Narrowed it down - which do you prefer?

[Violetandpurple]

Our 4th baby girl is due in the summer.

Madeline
Matilda
Primrose

All 3 go lovely with our other dd's names
Primrose I think is beautiful but is it too out there.. which do you prefer and why.

Primrose. It’s a family name and we’ve always had lovely comments.

I like Primrose but wouldn't like any shortening of it, it would bother me!

Madeline is lovely, and I don't mind Maddie.

Matilda is probably my favourite but also probably the most popular, so it depends how much that concerns you!

I prefer Madeline.

I think they are all likely to end up shortened.
Maddy
Matty / Tilda
Rose / Rosie.

So from there I think a prefer Matilda or Primrose. Not a big fan of Madeline.

Matilda is really different. I'm liking it.

Matilda 💕 one of my favourites but DH hates it xx

Primrose

Because Matilda and Madeline are overused and a little dull.

I like Madeline best.
Matilda is too popular and Primrose is too twee - also very hard to carry off if she is not very “stereotypically girly”.

Matilda

Matilda. It’s one of my favourites and I wish I could use it for this baby (if a girl) but sadly the short version (Tilly) sounds silly with our surname! The other two are ok, but I much prefer Matilda.

Matilda, hate primrose

Matilda!

From favourite to least favourite

Primrose
Madeline
Matilda

Primrose is beautiful

Primrose and Madeline, both beautiful and classy and not too overused. I’m not a fan of Matilda

Primrose, although I quite like Matilda.

Madeline…gorgeous name.

I love them all! Primrose is my favourite though.
You could use one of the other names as a middle name? Either would sound nice.
Great choices OP.

I like Madeline best. I also like all the Adeline and Adelaide type names. I think primrose could be cool at some ages but might be tricky at different ages. Prim isn't the best shortening and Rosie feels like a different name to me. Matilda I knew a really horrid one so that's not helpful as just subjective.

No help but usually I click on these and hate them all but all 3 of your names are nice. Any would be lovely

Madeline, it's just really beautiful.

Matilda is fine. Primrose I don't really like, it is a bit twee and prissy as pps said. I do like most 'rose' names, but I think it's the 'prim' bit of Primrose that spoils it.

Primrose no Prim like Hunger Games

Nn (not no)

I'd probably go for Madeline. Anything but Primrose to be honest. That's
a bloody awful name.

Matilda. I only know one and she is 26. I like the pet names and the full name, it just sounds nice in all permutations!

I like Matilda and Madeline equally.

Can't stand Primrose. Just makes me think of Harold Shipman's wife.