Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christa Pikes is awake and ‘talking’

19 replies

wouldntyouwanthelp · Today 22:32

She’s out of the coma and talking to her lawyers. Aibu to think the state of Tennessee can’t possibly try to do the lethal injection again ? Surely not? People on Reddit are suggesting she might need an amputation of one of her arms because of how caustic pentobarbital is.

Christa Pike 'conscious and speaking at hospital' after failed execution in US
https://news.sky.com/share/13595950

OP posts:
wouldntyouwanthelp · Today 22:35

I really feel for her victim’s mother. Colleen deserves to be remembered but I don’t personally agree that she (Christa) should go back on death row, I think life without possibility of parole would be a fair choice.

OP posts:
Littlejellyuk · Today 22:36

Sounds like a case of 'Rasputin'.
He was hard to execute as well. 💯

Remember that her victim, Colleen Slemmer was tortured by being beaten, slashed, and was then carved into her chest before Pike killed her by crushing her skull.
Slemmer's family were devastated.

@wouldntyouwanthelp

DuggansBakery · Today 22:37

The whole situation is unconscionable. And Trump mandating a firing squad to execute the Fort Hood killer just confirms my belief that the death penalty is barbaric and anachronistic.

wouldntyouwanthelp · Today 22:45

Littlejellyuk · Today 22:36

Sounds like a case of 'Rasputin'.
He was hard to execute as well. 💯

Remember that her victim, Colleen Slemmer was tortured by being beaten, slashed, and was then carved into her chest before Pike killed her by crushing her skull.
Slemmer's family were devastated.

@wouldntyouwanthelp

Edited

I completely agree with you! Colleen was tortured by her and she deserves to die in prison but she deserves to die an old lady having 23 hours a day to think on her sins not be tortured by the state. I mean she won’t be put to death this year as they’ve stopped the executions for the year to figure out what went wrong.

horrible

OP posts:
seahorsessky · Today 22:46

I'm against the Death Penalty anyway, for various reasons. But I don't see the logic in them changing their minds, as in, if you believe she deserved it in the first place, then why not now? Just as if someone put in prison for life is attacked, while you might blame the authorities for allowing that, you presumably wouldn't want the person not to have to serve out the rest of their sentence.
Unless what has happened to her made you change your mind and you are now against the DP, obviously.

ElatedOtter · Today 22:47

seahorsessky · Today 22:46

I'm against the Death Penalty anyway, for various reasons. But I don't see the logic in them changing their minds, as in, if you believe she deserved it in the first place, then why not now? Just as if someone put in prison for life is attacked, while you might blame the authorities for allowing that, you presumably wouldn't want the person not to have to serve out the rest of their sentence.
Unless what has happened to her made you change your mind and you are now against the DP, obviously.

You can’t keep injecting people with fatal substances until you get it right and they actually die, surely?

nocoolnamesleft · Today 22:50

ElatedOtter · Today 22:47

You can’t keep injecting people with fatal substances until you get it right and they actually die, surely?

It's wrong to torture people to death. Even murderers. If you're going to kill them, it should be fast.

crikeymikey123 · Today 22:52

She's suffered enough.

dustabsorber · Today 22:52

I am surprised that since they are such god-fearing folks down there that they just don't accept that it is divine intervention and commute her sentence.

VanillaImpulse · Today 22:55

You think they would’ve just injected her with something else to finish her off, an overdose of morphine or insulin

SmallDFartyCarNRG · Today 22:55

I know they said on R4 they would indeed be trying again. Personally I feel if they already tried twice and failed they don't get to kill her a third time. If they had a shot and missed that is on them, should be a clean slate now. She is likely to have lasting damage and live in pain as it is.

ilovesooty · Today 22:58

I'm against the death penalty anyway.

However she's now going to have life changing injuries due to the incompetence of the process. Enough is enough.

Seriestwo · Today 23:02

She’s going to lose an arm?

its barabaric. Everything about this case - from pikes childhood to the murder, trial and this botched execution is horrific.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · Today 23:16

crikeymikey123 · Today 22:52

She's suffered enough.

So did Colleen and her Mum still continues to suffer.

knitnerd90 · Today 23:17

The death penalty needs to be abolished. They've executed innocent people. The execution was botched because pharmaceutical companies won't sell the drugs they used to use so now they're using riskier ones, and often doctors won't participate so sometimes they're not even done by doctors any more. It's inhumane. It's hardly like life imprisonment isn't punishment.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · Today 23:17

Seriestwo · Today 23:02

She’s going to lose an arm?

its barabaric. Everything about this case - from pikes childhood to the murder, trial and this botched execution is horrific.

Colleen lost her life and her mother lost her child. I’m afraid I have little sympathy

knitnerd90 · Today 23:19

Executing Christa pike won't end Colleen's mother's suffering. Her daughter will still be dead. The death penalty is vengeance, not justice.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 23:23

VanillaImpulse · Today 22:55

You think they would’ve just injected her with something else to finish her off, an overdose of morphine or insulin

I don’t think they can

The pharmaceutical companies aren’t allowed to provide anything for this purpose are they? So that’s why they end up using weird shit that doesn’t work.

Doctors aren’t allowed to give a lethal injection so it’s given by people who are not experts anyway.

And if I understood it correctly, due to the condition of her veins, the drugs don’t work the way they should.

The whole thing has made me puzzle over why they do it like this tbh.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 23:23

knitnerd90 · Today 23:19

Executing Christa pike won't end Colleen's mother's suffering. Her daughter will still be dead. The death penalty is vengeance, not justice.

But if you know you’ll never get justice, you might want vengeance if that’s all you can get.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread