Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to avoid birthday visitors and ask for gifts in advance?

146 replies

Hardyperennials · Yesterday 07:47

To ask you how you navigate other people’s birthdays and special occasions? To start, I know this is a 1st world problem but it’s something that’s been bothering me for a couple of years and I wonder if actually I need to be more chill about it.

I have always ensured that anyone in my family celebrating a birthday has had their gift / card before the day. So, what this looks like is me either posting or dropping off cards / presents in advance (a day or two) and letting that person know what I’ve done / checking it’s convenient. With my eldest child we actually used to laugh about her paternal grandparents desire to only give presents once they were in your company. When I say laugh, we found it a little annoying but didn’t get out of bed over it. But we did kind of agree that some people only want to gift give if they benefit from seeing someone open that gift. The eldest eventually became no contact with them and there was never a card or gift sent (even when the eldest was still technically a child and there hadn’t been a big fall out) Now, I have a younger child (about to turn 10) and I find myself with more people in my life like this. These people are kind and I know they don’t mean to be a pain but they all want to see my child on or very close to their birthday and as children get older they don’t want to sit in the house accepting guests for hours on end (one of these people has a tendency to over stay) do they?

Would you just accept that your child will need to spend a portion of their birthday at home in order to receive gifts from some family members? Would you mention to the family members that you would appreciate them being a little more organised in future so that you aren’t then trying to coordinate visitors on special occasions? For example, this is two different sides of the family that wouldn’t normally be in the same room, three separate households, not enough seats if everyone arrives at the same time etc. I’m currently leaning towards fobbing them all off on my child’s actual birthday (we will be busy it’s not a lie) and giving them the same time slot the day after so that they hopefully feel slightly uncomfortable and organise themselves a bit better next year. The adult child is the funniest to me, they have lived and showed annoyance at the inconvenience of people who do this and now do it themselves! I saw them 2 times recently and they are giving cash in a card so really did have time to sort this. But maybe they just want to see us on our birthday? I doubt they would like us descending on them for hours on their birthday though. And they seem really capable of organising themselves for their own birthdays.

What do you do? If you’re a visitor on the day, what is your motivation? I’ve never cared about watching someone open their gifts but then I’m not very sentimental.

OP posts:
Sirzy · Yesterday 07:50

You sound like hard work. You’re making a mountain ouf of a very small molehill.

people wanting to see your child around their birthday is nice! Don’t make them think otherwise

Sartre · Yesterday 07:52

I think people wanting to see the recipient open the gift is quite usual behaviour. If you can’t accommodate them on the actual birthday, make that clear in advance and arrange a day before.

RampantIvy · Yesterday 07:53

First post nails it.

YABVU @Hardyperennials

FiveShelties · Yesterday 07:55

Yes,do ask everyone for gifts in advance, I cannot wait to see the threads from your friends and relatives.😂

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 07:55

‘I’m not very sentimental’

no kidding.

modgepodge · Yesterday 07:56

This all seems like a lot of fuss about nothing! On both my husbands and my side of the family there is a bit variation each time - if my child is having a party and family are invited they’ll bring the present that day (this has never been on their actual birthday so far), or they may come visit but again not usually on the birthday, or they might post it. Birthdays often fall on school/work days so a visit on the day wouldn’t be possible (but my family aren’t local so visits are more of a big arrangement than a pop round just to drop a present off). If birthday fell on a weekend or holiday we’d almost certainly go out for the day.

i don’t think you’d be unreasonable to say you have plans on childs birthday but they are welcome to drop round before/after the date to give the present. I certainly don’t think the child’s birthday should be structured to sit around waiting for multiple family visits to be fair, I would find this expectation v odd.

OhIHaveACopy · Yesterday 07:57

It’s normal to give someone a present and then they open the present.

It’s not normal to allocate slots for visitors on birthdays when you want to do other things. That’s why people have ‘birthday tea’ or similar. This is obviously more difficult if you have people who don’t get on but this is why people have birthday parties. So the people who care about them can celebrate their birthday with them. It’s not supposed to be a miserable chore.

Quartzfairy · Yesterday 07:57

We used to invite family around on the child’s birthday! My children loved seeing their grandparents and would have been disappointed not to see them. If you have lots of people to coordinate, invite some lunchtime, some teatime, for example. Or if you’re going out for the day, invite them the following day. It’s really not difficult!

