Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OH wants custody of baby niece?

1000 replies

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 10:55

So OH's younger sister has recently had a baby and there is possibility that the baby may end up in care.

She already has an 18 year olds on who has lived with their mum since he was 8.

She dips in and out of his life, she even forgot his last birthday, she hasn't really been a mum to him at all. Despite this he has turned out to be a lovely, smart and hard working lad.

Everyone was so surprised by the pregnancy.

From what we understand she was kept in hospital for 2 weeks whilst some kind of team were getting stuff ready for the baby.

I think the hospital staff were monitoring and observing her interact with the baby and something must of been flagged?

Her mum has sold her house and was due to move abroad in September but she had been visiting her and the baby at the hospital daily and helping.

OH isn't really close to his sister but he is close to her son, he calls OH the "best uncle" as him and the other uncles have all chipped into help raise him.
OH would sometimes not see his sister for years and she was always changing her number and would have to talk to her though her son.

Anyway the family don't want the baby to end up in care but everyone has young kids themselves ( we have toddlers and are trying for a 3rd).

OH wants to go for custody but the care would really fall on me and I work from home and have a very flexible job.

Just wanted input on the situation as OH and the family don't want the baby to go into care

OP posts:
Imanautumn · 09/05/2026 23:59

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 10:59

I feel really sorry for the baby and would love to keep her in the family but I don't see how it would work.

It would also mean putting baby number 3 on hold.

Wouldn’t she be your number 3?

godmum56 · 10/05/2026 00:00

LellyLov2 · 09/05/2026 23:36

Put baby number 3 on hold …. A baby that’s already been born and on the verge of going in the system over you wanting another child ?

oh look, here's a spare puppy....

godmum56 · 10/05/2026 00:00

Imanautumn · 09/05/2026 23:59

Wouldn’t she be your number 3?

oh look here's a spare puppy

ThePieceHall · 10/05/2026 00:01

CANCEL THE CHEQUE. (So sorry for shouting).

Needspaceforlego · 10/05/2026 00:07

eotwaski · 09/05/2026 23:48

There's been a big gap between these two babies. She might not be capable of parenting on her own, she might be capable of parenting with support if she moved in with her mother. Sorting whether this is possible will come down to what social services determine and what support is available. None of this means that OP has to offer her life and service to taking on the baby however, which is the core of it.

If she wasn't capable of parenting a teen in the last 5 years ago do you really think she'll be capable of parenting a pre-schooler over the next 5 years.

The Gran has done encourage over the last 8 years or whatever she can't be relied on for the next 18 years

The teen moving into a council flat makes me think he's classed as a looked after child, care leaver.
Based on no councils seem to give houses out that easily unless its the roughest of areas that nobody wants to live in, with loads of empty properties.

Feels like lots of bits missing. But op can only make the right decision for her and her family

StrawberryStace · 10/05/2026 00:07

I would look at getting full custody of baby girl and she calls you mum (and also has a tummy mummy) so she grows up knowing the truth but she is the baby girl you always wanted.

So many people have 2 boys and try for their 3rd expecting a girl but it’s another boy. This is your chance to have your princess and make a difference to that little girls entire future.

If your sibling had a baby and needed you to take her would you?

LivingTheDreamish · 10/05/2026 00:10

If I was you, facing all these dilemmas, I would just keep an open mind for now. See what social services have to say (which may differ from SIL's story). Would you be looking at a full adoption, a fostering situation - as I agree it would be hard to co-parent with SIL. You could still have another of your own as well as taking on DN. Just don't feel pressured into it as raising someone else's baby is a big ask.

MNBV221 · 10/05/2026 00:47

Imanautumn · 09/05/2026 23:59

Wouldn’t she be your number 3?

Yes because non blood babies are totally interchangeable with a child you WANT to carry and give birth to aren't they 🙄🙄🙄

I just can't...

MNBV221 · 10/05/2026 00:56

StrawberryStace · 10/05/2026 00:07

I would look at getting full custody of baby girl and she calls you mum (and also has a tummy mummy) so she grows up knowing the truth but she is the baby girl you always wanted.

So many people have 2 boys and try for their 3rd expecting a girl but it’s another boy. This is your chance to have your princess and make a difference to that little girls entire future.

If your sibling had a baby and needed you to take her would you?

