Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say yes to another baby

119 replies

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 20:40

I’m early 40s with 3 children. My 2 eldest are nearly adults and are from a previous relationship. I also have a 4 month old with my current boyfriend. I’m 16 years older than him and I was unsure if we would be compatible long term and so deciding to have a baby with him was difficult. I was worried that the novelty would wear off. Things have been really good and we are contemplating trying for another as we don’t want my 4 month old growing up as an only child. My boyfriend feels more strongly than I do as he is desperate to have another of his own. He is a good dad and we work well as a family unit but because we have the 2 older children there is lots of help on hand. Both of my eldest children will be at uni and then off into the world in the next year and I’m worried how I will cope without them. Remind me of the realities of having 2 under 2 in your forties.

OP posts:
wfhinpjs · 27/10/2026 00:52

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 21:21

My eldest is already at uni but lives at home. When he graduates, he will be most likely required to move to the city. Youngest goes to uni next year - no idea where yet. Financially we are fine. I more worried about the toll of two little ones in my 40s without the support. We spend lots of time together as a family. We eat together, watch TV, play board games together most nights. In regards to 1:1 time we don’t really get any without the baby but I’m not sure it’s needed. They both get on really well with my boyfriend and they would prefer 1:1 with him. They go to the football and gym together and my boyfriend and eldest play on the same football team. Even without the baby I’m not sure we’d really spend anymore time together. They have their own lives.

That’s because he’s closer to their age!

ScrumbleMonkey · 27/10/2026 00:54

id like to hear your older kids views on this situation..

wfhinpjs · 27/10/2026 00:56

@confusedeffie I would be desperately sad if my 24 yr old son tied himself down to a 40 yo. I would also assume it wasn’t for keeps. The age gap will become very noticeable the older you get OP so I would think very carefully about expanding your brood.

SandyY2K · 27/10/2026 00:59

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 21:12

Yes faster than I would have liked but I’m fully aware that conceiving in your 40s is more difficult and ideally I would want them close in age. I own the property. Boyfriend moved in when I found out I was pregnant. We work in the same industry but he is in a more junior role but he has also started his own business which is going well. I will go back to work but maternity pay is good and I have savings. I am not reliant on him financially. I am not worried so much about that. I essentially raised the eldest two with very little help from their dad. If this relationship goes to pot, I wouldn’t be worried financially.

How helpful will your boyfriend be with another baby?

He can't leave it all to you. If he wants another child, he needs to commit to the work that goes with it.

You can't rely on the older kids.

jupiter2000 · 27/10/2026 03:35

Shoobadadoo · 26/10/2026 21:15

Bloody Nora your older kids look after your 4 month one night a week for date night?! Not cool IMO

Oh come on! If she said they are paid does it make it better? We all babysat as teens.

OneHazelBird · 27/10/2026 06:25

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 21:50

I wouldn’t say struggling at all - quite the opposite. The baby is a joy. My eldest children are happy to help and I think maintaining my relationship is important. I think because things are so perfect I’m worried another one could change that along with the possibility that the eldest two won’t be around as much. I would still seek alone time together with my boyfriend. My eldest children have been raise to be considerate and respectful. It reminds of when they were younger and by colleagues being aghast that they were on the rota for cooking and cleaning from around 9 and 10 years old. My eldest were helpful and supportive before the baby not because of it.

Your 4 month old is the easiest is will ever be for a few years.
You may feel differently as it gets harder work.
I would definitely be waiting at least another couple of months before you even think about considering TTC in the future.

I think kids should do their fair share and it’s great you’re teaching them life skills but your kids seem to be doing much more than other children - it almost sounds like you have expected them to be adults from a young age.

Sometimes single parents can unintentionally make their children become the missing adult.
Most parents would be upset that their other DCs weren’t around because they’d miss them, your only concern is them leaving you with 2 kids to look after - they’re not their kids though!

Do you and your DP do the majority of the housework, cooking and parenting?

