Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I wrong for feeling abit annoyed?

121 replies

SunnyL23 · 05/10/2026 08:55

Need some thoughts here on who is in the wrong on this, my sister in law told my husband she was pregnant but wasnt announcing to everyone yet, and when he said to her that he'd just tell me if that was okay, she said she'd be really angry and disapointed in him if he even told his wife, that he should keep it to himself till she announced to everyone, in few weeks time.
When my husband told me he knew later on, and said what she told him about him telling me, it just kinda made me feel it was a weird thing for her to ask him to keep it a secret from his wife.
In my view if I were pregnant again i'd tell all my family when I was ready for them all to know, as I did at 11 weeks pregnant with my son, after I had a scan photo to show everyone aswel, I wouldn't tell my brother and expect him to keep it a secret, but mabye this i'm overthinking?

OP posts:
MrDarcyssneer · 05/10/2026 11:37

Anyway, OP, I wouldn't be hurt by her trying to keep a secret from you, because she's only pregnant - it's hardly news of the year.

And your husband made his own choice, despite his sister trying to manipulate him, which is great. She's learned a valuable lesson - use your manners and ask FIRST before vomiting secrets onto other people :)

I would just ignore her when she starts melting down in future. She's a drama llama attention seeker, best to distance yourself a bit.

Gotta go, things to do :)

nomas · 05/10/2026 11:38

On the face of it, it’s her body so she gets to decide who knows about her baby and when.

But most people would know that if you tell your sibling, they are likely to tell their spouse.

Dies she have forn for wanting to leave you out?

Make sure you leave any baby card / gift to your DH, don’t get involved.

bunnypenny · 05/10/2026 11:39

MrDarcyssneer · 05/10/2026 11:34

Tell your mum you've been in at her gin love, and get off Reddit. I know you think repeating teenage comebacks is super effective, but you're humiliating yourself.

YW :)

The irony.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 05/10/2026 11:40

MrDarcyssneer · 05/10/2026 11:25

Nah. Literally doesn't matter who he told. His dopey sister should have asked him FIRST if he was willing to keep secrets for her.

She didn't (I am willing to bet) so he can tell everyone if he likes. You don't get to vomit out a secret and then start throwing a tantrum if the person you puked it onto wants to tell other people. Always ask first if they are willing to keep secrets.

Plus, the daft woman is only pregnant, it's just not that important to most people. If she wants to keep it a secret, she should stop telling people.

You really are a gem. 😳 dopey, daft woman, that’s not very nice.

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 11:42

bunnypenny · 05/10/2026 11:23

Mumsnet is absolutely wild for the number of members who think their husbands and partners must tell them everything. The codependency and entitlement is mad.

Edited

It’s really disturbing!

I highly doubt that many people confide in anything in people like this at all though; it doesn’t take long for their gossiping and lack of appropriate boundaries, respect and consideration for others to become obvious so they will be very, very far down the list of people with whom anybody would share anything private.

JaneJaneAnne · 05/10/2026 11:42

MrDarcyssneer · 05/10/2026 11:32

Lol. Her reality check is that she can't vomit secrets at people without asking them first if they will keep her secrets, and then have a hysterical meltdown when they use their autonomy and choose if they want to tell other people.

She can just use her manners and ask first if they don't mind keeping her secrets. Good lesson for her to learn.

Also, nobody really gives a fuck, except probably her mother. She's only pregnant. it's no big deal.

Being pregnant is a big deal, of course it is.

She’s about to go through a life changing (and life threatening) process.

It will impact her life physically, emotionally and financially.

We don’t know her history, in the early stages of her pregnancy she might have been very worried about miscarriage or simply overwhelmed thinking about the future.

That she wanted to discuss that with her DB is a lovely thing and speaks well of the OP’s DH.

IamnotSethRogan · 05/10/2026 11:46

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 09:15

It's got everything to do with loyalty.
When you marry your loyalty is to your spouse. You are a husband or wife first. A sibling or a child of parents second. The only relationship which is more important is your care for your own children.

