Barristermum - I have to agree with you (a bit) here...me and DH have been finding BUB really annoying, not because we hate CV (or anyone else) but because it is clearly filmed in order to manipulate the audience into responding in that way....grrr!!
Obviously they've taken some extreme examples (and its weird seeing Spock as the putative middle ground) but its the blatant attempt to over-emotionalise (hmmm, not really very good english, but its late and I've only just got ds into bed!) the feeding/sleeping/leaving to cry issue which is winding us up. IMHO it is the least helpful baby programme I've seen so far ;)
Sorry all...that was a bit of a rant, wasn't it?
I would say that I read she-who-shall-not-be-named's book a couple of times pre-baby and thought there was some sensible advice in it but found the over-rigorous approach ("do not under any circumstances, even if the world is about to end or your partner hasn't seen the baby for 2 weeks, bathe your baby after 5.30pm") and slight stretching of the truth ("your baby will be going through the night...oh, except for the peach water you'll be giving it at 4am which I failed to mention in the headlines") rather offputting.
In the end we went with the Baby Whisperer, which was a bit more baby-centred and problem-solving whilst still being fairly structured : the whole approx routine (or 'day structure' rather than schedule) fits on a single page and covers the first 4 months and she recognises that you obviously can't expect a newborn to wait until, for example, 1pm prompt, for its feed if its hungry at 12.30.
Even with BF-ing, DS went through from 11pm-7.30am by 7 weeks and slept through completely by 9 weeks. Without leaving him to cry with hunger or anything else (before anyone shouts at me!). Which is actually better than CV on BUB or GF claim they can achieve...
This might have something to do with me patiently and repeatedly explaining to my new baby that mummy is a much happier and nicer person when she has had more than 3 hours sleep, so its in everyone's interests to leave her for a bit longer!
But...(again, before anyone shouts!)...
...every baby is different. I have no doubt that my current bump will have an entirely different idea of how to be a newborn and might well decide to try to prove that just because a certain approach worked for its brother doens't mean it will do the same...!