Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Should I ask my DS and his girlfriend for money

733 replies

DiaryofWimpy · 17/03/2026 19:43

My DS2 has moved his girlfriend in with her 2 cats.

Obviously it’s another person using the washing machine,,TV, gas and electricity they are both 22 and don’t work but get benefits.

Do you think I’m being unreasonable asking them for money?

OP posts:
QuaintMauveCrow · 18/03/2026 12:08

firstofallimadelight · 18/03/2026 12:05

@DiaryofWimpy
i hope you have stopped reading love.
None of us know how your bipolar impacts and it’s not for mn to decide you should be in work when they don’t know anything about you.
wether your son and his gf need to find work is debatable (based on your posts) but not your responsibility as they are both grown adults.
You asked should they contribute and the answer is yes they should. You have spoken to them and they have agreed to do so. So really your question has been solved.
There’s not really a need for further criticism/ judgement from mn.
Hope you are ok.

🩷

purpleygrey · 18/03/2026 12:10

Malasana · 18/03/2026 09:22

Good grief.
Maybe getting jobs would be good for the mental health of all 3 of you. It can’t be good for you all lolling about with no purpose.
Apologies if this sounds hard but people with all manner of disabilities both mental and physical work. Myself included.

i fully agree!!

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:11

4wardlooking · 18/03/2026 12:06

Being late for a meeting to discuss employment, is the equivalent to being late for an actual job, it's not acceptable. Some places fire those who are late to work, you're lucky you only got a sanction.

I know the government won't find people jobs. I do wish the allocation of jobs for the unemployed, but able bodied, was a thing though. It would really help people's MH if they were given work to-do.

I didn't get a sanction. You clearly didn't read my post.

By the way. I worked for decades before going on UC. Don't bother telling me I was "lucky" to get a sanction or lecture me on timekeeping when I didn't actually get one and you have absolutely no idea what what I was dealing with in my life at that point as well.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:13

4wardlooking · 18/03/2026 12:06

Being late for a meeting to discuss employment, is the equivalent to being late for an actual job, it's not acceptable. Some places fire those who are late to work, you're lucky you only got a sanction.

I know the government won't find people jobs. I do wish the allocation of jobs for the unemployed, but able bodied, was a thing though. It would really help people's MH if they were given work to-do.

However it's completely acceptable for people going to meet their work coach to be sitting waiting for up to twenty minutes - because they are running late.

ParmaVioletTea · 18/03/2026 12:14

Mangelwurzelfortea · 18/03/2026 11:17

The OP is on benefits too. She has bipolar. Which let's face it has modelled to her son that you don't actually need to work.

There's a huge difference between being bipolar and having generalised "anxiety."

I used to work with someone who was bipolar - they could be a pain sometimes as they could be unreliable & unpredictable, but they kept working. When they were healthy, they were amazing!

And a big up and Flowers to all the PPs on this thread who keep on keeping on. I salute you!

muddyford · 18/03/2026 12:15

I always thought that's what benefits were for, paying for living expenses.

tara66 · 18/03/2026 12:20

OP re. DS - a very good cure for anxiety is a good sense of humour - that has seen me through many disasters - and I do mean very bad things. There can usually be an ironic side to most things.
Don't let the bastards get you down!
Has DS considered the army? He might adore it! - I understand defence is being strengthened - so may be jobs there.
Force positivity onto them and things like going for runs at 6am/cold showers etc!! They need a regime at their age. OR they may just move out.
Don't get too attached to the cats.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:21

tara66 · 18/03/2026 12:20

OP re. DS - a very good cure for anxiety is a good sense of humour - that has seen me through many disasters - and I do mean very bad things. There can usually be an ironic side to most things.
Don't let the bastards get you down!
Has DS considered the army? He might adore it! - I understand defence is being strengthened - so may be jobs there.
Force positivity onto them and things like going for runs at 6am/cold showers etc!! They need a regime at their age. OR they may just move out.
Don't get too attached to the cats.

Yes that's right. All you need to cure anxiety is a sense of humour. Cold showers and 6 am runs will cure you

Shatteredallthetimelately · 18/03/2026 12:22

Happyjoe · 18/03/2026 11:17

Thing is we need a fool-proof way to weeding out the genuine to the chancers. Until that happens I don't want anyone in need, genuine need to suffer because of others ruining it. Tbh, am not sure that's possible.

While I agree I don't think its something that the government are interested in doing, why would they be?

