Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister is projecting her regrets onto me?

143 replies

TheAgileOP · 04/05/2026 18:47

DH (40) and I (40) have been together since we were 19 we met on our first day of uni. From the beginning we always said we didn’t want to rush into settling down and wanted to travel first, and that’s exactly what we did.
After graduating we spent about 18 months in South America volunteering, doing odd jobs, teaching in schools etc. I learnt Spanish (still fluent now) and we had an amazing time. We tried coming back and doing the whole city job thing but it just wasn’t for us, so we carried on travelling on and off for years.

We were very lucky financially I inherited about £300k from my grandad at 25 and DH had some money from a trust fund so we had the freedom to live like that.

We ended up getting married at 36 and had our first baby last August. I absolutely love being a mum and I’m so glad we had our son, but I’m also really glad we waited. I feel ready now and don’t feel like I’ve missed out on anything.

My sister is 3 years older than me and made very different choices. She also inherited a decent amount from our grandad but chose to use it to buy a house with her ex-husband. They got married at 27 had two children, and then divorced. She’s now remarried to someone who is genuinely lovely, so it’s not like she’s in a bad place now.

But over the years there’s been a definite undercurrent from her towards me, and more recently it feels like constant sly comments. When we were travelling she’d say we were “running away from real life”, when we came back and didn’t settle into careers she’d tell us to “grow up”, and when we got married later she made digs about it being “about time”.

Even during my pregnancy and birth she was quite judgemental. I chose to have a water birth with no medication (all approved and it went completely fine), but she made comments about that and about my age which just felt unnecessary.

Recently I mentioned we might like another child and she rolled her eyes, laughed and called me selfish, saying “you and him have had all this time just having fun and now you want to take things seriously?”

What I don’t understand is where this has come from. Growing up and well into our 20s we were really close genuinely close, no big fallouts, nothing bad between us at all. That’s why I find this shift so confusing.

Now it just feels like there’s a lot of judgement from her, and the only way I can make sense of it is that there’s some resentment there about how differently our lives have turned out. She had the same financial opportunities but chose a different path, and I do wonder if she has some regrets, even if she wouldn’t admit it.
I know I’m not completely innocent (I did say years ago she could have travelled before settling down, which she didn’t like), but this feels like more than that.

My sister is far more successful than I am and than I’ll ever be. I’m unsure why it seems as though she resents me.

DH and I are settled into our jobs. I work in policy in civil service and DH is head of maths at an independent school, we are so content with our life. My sister thinks I need to be more ambitious and says I seem lazy, she is on a very high income but seems quite judgmental on DH and I.

OP posts:
Isittimeformynapyet · 05/05/2026 06:30

Happytaytos · 05/05/2026 06:18

It sounds smug AF. "look at me with my no medication and perfect water birth". She's incredibly fortunate it all worked out well for her and there were no complications. It could very easily have been a different scenario. OP should be gracious about that because there are many women out there who would feel judged and inferior when told that story.

OP should be gracious about that because there are many women out there who would feel judged and inferior when told that story.

That would be their problem I'm afraid.

It would just be awful to keep positive birthing experiences secret because of other people's potential insecurities.

amargaritaplease · 05/05/2026 06:41

Happytaytos · 05/05/2026 06:18

It sounds smug AF. "look at me with my no medication and perfect water birth". She's incredibly fortunate it all worked out well for her and there were no complications. It could very easily have been a different scenario. OP should be gracious about that because there are many women out there who would feel judged and inferior when told that story.

It really does not sound smug AF, what an incredibly bizarre take on it.
you sound unpleasant @Happytaytos

Happytaytos · 05/05/2026 06:45

amargaritaplease · 05/05/2026 06:41

It really does not sound smug AF, what an incredibly bizarre take on it.
you sound unpleasant @Happytaytos

That's rude.

Perhaps I'm jaded by experience but those with "perfect births" do tend to share as often as possible with throwaway lines 'it was so essy' or 'I don't know what your problem was' or 'you didn't really give birth'.

Perhaps OP was being just factual but I can see how her birth story could rub her sister up the wrong way.

hidingmynuts · 05/05/2026 06:47

Shes bitter, jealous and insecure; no other explanation for it. She belittles your choices to validate her own because deep down, she didn’t have the balls to do what you did. If she was confident and comfortable with her own choices (which are perfectly valid ones), she wouldn’t say anything.

Yup- she's jealous and it's super obvious. You dont even have to have more than someone for them to be jealous of you because jealousy is about insecurity within themselves where they always feel lacking in something.

On threads where people feel jealous on MN I have never understood why people always defend it and say "it's completely natural to feel jealous!"- it's really not natural to spend your life eaten up with bitterness at all!

Yes, we all feel moments of jealousy at time but those feelings come and then they go, the fact this has now become your sister's personality is really, really sad and just shows how corrosive and harmful jealousy really is when you choose to marinate in it.

PolkaDotPorridge · 05/05/2026 06:53

I think you sound very smug and maybe she feels judged by you. She also sounds like a pain but maybe look at how you behave, it’s giving superior vibes here so she must feel that even more so. Why don’t you meet up to discuss it?

sparrowhawkhere · 05/05/2026 06:54

Perhaps it’s how you come across?
wording like ‘I chose to have a water birth with no pain relief’ because you were lucky to have a water birth, I chose the same but my baby had other ideas!

It does sound like you’ve landed on your feet a lot, travelling and still getting on the property ladder and getting a decent job, leaving it late to have children but still falling pregnant quickly (presumably), she sounds jealous but is it how you’re talking to her as well? I could be completely wrong, sorry if I am!

Happytaytos · 05/05/2026 06:55

sparrowhawkhere · 05/05/2026 06:54

Perhaps it’s how you come across?
wording like ‘I chose to have a water birth with no pain relief’ because you were lucky to have a water birth, I chose the same but my baby had other ideas!

It does sound like you’ve landed on your feet a lot, travelling and still getting on the property ladder and getting a decent job, leaving it late to have children but still falling pregnant quickly (presumably), she sounds jealous but is it how you’re talking to her as well? I could be completely wrong, sorry if I am!

Yes, it's the "I chose..." attitude. Like those who didn't have a water birth made shit choices.

Sartre · 05/05/2026 06:58

Well you have painted an incredibly rosy and perfect image of your life here so she’s undoubtedly jealous…

Velvian · 05/05/2026 07:00

I wonder if a lot of it is her new husband's opinions @TheAgileOP .

6AccomplishedWomen · 05/05/2026 07:01

She's jealous you've had all this fun and still landed on your feet.

hidingmynuts · 05/05/2026 07:01

Sartre · 05/05/2026 06:58

Well you have painted an incredibly rosy and perfect image of your life here so she’s undoubtedly jealous…

No she hasn't, she literally said: My sister is far more successful than I am and than I’ll ever be. I’m unsure why it seems as though she resents me

They both inherited significant sums of money - theyve both been fortunate here

Duckiewasthefirstniceguy · 05/05/2026 07:02

I’ve read this exact post before.

I'll repeat what I said the first time. Tell her to fuck off.

Preppyprepper · 05/05/2026 07:04

You don't sound like you understand her choices, and she doesn't understand yours.

For example, you have had your children later. I would have hated that, as the fun decade of your 30s you could have spent with your children. But it wasn't right for you, you would probably have hated having your kids at 30 when you could have been travelling etc.

I think you have posted on here because you want everyone to tell you how jealous your sister is, and what great choices you have made. Nah.

I would also be bored to tears listening to someone banging on about travelling in a baby group setting😂

SixAndJuliet · 05/05/2026 07:10

Is it me or is there not a lot in the OPs post that the sister has actually done or said wrong? Theres about 3 tactless/rude comments over a span of about 2 decades between sisters. The rest of it is OP talking about situational stuff.

Maybe she’s just making the odd throwaway comment when she’s had a bad day. Or maybe it is in response to comments made by OP to the sister, context being everything. OP clearly wants us to come to the conclusion that sister is jealous because the way it is written is very much set up that way, but a 40 year relationship between sisters will always be more complex than that.

youalright · 05/05/2026 07:10

6AccomplishedWomen · 05/05/2026 07:01

She's jealous you've had all this fun and still landed on your feet.

