Which girls name would you pick?

[hebclgiwlwon]

Baby is due in May and we are trying to finalise our girls list...

Which would you pick?

Edie - my top currently. Think it's classy and pretty and still not too popular.

Connie

Marcie - slightly different but is it one of those trendy / modern names that will fade ?

Isabella - Bella as nn. Worried she would end up Izzy though which I'm not keen on.

Clara - like as an adult but can't really imagine as a baby / toddler?

Sadie

Clara
Edie is too popular for me and also a shortening of Edith. Would prefer Edith nn Edie
Isabella also took popular along with all the Ella, Bella type names
I don't like Connie - makes me think of con men and being conned.

Marcie is sort of ok but also sounds like a nickname to me, same with Sadie, not so keen . Would prefer Sarah, with Sadie as a nickname if you really loved it.

Clara is classic and less common than Edie or Isabella

Clara or Connie. Both gorgeous names x

Clara of your list I think. She will have a really brief time as a child - imo it’s more important to think about what sort of name she might like to have as an adult (kids quickly “grow” into their names or sometimes have cute non- related nicknames when little like Pip, Bean, Badger etc). I’d always try to go for something a little more classic where possible, so it avoids dating them or any background assumptions and Clara and Isabella of your list fit closest to that.

But Isabella is a no go if you really hate one of the more common nn’s imo (as you can’t really police it once they are in school/can make up their own mind - it’s probably 70/30 Bella to Izzy imo).

Connie/Marcie/Edie/Sadie are all trendy diminutive style names - they just happen not to have made the Top 100 yet. Of them, I personally like the sound of Edie best - yes, it’s very fashionable but at least it’s Edie Sedgwick cool and has a nice sound (though a bit similar to Evie). Sadie and Connie don’t sound very nice to me and Marcie blends into all the Marnie’s and Darcie’s. You might like similar Sylvie though?

I would pick Eden rather than Edie.
Dislike Connie. The others are ok but a bit bland.

Clara or Connie.

Clara, 100%

What about …

Cora or Coral?

Sadie

Clara, she can share her name with my car! 🚙

I used to teach a Connie- she was ace!!

I like Sadie, Clara, and Edie (though I'd put Edith on the BC). I think they suit any stage of life.

I don't like Connie at all, or Marcie. Isabella is very popular.

I like Sadie, Clara and Edie the best (although I do think Edie would be better as Edith on the birth certificate as Edie feels a bit nothingy on it's own). It could get misheard as Evie though, which is much more popular. Clara is fine on a baby, there are plenty around these days. Lara could be an alternative though if you're not sure? Or Zara?

I quite like Connie but, again, I'm not sure how it holds as a given name and I really dislike Constance (reminds me of incontinence).

Isabella is ok but I'm the opposite to you. I like Izzy and I'm really not keen on Bella.

Marcie isn't for me, at all. I'm not a fan of any of the similar trends either, like Marnie and Marley. I think they'll all date badly.

I think Sadie would be my top choice over all. Traditionally it's short for Sarah, if you wanted another option for the birth certificate, but I do think this one works ok as a given name.

Clara or Edie

I like Clara and Edie, but only with Edith as they full name. I don't like nicknames on the birth certificate.

You have very similar taste in names to me.
Favourite would be Clara, closely followed by Connie and Sadie.

How do you feel about Marcia with Marcie as a nn? I know a little girl called a Marcia and she is awesome so that is a big yes from me!

really like Clara and Edie (Edith) not so keen on the others but i must say Sadie is growing on me.

Edie - Not a fan of this name myself, bit old and fuddy duddy.

Connie - a 60 year old country singer.

Marcie - Kind a like, I've always had a soft spot for Darcy too.

Isabella - Bella as nn. - very popular, but it is a very lovely name, hence the popularity. I had a dog called Bella though so never been a fan of it as a nickname.

Clara - I absolutely love this name, it was high up my girls name lists, I think it has a lovely sound and I think it definitely works for a little girl up to adulthood.

Sadie - nice.

My favourites, inspired from you list ..
Edwina - Edie
Marcie
Claris
Mary-Ellen
Constance
Sara

Clara. Lovely name

ie names are a bit twee and naff IMO

Edie and Connie are shortened names (Edith and Constance), and so presumably is Marcie (Marcia?). Of the others I prefer Isabella as its classic, and at a push Clara. Not really keen on Sadie.

My favourites are Edie (if short for Edith) and Connie (Constance). Clara is quite nice but I find it a bit sickly and it’s very popular amongst little ones where I am. Sadie is OK.

Personally, I’m not keen on Marcie and I don’t like Isabella/Bella - it’s just too fluffy and princessy for me. I like Isobel.

I love Clara and think it suits all ages. I know an Edie and at age 7 she already prefers to be called Edith, so I think I’d go for Edie as a nn for Edith rather than a name on it’s own.

Edie - Short for Edith and Eden. Also very similar to Evie. Will be Ede.
Connie - lovely if short for Constance
Marcie - doesn't seem modern, might be short for Marcia, Marcelle or Marcela.Too close to the now dated Darcey.
Isabella - Bella and Izzy both far too popular
Clara - not keen but it's OK
Sadie - might be short for Sarah, but is OK on its own

I'd use isabella as a middle name. Connie as a first name.

I would NOT use May as a middle name.

I love Sadie and Marcie, and like Edie and Connie. Not keen on Clara and Isabella.

Clara is adorable. I also like the name Connie.