If it was a secret that in any affected your spouse then I'd be inclined to agree with you, but it in no way does. I certainly don't tell my husband my friends personal, private information.

It's not some pissing competition about who is more important to him, it was a conversation between siblings.

AMarkAMissionABrandAScar · 05/10/2026 11:47

Depends really. Not enough info. If she genuinely only told her "blood" family of parents and siblings, fair enough, but I guess you'll have an inkling if the dad's side all knew including spouses and she doesn't like you, or is trying to leave you out on purpose.

CurlewKate · 05/10/2026 11:49

nomas · 05/10/2026 11:38

On the face of it, it’s her body so she gets to decide who knows about her baby and when.

But most people would know that if you tell your sibling, they are likely to tell their spouse.

Dies she have forn for wanting to leave you out?

Make sure you leave any baby card / gift to your DH, don’t get involved.

I can’t tell you how vile this “couples automatically tell each other everything” thing is! Apart from anything else, it means that married couples can’t have any separate friends.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/10/2026 11:50

I think it’s fair enough to tell one person something and expect it to stay with that person, especially when it doesn’t affect anyone else you may not be ready to tell.

I find it a bit annoying when people act as though couples are one person.

Obviously if it affected the spouse in some way then tell them, but not necessary otherwise if asked to keep it to themselves.

Annualsouptime · 05/10/2026 11:53

My parent kept sil's pregnancy secret. Found out accidentally before they were ready to tell everyone. They waited way past 3 months due to previous losses.
I would never think this is one kind of betrayal within family or spouses....

Some mumsnetters are weird sometimes and really make me wonder and worry if I know people like that irl... . Your marriage certificates don't override basic human decency of keeping confidential stuff confidential.

Grapewrath · 05/10/2026 11:55

She’s entitled to share something personal with her sibling with the expectation he won’t tell anyone, even his wife.
Spouses are allowed separate relationships and conversations. Weird to think otherwise imo. Are you normally this controlling?

nomas · 05/10/2026 11:56

CurlewKate · 05/10/2026 11:49

I can’t tell you how vile this “couples automatically tell each other everything” thing is! Apart from anything else, it means that married couples can’t have any separate friends.

I don’t think couples should tell each other everything, where did I say that?

I don’t tell my DH everything. My friends and family are entitled to their privacy, as is OP’s SIL.

But an upcoming baby is usually considered happy news, so most people would assume that if a brother is told the news, he will share the news with his wife.

If the SIL doesn’t want OP to know then the back story could be relevant. If the SIL has form for leaving OP out then in that situation I would want to take a step back from organising anything for the baby.

GreyCarpet · 05/10/2026 12:05

As far as I'm concerned, keeping someone else's confidence is not the same as keeping a secret from your partner.

If someone tells you something about themselves in confidence, you keep it to yourself. Especially if you have already checked whether you can tell your spouse and they've specifically asked you not to.

I just don't see how that can ever be a grey area unless it directly and negatively impacts your spouse or the person confiding in you needs protecting from harm.

JaneJaneAnne · 05/10/2026 12:10

nomas · 05/10/2026 11:56

I don’t think couples should tell each other everything, where did I say that?

I don’t tell my DH everything. My friends and family are entitled to their privacy, as is OP’s SIL.

But an upcoming baby is usually considered happy news, so most people would assume that if a brother is told the news, he will share the news with his wife.

If the SIL doesn’t want OP to know then the back story could be relevant. If the SIL has form for leaving OP out then in that situation I would want to take a step back from organising anything for the baby.

The SIL is pregnant and therefore in a delicate emotional state. She’s entitled to speak to her DB about that.

Given that we know nothing about the SIL or the family’s history suggesting that she step back from her SIL and new baby is really horrible.

Punishing a pregnant woman for wanting some privacy about a medical condition is really not the way to ensuring a happy family (or in fact a happy marriage).

