Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

^^Extraordinary breastfeeding - tonight on C4 ^^

843 replies

harpsichordcarrier · 01/02/2006 17:27

new thread for RTKM

OP posts:
wantedmyboobsback · 01/02/2006 22:46

its me not bourneville that intends giving up at 6 months again i was exhauseted through the feeding at night but they had both dropped night feeds by 3 months thankfully bottle feeders probably get more sleep as there partner can share with the feeding not an option for me as i couldnt express its nice to be able to go out for a few hours without the baby have the occasional night out they dropped night feeds not the 10pm feed so stayed at home every night for 6 months

nanneh · 01/02/2006 22:47

Slash face - you were weaned too early love

bourneville · 01/02/2006 22:47

um, hercules, i don't know that it was positive for extended breastfeeding. like i said, i'm all confused again now having watched it.

wantedmyboobsback - i hate it when people talk about mothers being "too selfish". Don't call yourself selfish - we all have our limits and it doesn't sound selfish to me doing what was best for you & your dh, and therefore what is also best for your baby. if i had had a dp (am single mum) i would've done all i could to ensure he could be involved in feeding, if he wanted to. I think it would be important for the baby too, to have two dedicated carers and two people to rely on it that way... plus, happy mummy = happy baby and all that (within reason, assuming she's not doing anything to make baby unhappy!)

VeniVidiVickiQV · 01/02/2006 22:48

absolutely SL.

I said a similar thing to dp today - maybe they dont 'need' the nutrition, but are enjoying a closeness to their mum. Its only other people with hangups that are suggesting that extended b/feeding is anything other than just that.

starlover · 01/02/2006 22:48

there is something called bottle-mouth which can occur in breastfed babies too...
basically caused by falling asleep with breast/bottle and the sweet liquid being around the teeth.

i don't think it's necessarily more likely with extended breastfeeding... no diffferent to letting your toddler take a bottle of milk to bed

bourneville · 01/02/2006 22:48

oh jee just to quickly say i haven't read thread since post from hercules and posted that thread without reading... will catch up now....

SlashFaceAntiPeadifiddler · 01/02/2006 22:48

Oh no I aint. The Mrs gives me all er milk. We've got 5 little uns, but rather than waste all the milk on them, it goes on my wheetos. Bloody lovely. Oh, but yeah, see what they mean about the fillings. Whole mouth full of them.

chapsmum · 01/02/2006 22:49

hercules, did dh feed till 4 am or age 4???

starlover · 01/02/2006 22:49

definiteyl qv.. like i said on my other thread... i would have thought it was totally weird and, dare i say, disgusting before i had ds and breastfed him! that totally changed my perspective!

i thought i'd be weirded out by the 8 year old... but it just seemed natural still

chapsmum · 01/02/2006 22:50

Slash face, if you cant feed em dont breed em, that me motto!!!
tiny tim is the 12th member of our family who are exclusivly bfed!

bourneville · 01/02/2006 22:51

got to nanneh's post - I was bf dd every couple of hours for most of 1st year.
I wasn't exhausted through lack of sleep, i did cc at 6 months so dd was sleeping through from then on. it seriously was bfeeding related, like i said, i felt like i came out of a fog. it was possibly emotionally draining for me too, like i said before, I really feel invasion on my space and all that.

SlashFaceAntiPeadifiddler · 01/02/2006 22:52

Pah. I'm more important that the kids. En I?

roosmum · 01/02/2006 22:52

actually SL, isn't that part of the point of lots of attachment parenting-type thinking?? ie that the child is feels loved & secure, avoiding negative feeling (eg resentment, anxiety - whatever). bf is a part of this too?

hercules · 01/02/2006 22:52

4 years.

nanneh · 01/02/2006 22:53

alexmum - that's a myth. There have been extensive studies done on that (see kellymom.com) - one of them analysed 1,000 year old skulls that showed almost a total lack of tooth decay.

Obvioulsy 1,000 years ago anyone who survived into adulthood would have been breastfed usually for the first few years of their lives, but they just didn't have tooth decay the way we do today.

Plus breastmilk has antibacterial components that actually help to fight tooth decay.

starlover · 01/02/2006 22:54

i think so roosmum... it makes a lot of sense!

hercules · 01/02/2006 22:54

Isn't it a type of sugar that doesnt rot your teeth in bm? I'm sure I've read that somewhere. Neither of my kids have any decay either.

muma3 · 01/02/2006 22:56

kirsty was an angel herself.reminded me of me as a young bf mum. makes me very angry at the fact that it is seen as inappropiate to find in public thats just nuts iyam.

the mother of the twins did seem to offer more then get asked but i dont think that the 2 darlings minded . it seemed that it worked for them as well as mum for 2.3 years, do think though that to just stop like that was a bit drastic and she must of been very uncomfortable.

the lady trying to feed her adopted daughter now that was just wrong. we produce milk to nurious our off-spring , she was obviously doing for her own benefit imo.

and the lady with her older daughters is barking mad imo. she seemed a bit uncomfortable to feed whilst being fimled at one point and looked strange doing it. not relaxed, not natural. the 2 girls seemed very strange and i was wondering if there was any concern regarding there relationship with their mother and her breasts???. drawing pictures /na,ing them and touching them whilst mum got dressed ???/ def probs in future. ime my 8y would find that extremely strange and so would any 8y surely?
do they keep them at home so she can feed without outside judgement? and dont even get me started on the father drinking aswell OMFG!!!!!!! wrong wrong wrong. not natural, not what the milk is produced for and defenitly tapped and barmy the whole family ( and for granny that is very worring surely?)

it has honestly changed the way i see extended feeding and the ideal age imo has rose to maybe 2-3y and im all for the little angels that is a very good idea as there just isnt enough support in hossies these days

anyway WILLIES lol i will be watching it !! just time to make a cuppa

muma3 · 01/02/2006 22:57

sorry meant to say "feed in public " sorry

hercules · 01/02/2006 22:59

Personally I wouldnt have let my mum bf my baby but wet nursing is hardly a new thing and is only rare nowadays.

Yes, the 8 year old was annoying but it's not fair to judge extended bf on that. Lots of 8 year olds are annoying and have never been bf!

Aloha · 01/02/2006 22:59

So the freak-woman who breastfed her eight year old and was going to breastfeed her ten year old also breastfed her husband? And some of you are still saying she isn't a loon? Pah!

bourneville · 01/02/2006 23:00

re security and all that, those older kids feeling secure etc, that's not what I thought, I thought if they are getting so upset and feeling insecure about having to stop breast feeding, what does that say about their feelings of security in a general way, and about their relationship with their mum?

On a different issue entirely but also related to secuity, i did cc at 6 months, and feel it was one of the best things i have ever done for me and dd and that she is very secure as a result of it, compared to someone I know who so far has chosen not to and as a result has a very clingy, insecure toddler esp at bedtime. dd learnt to fall asleep by herself, comfort herself etc and i really do believe she is now the independent, secure person she is now partly because of that... she knows that even if i disappear, i am actually still there and always come back.

perhaps the same thing applies to breast feeding that late? I didn't leave dd with anyone else at all until over a year old (partly cos she was such a frequent b'feeder) but i so, so wanted to for the same reasons that cc worked for her. am i making sense? when i was deciding whether or not to do cc and whether or not dd was ready etc, i did worry that it would have the opposite effect. getting a balance is important i guess.

again, i have probably now missed loads of posts...

hercules · 01/02/2006 23:01

So what if she doesnt follow the norms of our society and decides to bring her kids up on an alternative way.

Yes, she was a looney but that doesnt mean she's not a good parent creating a loving home for her kids.

starlover · 01/02/2006 23:02

i guess different things work for different people though, and everyone does what they think suits their kids,.

i have never done cc with linus, and never would. he is the most independant child i have ever met (lockets will vouch for that!!!)... i have had him with me pretty much constantly since birth and he has never had to be left to cry or anything

hercules · 01/02/2006 23:02

I think she was a bit loony but not a freak.

Swipe left for the next trending thread