Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Farage promises to deport people with ILR

1000 replies

Acidburn · 22/09/2025 12:21

Posting in AIBU for traffic.
Nigel Farage stated he would deport anyone with existing indefinite leave to remain. We are talking about millions of people.
This terrifying. If people live here, work here, have kids and mortgages - where are they supposed to go?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:05

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:00

Aah, so now, because certain aspects of the service level offered by a hotel that has been advertised as 4 up until its closure for use by asylum seekers are no longer available, you are claiming that asylum seekers are not being put into 4 hotels??

A bit of a desperate reach, no?

As you can see, the standard of amenities are quite important in the rating:

From the London Hotel website.

A 4 star hotel is defined as a hotel that provides above-average, deluxe service and experience for the guest. A 4 star hotel has a larger range of facilities available and the design is high quality. All service standards are aimed towards pleasing the guest. A 4 star hotel may have some of the following features:

  • A clearly designated reception area, open 24 hours a day
  • A restaurant or dining area that serves breakfast and dinner throughout the week
  • A liquor license and an area where beverages can be served
  • Room service available 24/7, with a cooked breakfast and full dinner option
  • A phone and WiFi service in every room
  • A fitness centre, a spa, or a swimming pool on-site or nearby
  • A concierge service, luggage assistance, and laundry service
  • Spacious and well-furnished rooms, with a minibar, a safe, a work desk, and a flat-screen TV
  • High-quality bed linen, towels, and bath products
  • Extra services, such as afternoon tea, welcome drinks, or turndown service

And you think all that is still being provided and hotel staff is there to provide it?

Really?

Maybe get yourself on one of those Farage Brexit Boats

Onegingerhead · 22/09/2025 22:10

Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

Farage did say anyone under 60K should go.
I’m guessing this is the cut of between a leech and non leech

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:11

BadgesforBadgers · 22/09/2025 21:29

This post is so embarrassing.

A 4 star hotel is rated as such due to the services it provides.

Do you really think a 4 star hotel used to house asylum seekers still roles out the best linen, offers spa treatments and has a heated swimming pool? Still has a lovely breakfast buffet?

From reliable sources ( as of which James O'brien definitely is ) , can you name me country manors that have cancelled weddings so they can host asylum seekers?.

A couple in Leicestershire have been left heartbroken after their hotel wedding venue cancelled their big day, because it was 'acquisitioned for a Government contract'.
Steph Grant and her fiancee Tom Moulding believe their wedding was cancelled as the Quorn Country Hotel will be closed and instead be used to house asylum seekers.

Devastated couples had their weddings cancelled after the hotel they were using closed suddenly to house asylum seekers.
The Best Western Cresta Court Hotel in Altrincham - owned by a group chaired by former BBC director-general Greg Dyke - was shut to paying guests on Monday after being turned over to accommodate almost 300 migrants.

A couple's wedding has been cancelled by a hotel that is being used to house asylum seekers.
Lucie Campbell and Simon Pritchard booked their wedding for 10 December more than a year ago.
But they were left with just days to find a new venue after discovering the Aberconwy hotel is being used to ease overcrowding at Kent detention centres.
Ms Campbell, 28, of Towyn, Conwy, said she was in "disbelief" but has managed to reorganise their special day.
The hotel, which the BBC is not naming for safeguarding reasons, is providing short-term accommodation as part of a project that began last week.

Where did I say that they would still offer spa treatment? You’re being ridiculous. They still have to put sheets on the beds, staff the restaurant to feed the men and do the cleaning.

Quibbling that a previously advertised 4 hotel is no longer a 4 hotel because some services may have been withdrawn but replaced with things like free private health and dental care (yes, I’ve got evidence of that too before you dig further into your denial) is pretty desperate - honestly.

MsJinks · 22/09/2025 22:13

Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

Oh dear - they actually do - just they spin a bit of apparent decency and fake common sense in.
What if someone falls ill? Not earning enough just in the time the reapplication is due?
What if their business isn’t doing that well suddenly?
What if your partner, kids, parents fall to needing care? And your earnings that year fall slightly below the required threshold.
Well, seems like it will be no visa, don’t pass go, and leave now. Whether they give appeal rights, 14/28 days to leave or something different is yet to be invented of course.
It’s not so easy to be assured nothing will ever impact your work, even temporarily. And what when you reach pension age?
Let alone the healthcare costs that will come in.