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:19

JaneJaneAnne · 05/10/2026 12:10

The SIL is pregnant and therefore in a delicate emotional state. She’s entitled to speak to her DB about that.

Given that we know nothing about the SIL or the family’s history suggesting that she step back from her SIL and new baby is really horrible.

Punishing a pregnant woman for wanting some privacy about a medical condition is really not the way to ensuring a happy family (or in fact a happy marriage).

Why are you wilfully pretending like you haven’t read my posts?

Both my posts talk ask about wanting to know if SIL has form for leaving out. If SIL regularly leaves OP out then of course that’s is going to inform OP’s thinking about why she feels annoyed.

It’s pretty horrible to accuse people of things without actually reading what they’re saying.

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:25

CurlewKate · 05/10/2026 11:49

I can’t tell you how vile this “couples automatically tell each other everything” thing is! Apart from anything else, it means that married couples can’t have any separate friends.

Yes. It’s a sign of co-dependency, controlling behaviour, a lack of respect of other people, paranoia and untrustworthiness, none of which are qualities that people look for in friends and all of which are qualities likely to damage relationships with extended family and also indicate that the marriage itself is highly likely to be an unhealthy relationship. Most people can spot people like this from a mile away so avoid being friends with them.

However, when someone in your family gets into such a dysfunctional relationship it’s more complicated because nobody wants to cut off/ distance themselves from family members they were close previously. However, generally one would have no choice but to distance oneself from them if they behave like this and demonstrate through their behaviour that they think it’s ok to treat their family differently now because they are in a very important relationship and, therefore, in their mind this other person has a right to know everything anybody close to them tells them in confidence. It’s so weird and very dysfunctional. Family members can get sucked against their will into being a pawn in the difficulties these types of co-dependent relationships create and the battles between the spouses over their controlling behaviour and - as evidenced by some posts here - such people seem to think that extended family should accept being treated so poorly just because their relationship with their spouse is dysfunctional.

Sadly the only choice available in such circumstances is usually to distance yourself from that previously close relationship with the family member because people like this seem to think that extended family should treat them and their spouse as one entity and given that they’re highly unlikely to be as close to a spouse as, say, the sibling with whom they’ve grown up and shared a lifetime of experience, if their sibling insists (or their spouse does and the sibling complies) that same boundaries/ level of sharing have to be applied to both of them then the only available option left is to reduce the level of closeness with the sibling to the level of how close they are to the partner and what they’d be happy to share with this person if they did not happen to be in a relationship with their sibling. This is usually not a lot at all unless the spouse has independently established a close relationship and friendship with their BIL/ SIL! I.e. if their marriage split up, would they still see the BIL/ SIL independently and be close friends? If not, then of course they will share information with you on a different basis to how/ what/ when/ in what detail they share things with their own sibling (if the siblings are close), and this is perfectly normal and reasonable. It’s difficult to fathom why anybody would feel entitled to be told everything that’s shared in confidence with their spouse unless it’s something directly to do with their own relationship.

It’s really sad that people do this. I’ve seen it happen so many times. I think perhaps it’s mostly done by people who lack empathy/ have grown up with very dysfunctional models of co-dependent relationships which they emulate, so they presume that because they trust their spouse and share everything about themselves with that person, that automatically means everyone else should be prepared to do the same. It’s quite a bizarre expectation, really. I’ve seen it happen in my extended family several times and it just ends up with the person quite isolated, with few friends and their family relationships becoming far less close/ completely detached. When inevitably many of these dysfunctional relationship break down and people who have behaved like this often find themselves very isolated indeed.

I don’t think the OP’s case is this extreme from what she’s said! I’m referring to some of the weird and quite manic/ disturbing posts on the thread from other posters. I think in the OP’s case maybe she just hadn’t thought through that SIL is not deliberately excluding her specifically and is taking this personally, rather than realising that there is no reason she needed to know about this earlier than most of the family and obviously it’s totally reasonable for her SIL to tell her brother about her pregnancy if she wanted to and not anybody else at that early stage (and there are very good reasons she may have decided to do that which aren’t personal to the OP; she didn’t tell everyone except the OP and exclude her in some way, SIL just decided to confide only in her brother which is totally legitimate if that’s what she wanted to do).