And would YOU be saying the same rubbish if the baby was a little Prince, and not a Princess <<vom>>

StrictlyCoffee · 10/05/2026 00:58

StrawberryStace · 10/05/2026 00:07

I would look at getting full custody of baby girl and she calls you mum (and also has a tummy mummy) so she grows up knowing the truth but she is the baby girl you always wanted.

So many people have 2 boys and try for their 3rd expecting a girl but it’s another boy. This is your chance to have your princess and make a difference to that little girls entire future.

If your sibling had a baby and needed you to take her would you?

So if he was a boy it’d be fine for him to end up in care, but not a girl? Have I understood you correctly?

StrictlyCoffee · 10/05/2026 01:01

Allisnotlost1 · 09/05/2026 21:26

JFC you’re back.

Where has anyone said the baby has high needs? Literally no-one - including OP - knows that.

Being removed from her mother will cause her to have high needs.

Lunde · 10/05/2026 01:33

Allisnotlost1 · 09/05/2026 21:26

JFC you’re back.

Where has anyone said the baby has high needs? Literally no-one - including OP - knows that.

The fact that the baby has spent 5 weeks in hospital suggests that there may be medical issues.

Allisnotlost1 · 10/05/2026 09:31

Lunde · 10/05/2026 01:33

The fact that the baby has spent 5 weeks in hospital suggests that there may be medical issues.

It could suggest that, and these could be temporary or long-term medical issues, or could suggest the mother has. We simply don’t know, so jumping to conclusions isn’t helpful.

Allisnotlost1 · 10/05/2026 09:32

StrictlyCoffee · 10/05/2026 01:01

Being removed from her mother will cause her to have high needs.

It’s not that simple, as I’m sure you understand.

Rosetyler1 · 10/05/2026 15:06

StrictlyCoffee · 10/05/2026 01:01

Being removed from her mother will cause her to have high needs.

That's not true, I'm not sure why people are insisting on this unscientific idea as if it's fact.

Tekknonan · 10/05/2026 15:33

It's easy to talk about putting children into care, but care, these days, means more or less writing off most children. Care is dire, and I speak as a witness. As far as you adopting this baby goes, how damaged is your niece? Is there likely to be pre-natal damage? Has she been able to form an attachment with at least one adult? The damage done in these early stages can't be under-estimated.

This child is part of your OH's family. Of course he should 'step up' and take on as much of the care as he can, but if you take this child, you will have to be prepared to be a mum for her just as much as for your own children.

It's a real dilemma and I feel for you, OP, but even if you say No, this situation won't go away. This baby now exists, wherever she goes, and will continue to be an important factor in your OH's mind.

RoseField1 · 10/05/2026 16:26

Tekknonan · 10/05/2026 15:33

It's easy to talk about putting children into care, but care, these days, means more or less writing off most children. Care is dire, and I speak as a witness. As far as you adopting this baby goes, how damaged is your niece? Is there likely to be pre-natal damage? Has she been able to form an attachment with at least one adult? The damage done in these early stages can't be under-estimated.

This child is part of your OH's family. Of course he should 'step up' and take on as much of the care as he can, but if you take this child, you will have to be prepared to be a mum for her just as much as for your own children.

It's a real dilemma and I feel for you, OP, but even if you say No, this situation won't go away. This baby now exists, wherever she goes, and will continue to be an important factor in your OH's mind.

Care does not mean 'writing off children' what an awful and wrong thing to say. Would you say that to the face of a couple waiting to adopt a child from care?

Allisnotlost1 · 10/05/2026 16:35

Tekknonan · 10/05/2026 15:33

It's easy to talk about putting children into care, but care, these days, means more or less writing off most children. Care is dire, and I speak as a witness. As far as you adopting this baby goes, how damaged is your niece? Is there likely to be pre-natal damage? Has she been able to form an attachment with at least one adult? The damage done in these early stages can't be under-estimated.

This child is part of your OH's family. Of course he should 'step up' and take on as much of the care as he can, but if you take this child, you will have to be prepared to be a mum for her just as much as for your own children.

It's a real dilemma and I feel for you, OP, but even if you say No, this situation won't go away. This baby now exists, wherever she goes, and will continue to be an important factor in your OH's mind.

You’ve written off the poor baby either way - ‘damaged’ already, and the prospect of going into care where she’ll be ‘written off’.

