Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel disappointed that my daughter has chosen a less prestigious college and a more practical degree?

133 replies

Idealist3 · Yesterday 20:44

My daughter is doing a degree in Business with Spanish and Italian, and she is very happy with her choice of college and course.

She had enough points to get into a more prestigious college and could have studied subjects such as humanities, communications or journalism. However, she was quite determined to do this particular course because she wanted something more practical and less theoretical. She also liked the industry links and the fact that there is a mandatory year abroad in Spain.

I completely understand her reasoning, and I have always wanted my children to make their own decisions about their lives. I don't want to be the kind of parent who tries to dictate what they should study or what career they should pursue.

However, if I'm honest, I feel disappointed, and I feel guilty about feeling that way.

My own degree was in Literature and Sociology at a good college, and I suppose I had hoped she might follow a more academic route. I value the intellectual side of a university education and had imagined her studying something along those lines at a more prestigious institution. I think I had an idea in my head of the sort of university experience I would have liked her to have.

Part of me worries that, given her academic ability, she could have challenged herself more and that she might be missing out on a richer university experience. I also wonder whether a degree from a more prestigious college might have opened up different opportunities for her in the future.

At the same time, I realise that she has thought about what she wants and has chosen a course that genuinely appeals to her. She isn't disappointed with her choice or wishing she had done something else. In fact, she's happy, which is what I should want for her.

I know that practical degrees can lead to good careers, and I can see the advantages of learning languages, spending a year abroad and having industry connections. I'm not suggesting that her course is a bad one, and I certainly don't want her to feel that I'm unhappy with her decision.

I think what I'm struggling with is that she has had the academic ability to pursue a different route but has actively chosen not to. Perhaps I had hoped she would value some of the things I valued about university.

I have always believed that my children should make their own choices, and I know it would be unfair to expect her to follow the path I took or to choose a degree based on prestige alone.

So, AIBU to feel disappointed, even though I respect her decision and am glad she's happy? Am I being too hung up on academic prestige and the kind of education I personally value? Or is it understandable to feel that she could have made more of her academic potential, even if she sees things differently?

I don't want to project my own expectations onto her, but I can't quite shake the feeling that I wish she'd chosen differently. I feel bad about that because, ultimately, it's her life and her decision.

I'd appreciate some honest perspectives, particularly from people whose children have chosen a different path from the one they might have hoped for them. How do you let go of your own expectations and feel genuinely happy for your child when their choices aren't quite what you imagined?

OP posts:
EveningSpread · Yesterday 21:09

Oops I totally fixed on the college thing and the three subjects and assumed A levels… failed to see this was a degree!! Sorry. Tired.

Business and two languages sounds fine! She’ll probably get a year abroad. That’ll be great.

SaySomethingMan · Yesterday 21:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree.

SmallDFartyCarNRG · Yesterday 21:09

No prestige in being a washed up Oxbridge has-been who can't find a job.
How has your degree worked out for you? It is odd to get to the age of having kids and still feel "prestige" is the most important thing to aim for in life. Do you announce where you got your degree from when you meet people or drop it into conversations regularly? How does that go down?

Penby · Yesterday 21:10

Completely up to her what she wants to do so yes I do think you’re being unreasonable. However at the same time I don’t think parents should be obliged to fund uni education and so can understand a bit more if you’re feeling obliged to contribute

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:11

Thank you all and I absolutely agree that IABU but i am being honest here and would never say it to her. On face of it I am proud that she knows her own mind and i know where this is coming from - I grew up on a rural area and a university education gave me fabulous opportunities and social mobility which i know sounds snobby

I work in education now and may it's just different values! I am happy for her and i think this is just for me to work out why i feel this way and i am sorry for it 🫣

OP posts:
Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:13

Oh sorry i meant university not college all who are asking! She is going to a technical university. Its in Ireland

OP posts:
NimbleTaupeTiger · Yesterday 21:14

BePeachNewt · Yesterday 21:08

Even nursing isn’t the guarantee it once was given the current NHS recruitment freeze. Loads of this year’s nursing grads are still unemployed.

I know, it's absolutely ridiculous that they have all these vacancies and won't take newly qualified nurses. DD graduated 12 years ago and walked straight into a job as did all her cohorts.

Hermione101 · Yesterday 21:17

As a journalist with a “prestigious” graduate
degree from a top journalism school, your daughter is 100% making the right choice about a practical business degree that offers industry connections.

Journalism is not a particularly academic degree, but neither is literature or sociology for that matter.

You remind me of myself, 20 years ago in my 20s chasing “prestige” and overlooking more fulfilling and viable career paths. I’ve had a decent career, but would 100% do it differently if I could again.

You should respect your daughter’s choice.

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:18

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 20:52

Don’t you just love an intellectual snob?

I think you hit the nub of it and I am ashamed of this 🫣 when i was at uni years ago we felt the business students were less cool than the humanities/literature ones. Awful.

I think i might be solving this for myself now that i type. I need to let it go

Also - she got much better marks for the course she is doing is another thing but i dont think it matters

My DH is in corporate world and i am in education/prison education/social work

OP posts:
BugJuice · Yesterday 21:20

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:18

I think you hit the nub of it and I am ashamed of this 🫣 when i was at uni years ago we felt the business students were less cool than the humanities/literature ones. Awful.