Why. What's to be jealous of do you think op will be jealous when she's still doing the school run and her sister has her freedom back. They've both been very fortunate and both have a home live with a partner and have children and a job they have pretty much the same life but have done it at different stages

Sartre · 05/05/2026 07:10

hidingmynuts · 05/05/2026 07:01

No she hasn't, she literally said: My sister is far more successful than I am and than I’ll ever be. I’m unsure why it seems as though she resents me

They both inherited significant sums of money - theyve both been fortunate here

Edited

Hmm except she travelled extensively with her husband for two decades before having a child, they met at uni and haven't got divorced unlike the sister, she had the perfect water birth she wanted, presumably the pregnancy and conception went well even at 40, her and DH have decent solid careers etc etc. I think she’s painted a pretty damn rosy picture of her life!

ThejoyofNC · 05/05/2026 07:12

You've obviously done a good job at painting her as the villain but I'd find you insufferable. From this post it's pretty clear you think you're so superior, going on about how you are just so different, you just had to travel the world and you had an unmedicated birth and god knows what else.

hidingmynuts · 05/05/2026 07:13

Sartre · 05/05/2026 07:10

Hmm except she travelled extensively with her husband for two decades before having a child, they met at uni and haven't got divorced unlike the sister, she had the perfect water birth she wanted, presumably the pregnancy and conception went well even at 40, her and DH have decent solid careers etc etc. I think she’s painted a pretty damn rosy picture of her life!

Her sister could have done all of those things but chose not to! You cant be jealous of someone for something you could have done but chose not to.

I agree with this poster:

They've both been very fortunate and both have a home live with a partner and have children and a job they have pretty much the same life but have done it at different stages

They have pretty much the exact same lives only theyve done it in different orders so whats to be jealous of, and why does that excuse the sister from making nasty comments?

Cheesipuff · 05/05/2026 07:17

Your sister was a happy, spoilt, greatly loved little girl then you had the nerve to come along and be born and steal some of the limelight - a crime never to be forgiven (ime experience of many first borns)!

DuskOPorter · 05/05/2026 07:20

Ask her

“What’s with all the judgement?”

or

”How do you feel when you make judgemental comments to me?”

Draw her attention to her behaviour. She is making you feel uncomfortable push it back onto her. She has no problem doing it to you.

Tsundokuer · 05/05/2026 07:20

SixAndJuliet · 05/05/2026 07:10

Is it me or is there not a lot in the OPs post that the sister has actually done or said wrong? Theres about 3 tactless/rude comments over a span of about 2 decades between sisters. The rest of it is OP talking about situational stuff.

Maybe she’s just making the odd throwaway comment when she’s had a bad day. Or maybe it is in response to comments made by OP to the sister, context being everything. OP clearly wants us to come to the conclusion that sister is jealous because the way it is written is very much set up that way, but a 40 year relationship between sisters will always be more complex than that.

Edited

I think I’ve read this Op before as well. If so, the op has a massive issue with her sister and basically wants MN to pile in and say that she (Op) did life exactly right and her sister is wrong, boring and jealous.

SixAndJuliet · 05/05/2026 07:30

Tsundokuer · 05/05/2026 07:20

I think I’ve read this Op before as well. If so, the op has a massive issue with her sister and basically wants MN to pile in and say that she (Op) did life exactly right and her sister is wrong, boring and jealous.

Edited

It is very familiar.

Birdsongsinging · 05/05/2026 07:31

Happytaytos · 04/05/2026 20:23

You do sound a bit smug and perhaps she's picking up on that attitude. Especially if you have made comments to her in the past, perhaps she feels OK to make comments back now.

(The worst part of your post was about your birth choices, you are very lucky that all worked out for you. I can see why your sister commented on that.)

I agree, it does sound like you think you and your partner have done it the best way!

Feis123 · 05/05/2026 07:39

Her marriage failed, you are still with your first love and happy - it trumps anything she has - can't you see it? Cut her some slack, she is jealous.

SonyaLoosemore · 05/05/2026 07:42

Are you coming back to this discussion you have started OP?
You sound quite smug which might be annoying your sister. Maybe she regrets some of her life choices. It isn't unusual around peri. You can challenge her about it if you want to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread