Oh dear. It sounds like much hugs, arm punches, chocolate, expressos etc are needed.
Tickle I wouldn't dream of giving a baby this age water in the night, even my ff one. He wants you not some manufactured thing.
Jeewhiz you are cut out for this. Because you are determined to do and be what your baby needs. Imagine if baba had a mum who was intent on doing a routine and cc etc? He would be utterly miserable all the time. Instead he has a mum who understands that he is a high need baby. It doesn't make the dark times any lighter I know, or make him any easier to read, and you will still get things 'wrong' but you are doing the best thing for him.
Titania I know what you mean. I was judged for giving ds a dummy, now I'm being judged for still cuddling him to sleep! Why? After all, when it works, it takes less than 5 mins! And I get a lovely sleepy snuggle thrown in free! Routine is for those without enough imagination to go with the flow 
Spanner repeat after me - 'it was a fluke'
. Seriously, you're doing nothing wrong. You are doing everything right even though sometimes it's hard.
DS is convinced that 5am is party time. It's damn hard, especially when I've been up twice in the night to feed him, but today I'm just going with it. Tomorrow I'll be raging against it again!
Finally - welcome to the newbies - you are part of a very exclusive club. We don't let just anyone in here you know 