I think i might be solving this for myself now that i type. I need to let it go

Also - she got much better marks for the course she is doing is another thing but i dont think it matters

My DH is in corporate world and i am in education/prison education/social work

When did you go to university? I remember sociology being seen as an ‘easy’ subject when I was at university.

Hermione101 · Yesterday 21:21

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:11

Thank you all and I absolutely agree that IABU but i am being honest here and would never say it to her. On face of it I am proud that she knows her own mind and i know where this is coming from - I grew up on a rural area and a university education gave me fabulous opportunities and social mobility which i know sounds snobby

I work in education now and may it's just different values! I am happy for her and i think this is just for me to work out why i feel this way and i am sorry for it 🫣

I can see your perspective and why you value academic degrees so much coming from a rural place / social mobility.

It’s not snobby, but it was your way out. Your daughter has more freedom to choose than you did and she sounds brilliant for following her own mind!

IPeggedABandana · Yesterday 21:21

YABU. If she does what she loves at uni then she'll find a job she loves.

Literally no one after your first job asks what uni you went to, what grades you got or what degree you did. What matters is what experience you have and how your learning shows up in what you know about how to do the job.

YABU and if I may say so a little snobby about academia vs practical. These days getting a job is so tough so well done to your daughter for prioritising a degree that will help her get a job.

Imonmyownhere · Yesterday 21:22

Be proud of her or you'll suffer the consequences.

BeautifulLittlePumpkin · Yesterday 21:23

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:18

I think you hit the nub of it and I am ashamed of this 🫣 when i was at uni years ago we felt the business students were less cool than the humanities/literature ones. Awful.

I think i might be solving this for myself now that i type. I need to let it go

Also - she got much better marks for the course she is doing is another thing but i dont think it matters

My DH is in corporate world and i am in education/prison education/social work

How strange. As a social worker with a son studying business, I just don’t understand why you’re being a snob about this.

Idealist3 · Yesterday 21:23

notacooldad · Yesterday 20:56

Im not going to lie , I've sent a few of these posts over the last few months snd they make me both mad and sad. Same tale everytime.

Your daughter has enough self-awareness at 18 to reject a prestigious title in favour of a practical course that actually suits her learning style and career goals. That shows higher intelligence and maturity than many adults possess.

Stop viewing her life through the lens of your own nostalgia. A mandatory year abroad and dual languages will give her a richer, more challenging education than sitting in a lecture hall studying theory. Be proud of her independence. Shake off the snobbery, put your feelings away, and cheer her on.

Thank you!!! I needed to hear this

This has helped enormously

There is a snobbery about university over technical skills and this is prob what i was adding to

She really is thinking of the future and does not want to be studying literature or anything theoretical

OP posts:
DemonsandMosquitoes · Yesterday 21:23

NimbleTaupeTiger · Yesterday 21:04

But with languages it's better

However, to be fair, my DD did nursing and so she's never going to be out of work.

As a nurse coming up retirement, let me tell you loads of nurses are out of work.

Fridgemanageress · Yesterday 21:24

Wowsers. I’m sorry but I lost the will to live after a couple of your paragraphs. Your daughter wants to study business and language, yet you want her to learn journalism. I’m surprised that your daughter is sane! I wish your daughter all the best with what will be an exceptionally worthwhile, enjoyable and rewarding degree and she certainly won’t be listening to gossip and then regurgitating it for thirty pieces of silver

Ilikesundays · Yesterday 21:24

Your references to “college” rather than university and “points” rather than A levels, make me wonder if you’re not in the UK, so comments here may be rather UK-specific. Over here we would regard a modern languages degree coupled with business studies highly academic and indeed, if that’s what you’re looking for, prestigious. A degree in journalism or comms wouldn’t be. Her choices here sound very sensible and well considered and will open doors to many very interesting and rewarding careers. Where were you hoping she’d go?

BoredZelda · Yesterday 21:25

That’s a lot of words to say you feel you are superior.

alexisccd · Yesterday 21:25

Sociology is not prestigious

Dublassie · Yesterday 21:26

I am in Dublin and I understand you feel like this because your daughter chose a technical college ( now called university ) as opposed to a traditional university like Trinity or UCD ?
I think the equivalent in the UK is the polytechics that are now called universities also ?? I can be corrected on this .

My kids are all in UCD because the courses they wanted ( vet med, actuarial science and economics and finance ) were all in UCD . Please don't be silly . Your daughter is wise to study what she likes where she wants . The technological colleges seem to be very grounded and some of the universities seem to be stuck in the past .

However , I really do not understand your hierarchy of subjects . Journalism / sociology are more academic??? I would get it if maybe you wanted them to study maths and physics etc .

Random321 · Yesterday 21:26

Global Business & Languages in TU Dublin - A course with an 78% employment rate?

If you're living in Dublin all the money is in Finance, Law, Accounting & Tech!

Dublassie · Yesterday 21:27

Random321 · Yesterday 21:26

Global Business & Languages in TU Dublin - A course with an 78% employment rate?

If you're living in Dublin all the money is in Finance, Law, Accounting & Tech!

Don't think the money is in law any more ??

OneoftheWeddingPeople · Yesterday 21:27

The world is different now. I explained a very similar dilemma for our dd to two extremely successful top of their game famous in their field women in business - they both said without hesitation do the more vocational degree.

Thesafetygeneral · Yesterday 21:29

You say you want her to make her own choices but that’s clearly not the case.

Swipe left for the next trending thread