It doesn’t sound like your DP is very supportive if you’re so concerned with your other 2 not being around as much.

It’s a bit concerning you’re talking about getting your body back into shape too.

Not one part of your posts tell me that you actually want another baby.
I’m not sure you even wanted this one tbh and feel you may have done it just to try and keep your DP on the scene.

OneHazelBird · 27/10/2026 06:31

wfhinpjs · 27/10/2026 00:56

@confusedeffie I would be desperately sad if my 24 yr old son tied himself down to a 40 yo. I would also assume it wasn’t for keeps. The age gap will become very noticeable the older you get OP so I would think very carefully about expanding your brood.

I agree about it not lasting.

I think that’s why OP had a baby and is contemplating another one, to try and keep him but it doesn’t work like that.

They only moved in together because she got pregnant, so this is a very new relationship and it was forced to move faster than planned - which rarely works out.

OP needs to think about the real possibility that she’ll be a single parent and how she’d cope with 1 vs 2 young DCs with no partner and no older kids to help.

ClawsandEffect · 27/10/2026 06:38

I had 2 little ones and a man child whilst doing everything around the house.

I'm 60. Old. Tired. How will you feel at 60 with two teenagers? I work and look after 1 grandchild. By 6pm I'm fit for nothing. Where you are physically and mentally isn't where you'll be in 15 years time.

And also, be blunt and honest with yourself. You'll be 60 and your partner will be the age you are now. There is a very good chance your relationship won't last. I've been in a relationship with that age gap (me younger though). The longer we were together, the bigger that age gap got.

Gooseinthewood · 27/10/2026 06:44

Do you work?

Supporting2026 · 27/10/2026 06:45

I had kids by myself and went to have the second one implanted at 6-7 months. It’s lovely, and I have very good financial resources so am coping, but the time when I had a small baby who slept well and was very predictable and portable was 10 percent of the work I now have with 2 toddlers who will kick off tantrums either each other.

SnowflakesandSlippers · 27/10/2026 06:49

No, I think having a further baby in your situation would be irresponsible. Focus on what you've got and think what is best for them. Also, no, most parents are not having weekly overnight breaks for 'date night', your children are being incredibly kind to help you so much and frankly I'd suggest you are somewhat taking advantage of them.

OhHobnobs · 27/10/2026 09:52

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 21:50

I wouldn’t say struggling at all - quite the opposite. The baby is a joy. My eldest children are happy to help and I think maintaining my relationship is important. I think because things are so perfect I’m worried another one could change that along with the possibility that the eldest two won’t be around as much. I would still seek alone time together with my boyfriend. My eldest children have been raise to be considerate and respectful. It reminds of when they were younger and by colleagues being aghast that they were on the rota for cooking and cleaning from around 9 and 10 years old. My eldest were helpful and supportive before the baby not because of it.

You didn't answer the question about whether you actually want another baby.

That's quite telling.

LifeBeginsToday · 27/10/2026 09:59

You also need to consider that the law is changing, and if / when you split your boyfriend will be entitled to a financial settlement from the value of your home as a live in parent.

Greendinos · 27/10/2026 10:10

LifeBeginsToday · 27/10/2026 09:59

You also need to consider that the law is changing, and if / when you split your boyfriend will be entitled to a financial settlement from the value of your home as a live in parent.

Interesting, why is this?

I can understand if he’s a SAHP but he’s not. Why would he be entitled to some of the value of her home just because he’s a live in parent?

I know sometimes people can claim on the basis of rent/mortgage contributions but interested to find out why merely having a child and living with someone entitles you to this.

Is it basically recognising the living situation as a marriage like I heard they do in Australia?

Greendinos · 27/10/2026 10:12

SnowflakesandSlippers · 27/10/2026 06:49

No, I think having a further baby in your situation would be irresponsible. Focus on what you've got and think what is best for them. Also, no, most parents are not having weekly overnight breaks for 'date night', your children are being incredibly kind to help you so much and frankly I'd suggest you are somewhat taking advantage of them.

