Lewis or Malcolm ?

[badg3r]

I feel like we have been round and round in circles but last night these two came up as new contenders for DC3... thoughts?

Lewis

wow.
neither
sorry

But especially not Malcolm

There's no decision, Lewis

Malcolm, seriously?

Lewis. Any Malcolm's I've ever met are old men!

Both terrible sorry.

Lewis.

Lewis. It is a very popular name here in Scotland. Not so much Malcolm.

Malcolm

I like Malcolm. People had the same 'it's an old man name' reaction to Arthur, Albert and Frederick and they are all the rage now. Times change. Tastes change. These things always work in cycles.

I like Malcolm. I grew up living next door to a Malcolm who was my age, so it’s never seemed like an old man name to me.

@SSW101

I like Malcolm. People had the same 'it's an old man name' reaction to Arthur, Albert and Frederick and they are all the rage now. Times change. Tastes change. These things always work in cycles.

still really really dislike Arthur, Albert and Frederick.

Alfie and Freddie just about OK.

Malcolm not in the same vibe. It is hideous

If you're giving birth to a middle-aged Rotarian who reads the Telegraph and refers to 'my good lady wife', go right ahead with Malcolm.

Aw I kind of love Malcolm! Lewis is nice too.

I prefer Lewis.

I like them both but prefer Malcom. It's more interesting and memorable.

My dads called Malcolm so I wouldn’t chose it! I like Lewis.

Love love malcolm.. unusual and really sweet .. i can imagine a little character

Lewis doesnt have anything to it.. too meh

I really like Lewis, it was on my list for boys names.

Love Malcom. Cool and not overused!

Lewis is ok. A little bland only comparison.

Lewis. No contest.

Neither.

I'm astonished at the love for Malcolm from some posters. I would group Malcolm with Geoffrey, Keith, Nigel, Bernard, Neville.

Malcolm is your bank manager, the chair of your local Conservative Association, the red-faced man propping up the bar of your village pub, airing his opinions about 'lady golfers' and advocating the death penalty and the return of compulsory national service.

Lewis definitely!

I have a 70 plus relative called Malcolm and he is and has always been an obnoxious pig. 😡

@Gatelodge

I'm astonished at the love for Malcolm from some posters. I would group Malcolm with Geoffrey, Keith, Nigel, Bernard, Neville.

Malcolm is your bank manager, the chair of your local Conservative Association, the red-faced man propping up the bar of your village pub, airing his opinions about 'lady golfers' and advocating the death penalty and the return of compulsory national service.

I almost agree with you, but I adore the name Bernard.

It reminds me of the Alfie books, the naughty boy was Bernard!

I really like Malcolm 🤷🏼‍♀️

It’s the natural successor to Arthur. Sorry folks.