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:14

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:11

A couple in Leicestershire have been left heartbroken after their hotel wedding venue cancelled their big day, because it was 'acquisitioned for a Government contract'.
Steph Grant and her fiancee Tom Moulding believe their wedding was cancelled as the Quorn Country Hotel will be closed and instead be used to house asylum seekers.

Devastated couples had their weddings cancelled after the hotel they were using closed suddenly to house asylum seekers.
The Best Western Cresta Court Hotel in Altrincham - owned by a group chaired by former BBC director-general Greg Dyke - was shut to paying guests on Monday after being turned over to accommodate almost 300 migrants.

A couple's wedding has been cancelled by a hotel that is being used to house asylum seekers.
Lucie Campbell and Simon Pritchard booked their wedding for 10 December more than a year ago.
But they were left with just days to find a new venue after discovering the Aberconwy hotel is being used to ease overcrowding at Kent detention centres.
Ms Campbell, 28, of Towyn, Conwy, said she was in "disbelief" but has managed to reorganise their special day.
The hotel, which the BBC is not naming for safeguarding reasons, is providing short-term accommodation as part of a project that began last week.

Where did I say that they would still offer spa treatment? You’re being ridiculous. They still have to put sheets on the beds, staff the restaurant to feed the men and do the cleaning.

Quibbling that a previously advertised 4 hotel is no longer a 4 hotel because some services may have been withdrawn but replaced with things like free private health and dental care (yes, I’ve got evidence of that too before you dig further into your denial) is pretty desperate - honestly.

A few years back, a local hotel got sold by their owners and all staff was made redundant, weddings and other stays were cancelled.

It happens

It didn't become a asylum hotel, it jsut stood empty for a while

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:15

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:05

And you think all that is still being provided and hotel staff is there to provide it?

Really?

Maybe get yourself on one of those Farage Brexit Boats

Try reading my post again. I clearly didn’t say that. 🙄

Just admit that they are being put into 4* hotels - the facts are out there. Pretending they are not just looks desperate.

MaidOfSteel · 22/09/2025 22:15

HJBeans · 22/09/2025 21:31

I wasn’t intending to be patronising and didn’t call you a bigot. You seemed sensible but have a very different view of this than I do and I wanted to understand how / why our views differ. Asking about the cost / benefit of immigration was a genuine question, as I haven’t dug into the costs myself.

My assumption from my side of the issue is that you could crack down on immigration in the draconian ways Farage suggests - and bring all the labour shortages and human suffering that would entail - and still have a threadbare NHS and public services that are not fit for purpose. Even including family members who are not working, I do not think those sums would add up. But I admit I haven’t checked them which is why I asked if you had. Certainly someone should before we make policy that impacts millions of lives based on assumptions.

I think immigration is a red herring which savvy politicians are using to divide us and distract us from those multi-millionaires you mention creating wealth from our country and paying fuck all tax. Much like the Covid profiteers and tax-avoiding politicians, I can’t understand why those hoarding and off-shoring wealth are not the common enemy of everyone upset about the state of the country.

Targeting immigrants seems to me to be punching down at people who are often the weakest in society (and who we depend on to care for our young, our sick and our elderly) rather than holding the strongest to account for the mess their greed and mismanagement has created. I’m explicitly not saying people who disagree with me are bigots or deserving to be patronised, but I do want to understand why there’s so much public anger about immigrants and seemingly so little about tax-avoidance and public sector profiteering. There could be enough money to support everyone if those who make huge profits from our country paid sensible amounts of tax.

Edited

As you can see in my post, I’ve taken profiteering people/companies into account. I think I’m fairly level headed and that’s why I get upset with many of the posts on here, and from both sides. In fact, I used to be quite a leftie, donating to charities helping asylum seekers & refugees. But the last couple of years have changed some of my thoughts & opinions. Seeing what is happening in poorer areas, like the one I grew up in, has shocked me.

This is the worst economic situation I can remember and I don’t see any way forward. I just feel despair. The extra 400k- 1m people, mostly earning minimum wage, that we’re adding year on year do use, mostly, state schools, the NHS etc. We need action on this, and action on the tax evaders. I don’t want to see us taken out of the ECHR, those are my rights too, but I don’t want to see judges letting criminals stay for crazy reasons just because they can, while appearing to not take into account community safety.