Yeah not at that age!

It would be different if her child was a bit older at least but insisting on weekly date nights especially at the expense of your older children’s time is unusual when your baby is 4 months.

You are suggesting it’s necessary to maintain the relationship. But when your baby is that young you and your partner should be able to maintain the relationship - if it has any substance - without date nights for a period of time.

My friend and his wife had their 2 kids during the pandemic, living away from both families with no close friends around . They had zero babysitters for the first 2 years and even after the pandemic they only get babysitters a few times a year when their family visit from abroad.

5 years later from having their first child they are still deeply in love and working great as parents and as partners!

PrettyLittleRose · 27/10/2026 10:15

confusedeffie · 26/10/2026 21:22

Can you explain why? Genuinely intrigued

I can't believe you are even asking this.

Ask ANY adult who was an older child how they felt about being chief babysitter for their younger siblings when they were a teenager!

See how many of them say that they loved it. Hmm

Seriously?!

!

PrettyLittleRose · 27/10/2026 10:17

jupiter2000 · 27/10/2026 03:35

Oh come on! If she said they are paid does it make it better? We all babysat as teens.

As if she's going to pay them! 😂

becreca · 27/10/2026 10:19

wfhinpjs · 27/10/2026 00:52

That’s because he’s closer to their age!

I wouldn’t be surprised if the boyfriend was the eldest kids friend first from what she’s said about them being in the same football team!

becreca · 27/10/2026 10:20

wfhinpjs · 27/10/2026 00:56

@confusedeffie I would be desperately sad if my 24 yr old son tied himself down to a 40 yo. I would also assume it wasn’t for keeps. The age gap will become very noticeable the older you get OP so I would think very carefully about expanding your brood.

Absolutely this!

Greendinos · 27/10/2026 10:21

As a teen I babysat 2-5 year olds sporadically. I would not have been comfortable being responsible for a 4 month old baby on a weekly basis! And no other teen I know was asked to look after literal newborns on a regular basis.

becreca · 27/10/2026 10:23

OneHazelBird · 27/10/2026 06:25

Your 4 month old is the easiest is will ever be for a few years.
You may feel differently as it gets harder work.
I would definitely be waiting at least another couple of months before you even think about considering TTC in the future.

I think kids should do their fair share and it’s great you’re teaching them life skills but your kids seem to be doing much more than other children - it almost sounds like you have expected them to be adults from a young age.

Sometimes single parents can unintentionally make their children become the missing adult.
Most parents would be upset that their other DCs weren’t around because they’d miss them, your only concern is them leaving you with 2 kids to look after - they’re not their kids though!

Do you and your DP do the majority of the housework, cooking and parenting?

It doesn’t sound like your DP is very supportive if you’re so concerned with your other 2 not being around as much.

It’s a bit concerning you’re talking about getting your body back into shape too.

Not one part of your posts tell me that you actually want another baby.
I’m not sure you even wanted this one tbh and feel you may have done it just to try and keep your DP on the scene.

From her additional posts sounds like this baby was a whoopsie baby

Tink3rbell30 · 27/10/2026 10:29

Absolutely not. Strange to even have one with a man that young aswell.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 27/10/2026 10:29

I would wait and see how much he pulls his weight after you return to work after maternity leave before deciding. Might it be appropriate for him to be the one to go part time if you decide together that it would be better not to use full time childcare? Although you are quite capable of flying solo, the world doesn't need the genes of useless wastes-of-oxygen to be propogated so don't conceive #4 until you are sure he's got what it takes and wouldn't leave it all to you.

AnneLovesGilbert · 27/10/2026 10:30

Is it right that your current boyfriend (telling language don’t you think) is about 25 or and your eldest is 18?

OsfameronTanamoril · 27/10/2026 10:36

AnneLovesGilbert · 27/10/2026 10:30

Is it right that your current boyfriend (telling language don’t you think) is about 25 or and your eldest is 18?

Pretty odd set up. All of it.