Lifelover16 · Yesterday 07:57

I think it’s cheeky to ask for gifts in advance. Take the day as it comes and go with the flow, it will all turn out fine.

AmethystDeceiver · Yesterday 07:57

I think you should create a shared calendar 'When you can bring me my present' for your family and friends. Everyone will really appreciate it @Hardyperennials

ShetlandishMum · Yesterday 07:58

Too precious...

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · Yesterday 07:58

I think if they’re close enough to the child to give them a gift why is it a surprise they’d like to see them or celebrate with them. Imo this is a nice and normal thing to do. It shows effort.

EatMoreChocolate44 · Yesterday 07:59

This is a bit bonkers OP. Most people wait until they see you on your birthday or another time if you're busy with other birthday plans to give you your present, spend time with you and of course watch you open it. I think most people wouldn't take it well if you said, actually we don't want to see you but could you just drop the present on the doorstep, thanks. 😂😂😂

thistimelastweek · Yesterday 07:59

Wow, I've never given that much thought to any birthday, including my own.

NolanChanceJustLikeTheWeatherNSoul · Yesterday 08:00

Mad as a box of 🐸🐸🐸

Midnightmoonface · Yesterday 08:01

This is a really odd take imo. It’s perfectly normal to give a gift in person.
You cannot seriously ask people to drop gifts off in advance of birthdays.

I actually feel this is often the parents wanting to piggy back on the large pile of gifts on the birthday morning and get the praise.

Personally I love people who have bought my children presents getting to see them open it. I teach my child birthdays aren’t about gifts so there is no issue with receiving a gift on the weekend when their see their aunt or whoever.

BlueMum16 · Yesterday 08:02

We tell everyone Cake is at 6.30 or whenever. They come then or they come day before/after

No sitting round all day.

If they struggle to be together that's on them.

It is usual to see the gift be opened and the person have opportunity to thank the giver themselves.

Hollowvoice · Yesterday 08:03

Are you seriously objecting to people taking time to come and give your child a present?

MajorSamanthaCarter · Yesterday 08:04

How to suck the mutual joy out of celebrating someones birthday 101!

Octopusk · Yesterday 08:04

Would you mention to the family members that you would appreciate them being a little more organised in future

Yes, this sounds like a great plan and not at all mad 😂

Fine to busy on the birthday. Not fine to deliberately make people feel uncomfortable for wanting to give your child a gift or spend time with them. Just try acting as if you don't hate everybody and see what happens.

Skatefordinner · Yesterday 08:10

Is this real? If so then yes as someone else has said, if you don’t want a family party you say - please come round for tea and cake at x time. If you don’t want to do that and don’t want your DC to have to be in to receive gifts that people have bought for them then tell them to please not worry about buying a gift for your DC this year. You can’t dictate everything!

CopeNorth · Yesterday 08:11

Just invite family round for tea and birthday cake on a day close to the birthday if you are busy on their actual birthday. they obviously want to see your DC to wish them happy birthday. That’s fair enough isn’t it. You have the house full for a couple of hours but you prevent lots of drop ins

HopAroundLikeKangaroos · Yesterday 08:11

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to give a time slot that’s convenient for you. Just say something like ‘we’ll be out from 11am to 5pm so if you want pop round it would be great if it could be from 9am to 11am or 5pm onwards’ or something like that.

Even if you aren’t going out it’s okay to say ‘it’d be lovely to see you over this 2 hour period’. If they are the type to just show up and not leave you could message them in advance to be really clear.

It is however really unreasonable to view family members as such an inconvenience you’d rather gifts be dropped off in advance to avoid interaction with them. Do you struggle more generally with assertiveness?

TallagallaPenguin · Yesterday 08:12

It’s normal to want to see a family member at some time around their birthday. Can’t always be on their actual birthday for many logistical reasons. It’s v nice so many family members want to give your child gifts.

Normal thing to do is to host a family birthday get-together to schedule this on your time, rather than having to vaguely be around for a couple of days for drop ins. Set a couple of hours aside for a family celebration. Done.

Baldrapunzel · Yesterday 08:13

Can't be real. Surely no one could be so daft?