Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't like Farage but..

460 replies

TheBlueKoala · Yesterday 05:35

I do agree with him that foreign nationals shouldn't be able to claim benefits and to scrap PIP for mild mental health issues. And that the money saved should go into mental health care so that everyone with mild mental health problems can access NHS care rapidly.

OP posts:
luckylavender · Yesterday 10:42

TheBlueKoala · Yesterday 05:35

I do agree with him that foreign nationals shouldn't be able to claim benefits and to scrap PIP for mild mental health issues. And that the money saved should go into mental health care so that everyone with mild mental health problems can access NHS care rapidly.

Don't like Farage but... imo it is wise to never believe a single utterance that passes his lips. Farage is not what this country needs

SpryTaupeTurtle · Yesterday 10:43

TheyGrewUp · Yesterday 09:24

Because the issue is that we need immigrants because the indigenous population doesn't want to work. That's the real issue imo.

I need to take issue with this. I worked for decades until some really horrible life stuff that I'm still recovering from meant that I couldn't. If you think that people from the UK don't want to work then go into your average supermarket or pub or any shop on the High Street and you'll see people that prove differently. My brother has been in the same job for 18 years now. He works full time. He was self employed doing the same job for a few years as well

This is just lazy trope bashing people on benefits - for no reason.

SerendipityJane · Yesterday 10:44

TheBlueKoala · Yesterday 05:35

I do agree with him that foreign nationals shouldn't be able to claim benefits and to scrap PIP for mild mental health issues. And that the money saved should go into mental health care so that everyone with mild mental health problems can access NHS care rapidly.

Why the fuck would anyone with two working brain cells that can talk to each other listen to a single word "Mr Brexit" ever says again ?

The is a word for people who are so desperate to find an acceptable cover for their racism that they are prepared to pretend they support a traitorous piece of shit like Farage.

The only think more dim (although it would be a close call) would be paying attention to Liz Truss on anything. Since our grandchildren will still be paying for her month in the sun.

IAmBeaIDrinkTea · Yesterday 10:44

SpryTaupeTurtle · Yesterday 10:14

Farage is popular with people who would send the Op home for being not from the UK. I have had a posted letter from reform this week and a leaflet. Both ripped up and straight in the bin

They also appeal to people who hate people like me - people on benefits (disabled).

The multi millionaire Farage doesn't care about anyone poor. People on benefits. Immigrants. People with mental health issues. According to the OP the savings would be invested in mental health care. The right wing parties want to slash benefits across the board - do people think they are going to invest in the NHS. Maybe go and read their manifesto. They want to get rid of it

Farage is popular with people who would send the Op home for being not from the UK

This
Baffles me, people like that. You're literally voting against yourself 😕

BeAmberZebra · Yesterday 10:44

TheyGrewUp · Yesterday 10:29

Unfortunately for a civilised society and fortunately for Nigel Farage (and golly the initials are scary in themselves), most Brits cannot analyse data. They cannot compute that the percentage of asylum seekers in the UK is vanishingly small. They cannot see that most in receipt of benefits are white/indigenous Brits. They cannot see that a high percentage of the NHS workforce, comparatively, comprises immigrants. They cannot even see that the NHS is only free at the point of delivery and every taxpayer pays for it.

Sadly the British public also did not see that the statistics during Covid indicated that a teeny tiny percentage of people died from Covid and that many of those who died did not die from Covid but with Covid. Based on very poor scientific analysis we allowed money to be printed and people's lives to be blighted by the social impact.

The scientists voicing reason were silenced. Some of the CoL crisis arises from the disproportionate reaction during that period. It was bizarre; but no more bizarre than the heightened sense of fear on MNet where most MNetters allowed themselves to be taken in, hook, line and sinker. But for some it was good, 80% pay and not much to spend it on and they didn't have to go to work. I'm sure that has had an impact on why so many people are claiming. Indeed there are threads on here where MNetters bemoan having to work and who look back fondly on the time they were furloughed.

Edited

Disagree with every word in your first paragraph. Totally agree with every word in your second two paragraphs. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Flymehomejeff · Yesterday 10:46

So foreign nationals are here on all sorts of different permits/visas and they have different access to benefits. I think it very unfair that some people might live here for years on some visas, pay the same NI as someone else and not be able to claim anything. My DH wasn't allowed to claim anything until he had settled status. Given that asylum seekers aren't allowed to work (stupid rule in my opinion) then yes I believe they should get benefits as many won't not be working out of choice.

Have you tried applying for PIP? I doubt it if you think someone gets if for mild mental health issues. If they do they are absolutely lying on their application and at interview.

Happyjoe · Yesterday 10:51

Seems he wants to get rid of the NHS for all of us, so hey, chose your battles.

BeAmberZebra · Yesterday 10:51

Flymehomejeff · Yesterday 10:46

So foreign nationals are here on all sorts of different permits/visas and they have different access to benefits. I think it very unfair that some people might live here for years on some visas, pay the same NI as someone else and not be able to claim anything. My DH wasn't allowed to claim anything until he had settled status. Given that asylum seekers aren't allowed to work (stupid rule in my opinion) then yes I believe they should get benefits as many won't not be working out of choice.

Have you tried applying for PIP? I doubt it if you think someone gets if for mild mental health issues. If they do they are absolutely lying on their application and at interview.

I think your final sentence is the concern most people have. There are advisors and webpages all over the place telling people what they have to say and do to get the resources they want but don’t really need.

SpryTaupeTurtle · Yesterday 10:52

And as a side issue. Farage is tapping into the immigrants are all bad narrative. I saw some stuff on Facebook that went viral a few months ago in my area - about how someone's daughter was too scared to open the door to a just eat driver because he was a "Black man". The inference being that "Black men" are out to harm women - these people will be voting reform or similar

This is someone working for a pittance self employed being trashed all over social media due to their skin colour.

We are at the point where people have no qualms about being openly racist. Not just Farage. Restore Britain and others tap into this narrative. They target immigrants. They target people on benefits. They target people who are vulnerable. There's reasons for that - setting people against one another.

Farage has been given far too much air time by the likes of the BBC. Even when his party had no MPs

BeAmberZebra · Yesterday 10:52

Happyjoe · Yesterday 10:51

Seems he wants to get rid of the NHS for all of us, so hey, chose your battles.

No he doesn’t. Just wants it to work.

TheyGrewUp · Yesterday 10:53

SpryTaupeTurtle · Yesterday 10:43

I need to take issue with this. I worked for decades until some really horrible life stuff that I'm still recovering from meant that I couldn't. If you think that people from the UK don't want to work then go into your average supermarket or pub or any shop on the High Street and you'll see people that prove differently. My brother has been in the same job for 18 years now. He works full time. He was self employed doing the same job for a few years as well

This is just lazy trope bashing people on benefits - for no reason.

OK, so why have I only been able to employ Eastern European cleaners and gardeners fkr the last 20 years, at £20ph and £35ph respectively? I'd love to employ people who were born and grew up here.

2dogsandabudgie · Yesterday 10:54

Alexandra2001 · Yesterday 08:38

Thats a very uncomfortable truth that Reformites/Tories/Brexitiers will never accept....

...but the reality is that Dublin Agreement allowed countries to deport asylum seekers back to the country they first registered in, applies to around 80% of cross channel migrants.
Why else did the x channel route balloon in popularity the moment we left the EU officially?

How many asylum seekers did we send back under the Dublin Agreement? I think you will find that it wasn't that many.

cantstopthinkingaboutit2 · Yesterday 10:54

IAmBeaIDrinkTea · Yesterday 10:44

Farage is popular with people who would send the Op home for being not from the UK

This
Baffles me, people like that. You're literally voting against yourself 😕

Wrong. Most Reform voters are not against immigrants who come and contribute to society, who work hard and abide by the law. The people who come via the legal channels, have a positive effect on society, and don’t just come here for state handouts.

I am not a Reform supporter by any means, but it’s easy to see why they are gaining support.

There are obviously some extreme racists who don’t like anyone ‘foreign’ but that is a small minority and you get those people in every corner of the world.

Pineneedlesincarpet · Yesterday 10:55

IAmBeaIDrinkTea · Yesterday 09:10

"Mild?" Who gets to decide what is mild and what isn't?!
Just sounds like a way of dumping on poor and chronically ill people more to me.
Not a CHANCE am I voting Reform. I value my health and the NHS too much, and the knowledge that there's help in the future if I need it benefits wise.
(Currently work full time and claim zero benefits.)

But benefits will always be available to the genuine claimant that is a citizen of the country who pay the benefits. You'll be fine if that applies.

MrTiddlesTheCat · Yesterday 10:58

Do foreign nationals get to pay less tax then if they're not allowed the benefits on the same basis as the natives?

2dogsandabudgie · Yesterday 10:58

TheyGrewUp · Yesterday 10:53

OK, so why have I only been able to employ Eastern European cleaners and gardeners fkr the last 20 years, at £20ph and £35ph respectively? I'd love to employ people who were born and grew up here.

That's a difficult question to answer without knowing your employee's circumstances. Are they married with children and have a mortgage or do they live in a shared house with other people so don't have large outgoings? How old are they? Are they just doing it for a few years and then going back home?

IAmBeaIDrinkTea · Yesterday 10:59

SpryTaupeTurtle · Yesterday 10:52

And as a side issue. Farage is tapping into the immigrants are all bad narrative. I saw some stuff on Facebook that went viral a few months ago in my area - about how someone's daughter was too scared to open the door to a just eat driver because he was a "Black man". The inference being that "Black men" are out to harm women - these people will be voting reform or similar

This is someone working for a pittance self employed being trashed all over social media due to their skin colour.

We are at the point where people have no qualms about being openly racist. Not just Farage. Restore Britain and others tap into this narrative. They target immigrants. They target people on benefits. They target people who are vulnerable. There's reasons for that - setting people against one another.

Farage has been given far too much air time by the likes of the BBC. Even when his party had no MPs

That's awful about the delivery driver 😓
Makes me think of that poor man who was just out in the park with his grandkids who was put all over social media as a "wrong un" and getting all sorts of disgusting racial abuse.
This is what the likes of Reform empowers.

BeAmberZebra · Yesterday 11:02

2dogsandabudgie · Yesterday 10:54

How many asylum seekers did we send back under the Dublin Agreement? I think you will find that it wasn't that many.

It was a tiny amount and most years we took in more than we sent back. There are numerous statistics demonstrating this clearly but it is still used as something to bash Brexit and Reform with.

Monty36 · Yesterday 11:02

One issue is that people often assume someone who is brown or black is an immigrant. But they are often born here now.
Britain turning brown is the issue for many who vote Reform. Many do not recognise those who are brown as being ‘of these islands’.
These islands identity is changing rapidly. Not just colour wise but culturally.

MsJinks · Yesterday 11:04

Flymehomejeff · Yesterday 10:46

So foreign nationals are here on all sorts of different permits/visas and they have different access to benefits. I think it very unfair that some people might live here for years on some visas, pay the same NI as someone else and not be able to claim anything. My DH wasn't allowed to claim anything until he had settled status. Given that asylum seekers aren't allowed to work (stupid rule in my opinion) then yes I believe they should get benefits as many won't not be working out of choice.

Have you tried applying for PIP? I doubt it if you think someone gets if for mild mental health issues. If they do they are absolutely lying on their application and at interview.

No - so every visa’d foreign national will have the starting point of ‘no recourse to public funds’. If they can’t live without those then they’d apply for destitution to have that no recourse lifted, if their claim is accepted.

Once you have ILR or settled status then that no recourse isn’t on it.

Some migrants may appear to get benefits as they have a British child - the British child is the one with a right to child benefit for example, as they’re umm British - this is sometimes added into certain stats of the numbers of migrants receiving benefits I’ve noticed - obviously some minor accounting error they didn’t mean I’m sure …

pipfs · Yesterday 11:05

People with mild MH problems are not getting PIP. Most peope are not gettiing PIP. Some people with genuine significant need are not getting PIP as the process is difficult and criteria is high. There is also criteria for foriegn nationals to be able to qualify, and they face the same assessment process as every other person.

HTH

From a PIP assessor.

MsJinks · Yesterday 11:05

MsJinks · Yesterday 11:04

No - so every visa’d foreign national will have the starting point of ‘no recourse to public funds’. If they can’t live without those then they’d apply for destitution to have that no recourse lifted, if their claim is accepted.

Once you have ILR or settled status then that no recourse isn’t on it.

Some migrants may appear to get benefits as they have a British child - the British child is the one with a right to child benefit for example, as they’re umm British - this is sometimes added into certain stats of the numbers of migrants receiving benefits I’ve noticed - obviously some minor accounting error they didn’t mean I’m sure …

Oh - and Asylum seekers get living expenses. If in a full board hotel for example they get £10 a week personal cash. If in a just bed provided place they get under £50 to include feeding themselves. It’s not benefits as such, ie not from DWP

LostThestral · Yesterday 11:07

you can judge a man by his friends, he'd have us in a war alongside that bungling idiot Trump in no time

BlackRowan · Yesterday 11:09

TheFrendo · Yesterday 10:02

The welfare bill is greater than the amount of money received in income tax.

The welfare bill simply has to come down, you can argue about how, but it must come down.

Th etwo simplest hits would be.

a) No access to benefits for foreigners.

b) Greatly reduce the amount of money people get paid for not working.

I cannot see a reductio in pension payments being politically possible for some years.

Foreigners don’t just get access to benefits. There are only limited cases like when they have indefinite right to remain (which is permanent residency). And new immigration reforms will make it even more difficult

MulberryBrandy · Yesterday 11:09

BeAmberZebra · Yesterday 10:41

All parties have supporters and donors who have concerns about many aspects of abortion. Some concern is mother’s health but a lot is that they believe abortion is murder. Some think that the stage of gestation is a critical point in the discussion. I don’t think this is a left right or party support issue. I am loathe to share my own views as I don’t want to be attacked and to be honest I am not sure what my views are and they change often. I support decriminalisation because the police went over the top and caused a lot of harm with their prosecutions but I’m not sure I support abortion at any stage. I wish we lived in a world where abortion just didn’t happen but we don’t, but I think it’s a complex, sad and depressing issue and really shouldn’t be regarded as a party political point but a deep societal issue which many aspects of are neither discussed nor dealt with.

"I’m not sure I support abortion at any stage"

The main point here is that Farage's UK Head of Policy, James Orr, opposes it at every stage and under all circumstances

Swipe left for the next trending thread