Judge my girl names

[twistandshoutoutloud]

This is a preliminary list of names that I like before even showing it to DP as I would also like some suggestions from everyone on here. These aren't the only names I like but just some of my favourites

Harper
Ocean
Lilac
Astor
Scout
Blaze
Greer
Indigo
Bali
Fallon
Holland
Tatum
Ace
Brighton
Lumen
Teal
Halston
Collins
Gage - Biggest guilty pleasure ever I don't even know why

Really open to suggestions and everyone's comments on them

I quite like Harper and Ocean🤔 but I do agree with pp’s... They sound like paint colours

Lumen makes me think of bowel lumen

Harper. It's okay. Very over rated though.
Ocean. It's okay
Lilac. Love this.Ruby Sienna Amber Scarlett are all very popular color themed names. Why not Lilac.
Astor. Not heard this but I quite like it
Scout. I think you'd have to be 100% sure she was going to be lively and full of character. I don't think it d suit a very shy child.
Blaze. See Scout.
Greer. I love this.
Indigo. See Lilac.
Bali. See Ocean
Lumen. I love this..
Holland. Id just think. I think I know what you did I'm Holland 9 months before.. Don't like the sound of it either.
Tatum. Gorgeous.
Ace. Nice name but more for a boy Id say.
Brighton. See Holland.
Fallon. One of my favorites.
Teal. See Lilac and Indigo.
Halston. Is that a place, too.
Collins.What an ugly name. Id assume it was your s or your mind maiden name.
Gage. It's a nice name. However it Just makes me think of the little boy in Pet semetery. I certainly wouldn't put it a girl, though

There is a Harper in my ds's class and I knew an Ocesn once who was team a travelling family.

Tatum for me. It was on my list. Strong list that sounds like you might be a feminist with hippy tendencies who grew up in the 80s and met you partner in Brighton. That’s my read anyway. 😉

Harper, Lilac, Astor and Indigo are very nice

The rest are a bit extra and try hard to be ‘out there’

I assumed these were all male names till I re-read the heading! Ace, Blaze, Halston, Collins cant surely be female names?

I do like unpopular and different names, but some on your list are just too out there.

Lumen in medical terms is the width of a tubular structure like intestines, veins or sizing for catheters, so this is a definite no from me

Fallon sounds rude and like something done to genitals!

The only names, at a push, I'd chose from a girl are Lilac, Teal and Indigo.

Awful

Sorry but I think they are all ridiculous. As a professional woman I would be mortified to be called one of these names

Who says Blaze can't be professional! Blaze would close that deal!

Fallon and Harper are the only reasonable ones on there.

Harper
Astor
Greer
Tatum

Poor kid

I like Fallon and Astor.
Gage I like but it's a boy's name to me.

I know a man called Blaise, is that any good? Would work for a girl I think.

Harper. Meh, it's fine.
Ocean. I really like, hippy but who cares.
Lilac. A very pretty colour name.
Astor. This sounds too masculine to me. Perhaps Astoria? Though not sure if that has an actual meaning given "Waldorf Astoria"
Scout. Cute literary reference
Blaze. Too try hard
Greer. Just sounds ugly to me, like sneer
Indigo. Pretty like lilac, and actually I prefer it
Bali. People will assume they were conceived here.
Lumen. It's a unit of measurement and reminiscent of a Harry Potter spell...
Holland. Again, conceived there.
Tatum. Not a fan, sounds like you are trying to use a name from another culture (assuming you are white British)
Ace. I agree with PP that this seems like a boys name.
Brighton. Again, reads as place you DTD
Fallon. Only makes me think of Jimmy Fallon.
Teal. I like all the colour ones, this included.
Halston. Again, DTD there.
Collins. My least favourite of all. Do not like at all. A boring surname.
Gage. I feel this is also v masculine.

I'd go with one of the pretty colour names or ocean

I know two Harper's in the same class. I know an Ocean who hated her name and changed it. I think Lilac is pretty but know people pronounce it differently, sometimes emphasising the Lac sometimes not.

I have an adult female relative called Blaise (Blaze) and it suits her perfectly and every one loves her name, she is a professional person.

Honestly? With the exception of Lilac they are all rather common and/or too American.

Dear God! I imagine this is a joke? The names sound like the equine inhabitants of our local riding school. Especially Blaze and Scout. I think this sort of name is known as a "Ghetto" name in America.

I do wonder why, if people are so keen on weird names, they don't adopt one themselves and give their poor infant something less remarkable.

Bloody awful.

Indigo is ok.
Aster like the plant rather than Astor is also ok.
Maybe Ocean. At a push.

The rest, well, your title is judge my girls names and I’m afraid I am.

So much negativity!!

Well yes. The names are awful. Well deserved negativity.

Lumen is a metabolism app & also a dating website.

Gage is a device used to make measurements.

Are you drunk OP?

Harper is lovely!