Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not provide my ex with a bag of stuff?

135 replies

PurpleJune · Today 08:42

Just want to sanity check this, because I'm sure I'm overthinking it.

Ex comes to see DC once a week and is only allowed to see them during the day, so he arrives by train and we meet him at the station. I provide a bag of essentials - nappies, creams, sunscreen, hats etc.

I'm frankly a bit fed up with providing this bag every week for his visits, as he's a grown man and needs to take some responsibility. I'm going to tell him that I won't be providing the bag any longer, and he'll have to bring what he needs for his visits with the DC.

AIBU if I do this? There's no question that he will provide that stuff, it's just we're going through all manner of court proceedings and I know he will weaponise anything and everything I do. The only reason this has continued for so long is that I've always been the organised and responsible one in the relationship, hence why he is my ex!

OP posts:
youalright · Today 09:43

WelshRabBite · Today 09:36

Do you also believe that Gisele Pelicot knew her husband was drugging and raping her? She was married to him for nearly 50 years.

Everyone i know who chose to bring innocent children into an abusive relationship. Where fully aware of what was going on but thought the innocent baby would fix everything. It pisses me off if you want to hang around an be spoke to like shit, be hit, threatened and feel like you're walking on eggshells and pretend its OK as he didn't mean it he was just tired, stressed, drunk, I annoyed him, then go for it but I am sick and tired of adults repeatedly putting children in the middle of it

PurpleJune · Today 09:44

I'm actually quite stunned at the attitude that I'm the one being selfish, that I should "pick my battles" and stop "point scoring". I'm also amazed that the same people are not applying these very rules to my ex, who turns up every week like he's king of the castle and gladly takes the bag he knows that I'll pack for him every week so he doesn't have to bother.

As I've said before and I'll say again - I would do anything for my children, and this has absolutely nothing to do with them. This is a relic of control left over from our relationship which I wish to abolish.

OP posts:
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · Today 09:44

AggroPotato · Today 08:49

Not unreasonable at all. Why should you have to do this?

Why? Because she loves her child and wants them taken care of - which bed may or may not to properly without the bag OP provides? Why? Because this is perhaps not the hill to die on in an acrimonious separation

ThreeGirl · Today 09:44

youalright · Today 09:43

Everyone i know who chose to bring innocent children into an abusive relationship. Where fully aware of what was going on but thought the innocent baby would fix everything. It pisses me off if you want to hang around an be spoke to like shit, be hit, threatened and feel like you're walking on eggshells and pretend its OK as he didn't mean it he was just tired, stressed, drunk, I annoyed him, then go for it but I am sick and tired of adults repeatedly putting children in the middle of it

You need to get some better friends.

Many abusive relationships start during pregnancy. It’s well documented.

BridgetJonesV2 · Today 09:45

It's not a hill I'd choose to die on, in honesty. I completely understand your logic, and he should be providing it, of course.

But it's the children who will suffer if he can't be bothered to change a nappy....

LoveHearts69 · Today 09:45

I’d maybe provide a bag of stuff as a one off that he can keep at his - so a bottle of suncream, a few changes of clothes that you don’t love, one pack of nappies and wipes and a bottle of calpol and tell him he will need to restock once anything runs out.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · Today 09:46

daffodilandtulip · Today 09:00

Not a battle I’d choose whist going through court.

💯

ThreeGirl · Today 09:48

If your mum’s doing drop off and collection anyway, you’ll need to pack a bag for her surely?

If the baby is dropped off in a dirty nappy without a sun hat, you can bet he’ll weaponise that.

BridgetJonesV2 · Today 09:48

You sound really stressed and angry, OP, but the sad reality here is that you chose to have children with this man and he will be in your life until the end of time. I wouldn't give him any ammunition against me, and I would point out in court that he won't even provide nappies during contact time. Use it against him.

Mankini · Today 09:50

LoveHearts69 · Today 09:45

I’d maybe provide a bag of stuff as a one off that he can keep at his - so a bottle of suncream, a few changes of clothes that you don’t love, one pack of nappies and wipes and a bottle of calpol and tell him he will need to restock once anything runs out.

This. And put it in writing via a text or email that this is now the arrangement.

PurpleJune · Today 09:52

BridgetJonesV2 · Today 09:48

You sound really stressed and angry, OP, but the sad reality here is that you chose to have children with this man and he will be in your life until the end of time. I wouldn't give him any ammunition against me, and I would point out in court that he won't even provide nappies during contact time. Use it against him.

After reading some of the more considered responses, I'm of a mind to continue supplying the bag because - as you say - it demonstrates how inept this man is as a parent. But I'm still surprised at much of the victim-blaming that excuses bad behaviour from one parent because the other has always picked up the slack. I will always pick up the slack for my children's sake. My point is, I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a man who believes himself to be a capable parent to take responsibility for our children once in a while.

OP posts:
ThreeGirl · Today 09:55

PurpleJune · Today 09:52

After reading some of the more considered responses, I'm of a mind to continue supplying the bag because - as you say - it demonstrates how inept this man is as a parent. But I'm still surprised at much of the victim-blaming that excuses bad behaviour from one parent because the other has always picked up the slack. I will always pick up the slack for my children's sake. My point is, I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a man who believes himself to be a capable parent to take responsibility for our children once in a while.

It’s not unreasonable. He should be providing what they need during his contact time. But you’re in a war with a man who is going to use everything he can against you, and this isn’t worth your energy.

daffodilandtulip · Today 09:58

BridgetJonesV2 · Today 09:48

You sound really stressed and angry, OP, but the sad reality here is that you chose to have children with this man and he will be in your life until the end of time. I wouldn't give him any ammunition against me, and I would point out in court that he won't even provide nappies during contact time. Use it against him.

