Identical Twin Girls - Eliza and ???

[SurpriseSurprise]

I’m 19+5 with identical twins girls and we struggling with a name for one twin

We’ve agreed on Eliza for one, but haven’t decided on a middle name yet.

I really like Lexi, but I don’t know if I sounds like a “real” full name or if it sounds like it’s short for something. However I can’t work out what Lexi could be short for, I don’t want Alexa because of the whole Amazon thing!!!! I’m also unsure if Lexi and Eliza sound too harsh

DH has suggested we honour his late mum (who I never met) who’s name was Enid but always called Ellie. But I think having two “E” names is naff, whether it’s Enid and Eliza or Ellie and Eliza. Plus I don’t know anyone under about 70 called Enid.

So any suggestions on what could go with Eliza?!

Eliza and Dorothea
Eliza and Freya
Eliza and Diana
Eliza and Charlotte

Ahh, I've got twins! Eliza and Jess xxx

Louisa, Clara or Alice.

Ok, having now read your OP, you can't really use Ellie because that could be a shortening of Eliza. You could use something with an 'Ell' sound at the end, like Cordelia (Della / Delia) or Petronella.

Eliza and Darcy

Betsy

Elizabeth and Charlotte- Eliza and Lottie

Sophia, Amelie, Katherine, Anna
And congratulations!

Eliza and Esther

Georgiana
Imogen
Alexandra
Charlotte
Iseult
Catherine
Alessandra
Francesca

Eliza & Imogen

Eliza & Heidi

Eliza & Lottie

Eliza & Florence

Eliza & Betsy

Eliza & Penelope

Eliza & Rosie

Eloise and Eliza
Faye and Eliza
Isobel and Eliza
Lottie and Eliza
Lucy and Eliza
Sadie and Eliza
Zara and Eliza

Eliza and Alannah

Eliza and Madeleine
Eliza and Juliet
Eliza and Cecily

Thea
Charlotte
Lydia
Catherine
Annette
Marianne
Jessa
Annalise

@fatlazycow I think the reason people dislike
Lexie is because it's a very modern name and Eliza is an old classic name.

Sorry, I love Eliza but really don't like Lexie at all. Doesn't have the same vibes at all.

My choice would be Elizabeth (Eliza) and Charlotte (Lottie).

Margot
Juliette
Constance
Isabel
Adeline
Lillian

I vote for Enid because that's my DD's name (and I assure you she's well under 70 😉).

Not keen on Lexi or Ellie with Eliza.

I'm d probably go with Hazel. Eliza and Hazel sound lovely together.

Ellie is too similar. Lexi is definitely not a full name (veers into stripper territory), Alexis or Alexandra could work.

Eliza and
Imogen
Susannah
Lydia
Claudia
Serena
Louisa
Saskia
Francesca
Clara
Frances
Beatrice nn Bea
Caitlin
Alice
Charlotte
Annabel
Katherine nn Kate / Kitty
Annabel
Harriet
Emily
Emmeline
Caroline
Marianne
Georgia
Jane

Elizabeth and Annabelle

Eliza and Anna

Lexi not my taste at all, sorry.

Eliza is beautiful.

May I suggest:
Lydia + Eliza
Anna + Eliza
Lucy + Eliza
Rosie + Eliza
Megan + Eliza

Eliza and Rose

Eliza and Harriet

Eliza and Phoebe

Eliza and Matilda

Eliza and Ruby

Eliza and Poppy

Eliza is a lovely name but she may well get called Liza, Ellie or Lizzie by friends so you'll need a name that isn't shortened or can't be shortened to something similar imo.

I love PP suggestion of Alexandra (Lexi) and Elizabeth (Ellie or Eliza)

Or
Eliza and Georgia/Giorgia
Eliza and Clara/Klara
Eliza(beth) and Meredith (Could be Ellie and Merry or Ellie and Edie or Eliza and Edie

Clara