Lunde · 10/05/2026 16:37

Tekknonan · 10/05/2026 15:33

It's easy to talk about putting children into care, but care, these days, means more or less writing off most children. Care is dire, and I speak as a witness. As far as you adopting this baby goes, how damaged is your niece? Is there likely to be pre-natal damage? Has she been able to form an attachment with at least one adult? The damage done in these early stages can't be under-estimated.

This child is part of your OH's family. Of course he should 'step up' and take on as much of the care as he can, but if you take this child, you will have to be prepared to be a mum for her just as much as for your own children.

It's a real dilemma and I feel for you, OP, but even if you say No, this situation won't go away. This baby now exists, wherever she goes, and will continue to be an important factor in your OH's mind.

The baby isn't up for adoption though. ATM the baby's mother doesn't want to give up the baby.

Mermaidsarereal · 10/05/2026 17:00

I know a family who also took in their baby niece, they see her as a daughter and their children see her as a sibling. However, both adults wanted to take her in, so they have a lovely family set up. Is that what you want? Could you see yourself raising the child as your own and treat her exactly the same as your children? It’s not fair on the baby or you for that matter if not.

Cheesipuff · 10/05/2026 18:11

Why would the baby go into care - surely there are still many couples wanting to adopt a baby - it's the older children who go into care as far as i understand it.

PinkEasterbunny · 10/05/2026 18:27

This child is part of your OH's family. Of course he should 'step up' and take on as much of the care as he can, but if you take this child, you will have to be prepared to be a mum for her just as much as for your own children.

But WHY should he? Why specifically him when there are other family members (even though they seem to be off the hook as they have children, conveniently forgetting so does the OP …)

It would be a huge undertaking for anyone, and no one should feel obliged to do this. If someone suggested sharing a pet out amongst a family, it would be an insane idea, so heaven knows why it should work with a baby!

godmum56 · 10/05/2026 18:29

And still there is no reply to why none of the other sibs who also have young families, could take this child on.

JenniferBooth · 10/05/2026 18:46

milkshakess · 08/05/2026 21:40

So SIL was under the care of the mental health team during her pregnancy.

She had to be induced and then it was decided that it would be best for her to remain in hospital with the baby as the mental health team were liaising with the council into getting her settled as she was moving into a brand new house.

Concerns were noted and observed by the midwives in the hospital.
The baby and SIL are still in hospital with MIL visiting every day along side her son.

There at various organisations involved already and they are looking to see if anyone can take the baby.

With the nephew, she wasn't a very good mum to him, would neglect him, leave him with his nan for days to go out drinking etc.

When he was 8 his nan became responsible for him and she has dipped in and out of his life.

She took loans out in her mum's name and went off to New York for 3 months when he was 11 and didn't even call to check how he was.

Nephew has turned out into such an amazingly kind and smart young man. He is at college and has done so well BUT he has no parental figure in his life and he says this a lot to OH and me.

He tells OH that he is like his dad and OH will give him money, buy him stuff and take him out for food etc every week.

I am really torn and I know when I see the baby that I will want to keep her as I won't be able to face her getting put in care.

Before I had kids I had 5 cats, and I was adamant that I didn't want any more.

Then one day a little kitten came to my front door after being dumped by someone after Xmas and she would come every day following me around and I kept her in my greenhouse, insulated it and made it her home until I got her vaccinated, checked for FIV and when she was spayed she stayed in my bedroom to recover.

We took her to Cats Protection with the intent on having her rehomed but I didn't have the heart to say goodbye and I think this will end up happening with this baby.

But as others have pointed out I would want the baby to raise as my own and now have SIL dip in and out as she does with her son.
That would both be stressful and unfair.

I will know more weekend as we are going with MIL to the hospital.

Cant believe no ones picked up on the brand new house. Because a lot of ppl on this site certainly would have picked up on it had this been a pensioner we were talking about. The SIL does not even want the kid full time but gets the house that has been allocated to her because of it. So she would be under occupying no? Not having a go @milkshakess and your OH is expecting too much of you.

Needspaceforlego · 10/05/2026 18:52

Cheesipuff · 10/05/2026 18:11

Why would the baby go into care - surely there are still many couples wanting to adopt a baby - it's the older children who go into care as far as i understand it.

I guess part of it is not every child in the care system is up for adoption.

Hats off to anyone who fosters children but I just don't think I could do it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread