07/2007 17:09

I don't think anyone should put a baby in danger, no, whatever society's views are. What sort of person do you think I am?

A mother and baby in a situation where the baby is in danger need a lot of support and help. It may be possible to salvage the breastfeeding, and if this is what a mother wants to do, then she can do - with the baby being fed in the meantime, of course.

Stress does not stop a mother producing milk, by the way.

milkmummy1 · 14/07/2007 17:21

Never worried about feeding in front of people, i BF everwhere i go. i do it very discreetly though, using a blanket over my boobie bits and tucked around DS.

My friends and family have mostly been v supportive towards my choice of feeding, though it does irritate me when some people (often my friends partners) leave the room when you start BF, as though you are doing something unusual. think they are just embarassed.

Annoys me also when some people look at me strangely when i say i am BF. think some are just not comfortable by the idea because of the whole sexual association thing, an attitude which really needs to change in this country.

I think what happens a lot is that people give up BF during the first few weeks when it is v v hard and you get no sleep, sore boobs etc. But if you can get through that stage you suddenly realise how convinient BF actually is, not to mention the health benefits. i think some of my friends whose babies are on formula are now wishing they perservered a bit longer. but as i say its not easy at the start or maybe i was just lucky that it got easier when it did.

has anyone noticed how hungry they get when BF? does it ever calm down? my appetite is huge at the mo and i am still loosing weight.

Going to have a slice of cheesecake now.

JoolsToo · 14/07/2007 17:22

"Why "choose" to bottle feed???"

er, cos I didn't want to breastfeed

that do?

MotherFunk · 14/07/2007 17:26

Message withdrawn

allgonebellyup · 14/07/2007 17:30

EscapeFrom -

you say you were 22 and had never seen anyone breastfeed or held a newborn..

i was 19 when i had dd, had never seen anyone breastfeed and also never had held a newborn/any baby before!

Also had NO family support and my partner used to pretend to puke when he saw me BF her.

  • BUT i still breastfed dd til she was 20mths as i knew her needs came before mine and i wanted her to have the best start in life, (and 7 yrs later shes attaining the highest possible grades in her year and doing amazingly well.)
allgonebellyup · 14/07/2007 17:32

i have a friend who also just had a boob job and wouldnt want to ruin her body by breast feeding.

what the fuck are boobs for then, if not for feeding children? THATS WHY WE HAVE BREASTS.

lilQuidditchKel · 14/07/2007 17:33

pls tell that to my breasts. they apparently aren't aware of that fact...

lissie · 14/07/2007 17:36

mine either!

tiktok · 14/07/2007 17:38

MotherFunk, you had a horrible experience, and I am sorry about that. You are changing what you said - I can't keep up if you modify what you originally said, which was, as I quoted, "And if your baby is losing weight due to not getting enough breastmilk, surely you would agree that it is in the best interests to switch to bottle, regardless of how society views you?"

Now you are saying you meant the baby is better off on formula than nothing...as if I have somehow suggested deliberately starving a baby rather than give formula.

Your HV was wrong and misinformed, and it's an unpleasant way of shifting blame for your situation onto your stress, rather than where it almost certainly lay - on the maternity care staff. A baby who has not eaten for 5 days and who has not been spotted not eating has been badly let down by the people whose job it is to check these sorts of things. My guess is that your baby was at the breast, and you were told all was well. But in fact he was not transferring milk - he may have looked as if he was, to their uninformed eyes. I expect you felt things were not right, too, but you were told not to worry and that things would soon get better.

In fact, you were right all along. Things were not fine. You were producing milk, but your baby was not getting it. Then you hit a crisis on day 6 when it became crystal clear he was in dire straits.

It might have been that you stopped letting down milk in response to that stress - you would not cease production, though, not as early as that. But milk was not getting into your baby and of course he needed formula at that point.

I may be a bit wrong about what happened - I am joining the dots to match what usually happens when a baby has a feeding crisis like this at this time. It is always due to inadequate maternity care, whatever the details.

You and your baby were let down. Stress? My a*.

lulumama · 14/07/2007 17:38

if only it were that simple though

some babies latch on like a dream, feed marvellously and gain weight beautifully

some don;t

hence why bf counsellors and supporters exist, and the LLL ,ABM, NCT

if bf were always that straightforward , none of these organisations would exist to help mums with breastfeeding

also, i had a client recently, whose milk did

allgonebellyup · 14/07/2007 17:40

i wasnt having a go at people who've tried bfing and cant do it, i was having a go at girls who have boobs jobs and dont want to ruin their figures

lulumama · 14/07/2007 17:41

oops

did not come in at all..no engorgement, no leaking, nothing. she felt she had no time to get her supply establised or even started as abby was in NICU, MWs failed to bring her a breat pump, so she formula fed..and was happy to do so.

she put the baby to the breast at birth, and he latched on, so she intended to feed, circumstances took over

lissie · 14/07/2007 17:49

lulu, thats really sad.

AGBU, but isnt it their choice? and as valid a reason as any?

MotherFunk · 14/07/2007 17:49

Message withdrawn

MotherFunk · 14/07/2007 17:52

Message withdrawn

allgonebellyup · 14/07/2007 17:52

lissie - as valid a reason as any?
i think not. Since when did boob jobs become more important than the nutrition of your child?

allgonebellyup · 14/07/2007 17:52

motherfunk - yes there is that too