They really aren't in office to be bothering with those that don't agree with their policies, they have nothing to lose by continuing to let generation after generation follow suit, come a time though those cheating the system will put the blame on how their lives turned out on those that sat by and let it happen, accountability for those is also dying out.

Same with those parents that know their DC are capable but make excuses for them, they know no different.
From someone that's now in their later years I've seen it coming over the last 30 or so years years.

We pretty much must all know of a family/families that cheat the system.

dizzydizzydizzy · 18/03/2026 12:25

Bernycycles · 18/03/2026 11:39

It’s very easy to game the system. If it’s anything like JSA was (which I was on for a total of a year or so during my 20s) proving you’ve applied to jobs is easy work. Doesn’t mean you’ve applied to job you realistically can get or put a good effort into the application etc.

I would imagine they have toughened up enormously. I am on Universal Credit (but not looking for a job due to serious illness). Even with me, they are constantly asking for 4 months of bank statements, council tax bills and (rather bizarrely), I keep having to send them my rental contract even though all my bank statements and council tax bill show my address has not changed and that I pay the rent every month. They treat all claimants like we are trying to claim fraudulently even in cases like mine when they have the proof that I have always been 100% open and honest.

Based on the way they have treated me, I would assume they demand detailed evidence of job search activities and interview each claimant in depth about what they are doing to look for work.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:32

dizzydizzydizzy · 18/03/2026 12:25

I would imagine they have toughened up enormously. I am on Universal Credit (but not looking for a job due to serious illness). Even with me, they are constantly asking for 4 months of bank statements, council tax bills and (rather bizarrely), I keep having to send them my rental contract even though all my bank statements and council tax bill show my address has not changed and that I pay the rent every month. They treat all claimants like we are trying to claim fraudulently even in cases like mine when they have the proof that I have always been 100% open and honest.

Based on the way they have treated me, I would assume they demand detailed evidence of job search activities and interview each claimant in depth about what they are doing to look for work.

You have to update your journal. They expect a 5/6 day updated journal showing what you've been doing to find work and can ask for evidence

It's not been my experience that they treat everyone as if they were claiming fraudulently but it's nothing like the old JSA

LakieLady · 18/03/2026 12:36

Silverbirchleaf · 17/03/2026 21:40

Yes , you charge them rent. They’re 22! Even £150 each a month is better than nothing. You shouldn’t be expected to Clothe and feed them. Guess they’re not doing any household chores either. Cocklodger red flag.

They'll only get £500 a month in UC as an U25 couple (unless they've been found to be too unwell to work or look for work), so that would leave them £100 each to feed and clothe themselves, buy toiletries etc. I daresay it's doable, but it would be tight.

But it's not your responsibility to house and feed 2 adults, OP!

Tarkadaaaahling · 18/03/2026 12:36

Bernycycles · 18/03/2026 09:19

Many people with bipolar and GAD work. I have mental health issues and worked for most of my life.

Just as I thought this is learned behaviour. I saw my mother working despite being a single mum from an immigrant background battle prejudice and her own mental health issues, so it was never an option in my head to be on benefits as an ongoing thing.

This is the young man you’ve raised in a certain way and you’re seeing the outcome of that now. And so the cycle continues…

Agree with this. I knew when people were asking if OP works herself the answer would be no - this situation seems to arise way more frequently when young people have no example set for them of an adult working.

I've worked with several people with bipolar/GAD /both. It's hard yes but it's absolutely possible to work.

I suspect this lad has no example to follow to understand that life costs money.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:38

Tarkadaaaahling · 18/03/2026 12:36

Agree with this. I knew when people were asking if OP works herself the answer would be no - this situation seems to arise way more frequently when young people have no example set for them of an adult working.

I've worked with several people with bipolar/GAD /both. It's hard yes but it's absolutely possible to work.

I suspect this lad has no example to follow to understand that life costs money.

She didn't post to get advice about her bipolar or working

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:38

The OP has also said her son gets other benefits. I assume he's been assessed as unfit to work

Bananalanacake · 18/03/2026 12:42

Are they going to look for work at some point or just waste their whole lives.
How long were they in a serious relationship when they decided to live together, if it was under a year it might not last that long.

4wardlooking · 18/03/2026 12:43

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:13

However it's completely acceptable for people going to meet their work coach to be sitting waiting for up to twenty minutes - because they are running late.

Yes, because they are working! The same as when you go to the doctor’s you may have to wait 20 minutes because they’ve overrun with their previous appointment.