He’s a separate human being, married or not, and this is SIL’s private information that the OP had no need to know at that point in time. Him being married shouldn’t impact in any way on his relationship with his sibling. I wonder how the OP would feel if it was the other way around and her husband told his sister something she told him in confidence, that was nothing to do with his sister?

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:26

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:19

Why are you wilfully pretending like you haven’t read my posts?

Both my posts talk ask about wanting to know if SIL has form for leaving out. If SIL regularly leaves OP out then of course that’s is going to inform OP’s thinking about why she feels annoyed.

It’s pretty horrible to accuse people of things without actually reading what they’re saying.

Presumably if that was the case then the OP would have mentioned that. She didn’t. Why are you inventing things?

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:29

nomas · 05/10/2026 11:56

I don’t think couples should tell each other everything, where did I say that?

I don’t tell my DH everything. My friends and family are entitled to their privacy, as is OP’s SIL.

But an upcoming baby is usually considered happy news, so most people would assume that if a brother is told the news, he will share the news with his wife.

If the SIL doesn’t want OP to know then the back story could be relevant. If the SIL has form for leaving OP out then in that situation I would want to take a step back from organising anything for the baby.

If SIL had wanted it to be shared with his wife then presumably she wouldn’t specifically have asked him not to do so at that stage. Why should he overrule her decision about whom the information should be shared and when? A trustworthy person would not dream of doing so, particularly as there are many legitimate reasons why she may not have wished him to do so.

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:30

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:26

Presumably if that was the case then the OP would have mentioned that. She didn’t. Why are you inventing things?

I didn’t invent anything, I asked OP ‘Does she have form for leaving you out?’

If you don’t understand the difference between a question and an invention then go off and do some reading, don’t waste my time.

And your attempt at a pile on is just bizarre.

ForTipsyFinch · 05/10/2026 12:31

That’s up to her. I think siblings have the right to being able to share things like that without a spouse being involved tbh 🤷‍♀️

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:31

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:29

If SIL had wanted it to be shared with his wife then presumably she wouldn’t specifically have asked him not to do so at that stage. Why should he overrule her decision about whom the information should be shared and when? A trustworthy person would not dream of doing so, particularly as there are many legitimate reasons why she may not have wished him to do so.

What part of ‘SIL is entitled to her privacy’ did you not understand?

If SIL doesn’t want OP to know, that’s her business.

OP can only control her reaction, not other people.

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:34

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:30

I didn’t invent anything, I asked OP ‘Does she have form for leaving you out?’

If you don’t understand the difference between a question and an invention then go off and do some reading, don’t waste my time.

And your attempt at a pile on is just bizarre.

As I said, if the SIL had been making her feel unwelcome in the family then presumably that would have been so pertinent to the issue that the OP would have mentioned it in her post. She didn’t. Therefore, it’s something you’ve invented that is not part of the AIBU we have been asked to judge.

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:36

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:31

What part of ‘SIL is entitled to her privacy’ did you not understand?

If SIL doesn’t want OP to know, that’s her business.

OP can only control her reaction, not other people.

My post was in response to this specific part of your comment;

But an upcoming baby is usually considered happy news, so most people would assume that if a brother is told the news, he will share the news with his wife.

4DCheckmate · 05/10/2026 12:36

nomas · 05/10/2026 12:19

Why are you wilfully pretending like you haven’t read my posts?

Both my posts talk ask about wanting to know if SIL has form for leaving out. If SIL regularly leaves OP out then of course that’s is going to inform OP’s thinking about why she feels annoyed.

It’s pretty horrible to accuse people of things without actually reading what they’re saying.

Ironic, given your posts on the thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread