I agree that Skye is probably the way forward as you at least both like it.
I love Eden, Amber, Thea and Arabella.
I like Skye and Morgan
I am not keen on Ruby or Beatrix
Similar to Skye (possibly!):
Ailsa, Eilidh, Iona, Skylar, Summer, Sadie, Kirsty, Shay, Seren, Serena
Similar to Eden:
Erin, Elin, Enya, Etta, Erica, Emery, Emmeline, Elliot, Emerson, Avery, Addison, Sutton, Madison
Similar to Amber:
Alexis, Alexa, Alyssa, Alicia, Arwen, Amanda, Aurora, Saffron, Sorrell, Ebony, Arianna, Autumn
Similar to Thea:
Tia, Tara, Tamsin, Tessa, Tabitha, Leah, Aliya, Verity, Valerie, Astrid
Similar to Arabella:
Annabelle, Annabella, Anastasia, Araminta, Cassandra, Clarissa, , Francesca, Gabriella, Henrietta, Isabella, Isadora, Lilianna, Miranda, Matilda, Natasha, Natalia, Olivia, Philippa, Rebecca, Rhianna, Sophia, Victoria
Similar to Morgan:
Brooke, Addison, Ashton, Paige, Peyton, Megan, Macey, Miley, Marley, Madeleine, Dakota, Devon, Tarryn, Merryn, Piper, Jordan, Hayden, Jayden, Kayleigh, Hayley
Similar to Ruby:
Lacey, Lexie, Ruth, Rachel, Dolly, Elsie, Dora, Abbie, Agnes, Nancy, Edith, Esme, Flora, Grace, Faith, Hope, Mary, Isla, Ivy, Ava, Ada, Penny, Sally, Sophie, Susie, Tilly, Tansy, Wendy, Zoe
Similar to Beatrix:
Beatrice, Agatha, Agnes, Bethany, Bridget, Belinda, Bianca, Bella, Constance, Caroline, Clara, Carla, Dorothy, Eliza, Elizabeth, Frances, Florence, Gloria, Harriet, Iris, Julia, Lillian, Lucinda, Margaret, Mabel, Nadine, Olive, Pearl, Prudence, Ruth, Rita, Susan, Tabitha, Teresa