And it will be pointed out right back, that the mother isn’t prepared to work with the father for the sake of the children. (Not saying this is what I think!)

MarieTheresevonWerdenberg · Today 09:58

abracadabra1980 · Today 08:53

If he's this irresponsible, I'd likely continue for the sake of your child. Pic your battles. You'll never 'teach him a lesson' by not providing it.

This.

Just not worth the potential aggro.

SecretSquid · Today 10:02

youalright · Today 09:43

Everyone i know who chose to bring innocent children into an abusive relationship. Where fully aware of what was going on but thought the innocent baby would fix everything. It pisses me off if you want to hang around an be spoke to like shit, be hit, threatened and feel like you're walking on eggshells and pretend its OK as he didn't mean it he was just tired, stressed, drunk, I annoyed him, then go for it but I am sick and tired of adults repeatedly putting children in the middle of it

Everyone you know who does this? How many dozens of people do you know who do this?
How much research have you done into DV?
Shame on you.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 10:04

HoldItAllTogether · Today 09:29

I’d carry on providing the bag. It’s hardly any bother for you really and it’s easier overall. I think it’s petty not to

How is the OP petty when she currently does everything for their child and he does nothing? How is it easy for her to provide the bag but not for him who is child-free for the rest of the week who I am sure has more time (and money) to provide the bag of essential items for his own child?

RobinEllacotStrike · Today 10:07

I would give him the bag one more time & tell him moving forward he needs to take care of packing for the childrens needs for the day.

Take a photo of the bag contents & you can use that if you need to instead of writing a list or whateever.

He will step up or not. Absolutely give it a go though - he is using this to further get to you.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 10:07

youalright · Today 09:31

I find it very hard to believe after living with someone 5/10 years that they suddenly have a complete personality transplant overnight. Everyone apparently has the perfect relationship then all of a sudden their ex is an abusive narcissist.

Victim blaming at its finest. OP has a non-molestation order against her abusive ex-husband yet the majority of posters seem to be on his side and accusing OP of being petty because it's so easy for her to provide the bag but so difficult for him for some reason.

MissyMooPoo2 · Today 10:12

AggroPotato · Today 08:49

Not unreasonable at all. Why should you have to do this?

For the sake of the child.

MaidOfSteel · Today 10:13

youalright · Today 09:31

I find it very hard to believe after living with someone 5/10 years that they suddenly have a complete personality transplant overnight. Everyone apparently has the perfect relationship then all of a sudden their ex is an abusive narcissist.

Are you for real? Where did it say that in any of the OP’s posts!

thepariscrimefiles · Today 10:16

youalright · Today 09:43

Everyone i know who chose to bring innocent children into an abusive relationship. Where fully aware of what was going on but thought the innocent baby would fix everything. It pisses me off if you want to hang around an be spoke to like shit, be hit, threatened and feel like you're walking on eggshells and pretend its OK as he didn't mean it he was just tired, stressed, drunk, I annoyed him, then go for it but I am sick and tired of adults repeatedly putting children in the middle of it

Often abusive and controlling behaviour only starts in earnest when the woman becomes pregnant. The abusive partner/husband feels safe to do this as it is so much more difficult for a woman to leave an abusive marriage when there are children involved and the woman will often think that it's best to remain in the marriage so she is always there to protect the children.

Your posts are very much 'you made your bed, so lie in in' and are completely lacking in any empathy or kindness towards OP who is a victim of domestic violence.

ThreeGirl · Today 10:17

thepariscrimefiles · Today 10:07

Victim blaming at its finest. OP has a non-molestation order against her abusive ex-husband yet the majority of posters seem to be on his side and accusing OP of being petty because it's so easy for her to provide the bag but so difficult for him for some reason.

There’s very little victim blaming, @youalright excepted. Most posters are saying to continue because doing so gives OP the upper hand in court proceedings, for minimal effort. If she sends her mum and the children without the bag, and her mum hands over a kid with a dirty nappy and clothes, don’t you think he’ll use that against her? Is it really worth arguing about in court and paying solicitors fees on?

OP is stuck with this abusive man for the next few decades. He’s highly likely to be awarded more contact time and will need to provide his own consumables then. She needs to focus on the bigger picture.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · Today 10:22

He shouldn’t need you to provide these items, I agree.

But (!) what’s the alternative? Will he step up or will your child simply return sunburnt, with a rash etc.?

This probably wouldn’t be the hill I’d want to die on. But I have never been in your situation, so… 🤷‍♀️

Catza · Today 10:30

PurpleJune · Today 08:58

I did mention in my OP that there's no issue with him providing these things, as long as I spell them out to him (he's a literal man-child). It's a relic of his control that he still "expects" me to do all this, because I'm a woman and therefore the person who "does this stuff". But if I say "you need to provide X, Y and Z", he will do it begrudgingly. I'm just curious about how other people handle it because I do feel like an a-hole, but I'm also sick of him still controlling me

It would be easier and faster to have a bag on standby than take on a mental load of reminding him every time, worrying whether he will do it and then potentially having to provide it anyway. He is your ex, you don't need to manage him. The bag is for your child, not for him.

FormerCautiousLurker · Today 10:31

PurpleJune · Today 08:52

@StrawberrySquash Yeah but I think it's just that for the best part of a decade I did everything in that relationship through his weaponised incompetence, and it's yet another way that he just expects me to pick up the slack even after we've split up.

Interestingly, he has often called looking after his own children "babysitting" which gives you an indication of what I'm dealing with 🙄

But weaponising his incompetence back doesn’t serve the needs of your child, though does it? It’s petty. Just provide a bag (which I assume you have on hand as it’s likely the one you use all week anyway, so not a hassle really) and save your energy for more important battles.

Swipe left for the next trending thread