LakieLady · 18/03/2026 12:46

Ilikewinter · 18/03/2026 07:36

Why are they paying different amounts? , I would charge them both the same. and I'm sorry, I know he's your son but there's no way they should be able to claim benefits for anxiety. This country is a joke.
Anyway, it's good you've had the conversation and sounds like your happy.

"Anxiety" is a very imprecise diagnosis. I've worked with clients whose anxiety is so severe that they can't interact with anyone they don't know without showing clear signs of being extremely anxious, eg, shaking, sweating, going very pale and being unable to communicate effectively.

It can be an awful lot more than just being generally worried. And I don't think anyone would get through the capability for work assessment if they were just generally worried. But yes, if they're generally just a bit nervous, it's taking the piss.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:46

4wardlooking · 18/03/2026 12:43

Yes, because they are working! The same as when you go to the doctor’s you may have to wait 20 minutes because they’ve overrun with their previous appointment.

Anything else you would like to say to me? I mean your attitude has come across loud and clear that you think I deserved a sanction - when the decision maker thought otherwise.

Labelledelune · 18/03/2026 12:47

DiaryofWimpy · 17/03/2026 19:47

They apparently have anxiety so can’t work.

He asked if she could bring her cat, she brought 2.

Yes I could do need the money.

So if you are ok with paying for 3 people’s water, electric, gas, heating etc then crack on. I have been in this situation so I’m going to say it plainly. Do NOT enable this and that is what you are doing. Throw them both out ( I wish someone told me this years ago). How dare they. This has brought back memories and made me angry at how weak and used I felt. Please for your own sanity make them pay at least £700 a month or thrown their lazy arses out.

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:48

Labelledelune · 18/03/2026 12:47

So if you are ok with paying for 3 people’s water, electric, gas, heating etc then crack on. I have been in this situation so I’m going to say it plainly. Do NOT enable this and that is what you are doing. Throw them both out ( I wish someone told me this years ago). How dare they. This has brought back memories and made me angry at how weak and used I felt. Please for your own sanity make them pay at least £700 a month or thrown their lazy arses out.

For goodness sake. She's asked them for a contribution and they are giving it. People under 25 on UC get 316 pounds a month unless they are on disability benefits too. Why should her son be thrown out?

LemonFancy · 18/03/2026 12:50

Labelledelune · 18/03/2026 12:47

So if you are ok with paying for 3 people’s water, electric, gas, heating etc then crack on. I have been in this situation so I’m going to say it plainly. Do NOT enable this and that is what you are doing. Throw them both out ( I wish someone told me this years ago). How dare they. This has brought back memories and made me angry at how weak and used I felt. Please for your own sanity make them pay at least £700 a month or thrown their lazy arses out.

Well no, she’s not happy with that. That’s why she started this thread and, since starting it, has asked them for a contribution.

4wardlooking · 18/03/2026 12:51

MyLimePoet · 18/03/2026 12:11

I didn't get a sanction. You clearly didn't read my post.

By the way. I worked for decades before going on UC. Don't bother telling me I was "lucky" to get a sanction or lecture me on timekeeping when I didn't actually get one and you have absolutely no idea what what I was dealing with in my life at that point as well.

No you’re right. I have no idea what you were dealing with.

I have been on anti-depressants for coming up to 20 years and have worked full-time throughout. At one point - for 4 years - I had two jobs. The bills had to be paid and the kids needed funding. So I’ve soldiered on throughout.

I do understand our lives are different though.

nochance17 · 18/03/2026 12:52

Yes charge them and make sure they do their fair share around the house. Their entitlement to benefits might change as they now live with you , have they reported a change in circumstances? I would set a time limit on them living with you, maybe 3 months to sort out their issues, get jobs and move out otherwise they might be there for the rest of your life, especially if she gets pregnant. Im sorry but I think she has seen your son coming, is she there because she wants him or because he has offered her a way out of her previous relationship and a ready made home. You need to let them know they cannot take liberties and they need to live by your rules. Nobody would take over my house. If you’re not careful you will soon feel like a lodger in your own home. Take control.

MajorProcrastination · 18/03/2026 12:53

Is the household just you and the two of them?

I'd sit down and have a chat about the full household responsibilities. Include the breakdown of the household bills, chores and other responsibilities. They are both adults and they need to be adults in the household even though one's your child.

I know they're not working but the assumption from the benefits system is still that adults will be paying their way in a household. It doesn't mean splitting the costs 3 ways but it does mean them knowing exactly what you're paying out.

They need to learn these things because they can't live with you forever like this.

If they're not working and you are, they could definitely take on more of the household chores and maintenance which aren't impacted by any disability.

Swipe left for the next trending thread