Brother for Jacob and Benjamin

[namechange272727]

Henry, Samuel or Alexander? (We would use the long name rather than shortening.)

or something else?

thanks

I think those three are all widely used in C of E and Catholic families too.

Things like Malachi, Levi and Abraham maybe less so.

I have a Benjamin and a Samuel.

Samuel goes best with your other two children’s names. All 3 lovely names though

Came here to suggest all these!

Henry, Samuel or Alexander? (We would use the long name rather than shortening.)
You won't have any control when they're older. Alex and Sam are very likely.
Of the three I'd pick Samuel but they're all ok.

As a wildcard, I'm suggesting Japheth.

Yes, I mainly agree. Once you have named your child, it is their name and their choice to have shortened if they wish.
Best to pick a name that has an acceptable shortening. Alexander to Xander, as an example, would tick all boxes in my humble opinion…

I like all three but Samuel goes best with the brothers' names.

I think Samuel goes best but I actually prefer the name Alexandra and then Henry over Samuel.

Jacob, Benjamin and Tobias
Jacob, Benjamin and Rupert
Jacob, Benjamin and Henry