I firmly believe there must be better ways to reform the immigration situation. We shouldn’t need to resort to extremes, like adding a million people every year, to deporting millions. I do understand, though, why people are so bloody angry and looking for alternatives. No-one has been listening, especially to the poorer parts of society where the burden is heaviest.

SuffolkSun · 22/09/2025 22:16

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:00

Aah, so now, because certain aspects of the service level offered by a hotel that has been advertised as 4 up until its closure for use by asylum seekers are no longer available, you are claiming that asylum seekers are not being put into 4 hotels??

A bit of a desperate reach, no?

As you can see, the standard of amenities are quite important in the rating:

From the London Hotel website.

A 4 star hotel is defined as a hotel that provides above-average, deluxe service and experience for the guest. A 4 star hotel has a larger range of facilities available and the design is high quality. All service standards are aimed towards pleasing the guest. A 4 star hotel may have some of the following features:

  • A clearly designated reception area, open 24 hours a day
  • A restaurant or dining area that serves breakfast and dinner throughout the week
  • A liquor license and an area where beverages can be served
  • Room service available 24/7, with a cooked breakfast and full dinner option
  • A phone and WiFi service in every room
  • A fitness centre, a spa, or a swimming pool on-site or nearby
  • A concierge service, luggage assistance, and laundry service
  • Spacious and well-furnished rooms, with a minibar, a safe, a work desk, and a flat-screen TV
  • High-quality bed linen, towels, and bath products
  • Extra services, such as afternoon tea, welcome drinks, or turndown service

And you really believe that some asylum seekers, being put up in buildings previously run as 4* hotels, have minibars and 24hr room service, are provided with high-quality bath products and linen, and that the management comes to turn down their sheets at night and leave a chocolate on the pillow? Apparently you do. Are you usually this gullible.

Hotels are privately owned businesses. If a hotel owner decides to sign a contract with government to house asylum seekers, and cancels wedding reception bookings already taken to do so, that's on the hotel owner, not the government or asylum seekers.

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:17

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:15

Try reading my post again. I clearly didn’t say that. 🙄

Just admit that they are being put into 4* hotels - the facts are out there. Pretending they are not just looks desperate.

They are put in former 4* hotels

peasporrige · 22/09/2025 22:17

MsJinks · 22/09/2025 22:01

Goodness! How terrible.
Anyway - you’ve flagged a further saving, those in care homes are allowed £30 a week pocket money, not sure why they need that - and don’t be deluded good old Reform won’t notice that as they work through their book of undesirable people we can stop funding.

The amount of "spend" allowed in care/nursing homes varies with area ;-

  • England: £30.65 per week
  • Scotland: £35.90 per week
  • Wales: £44.65 per week (in Wales it’s called Minimum Income Amount)
  • Northern Ireland: £27.19 per week

People in care homes aren't all gaga or immobile, you know.

They may want to go on an outing/Christmas Meal/afternoon tea with relatives, buy wool for knitting/crocheting, buy presents for grandkids, buy toiletaries (these are not supplied by the home) top-ups for mobile 'phones etc etc.

And why not? They've worked all/most of their lives, some have fought for this country and they deserve it.

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:19

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:14

A few years back, a local hotel got sold by their owners and all staff was made redundant, weddings and other stays were cancelled.

It happens

It didn't become a asylum hotel, it jsut stood empty for a while

So? Hotels close for other reasons - obviously. That is not relevant here.

My post lists 3 separate hotels that cancelled weddings to house asylum seekers. One of them was a country house hotel as I originally claimed and PP didn’t believe.

MsJinks · 22/09/2025 22:19

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:11

A couple in Leicestershire have been left heartbroken after their hotel wedding venue cancelled their big day, because it was 'acquisitioned for a Government contract'.
Steph Grant and her fiancee Tom Moulding believe their wedding was cancelled as the Quorn Country Hotel will be closed and instead be used to house asylum seekers.

Devastated couples had their weddings cancelled after the hotel they were using closed suddenly to house asylum seekers.
The Best Western Cresta Court Hotel in Altrincham - owned by a group chaired by former BBC director-general Greg Dyke - was shut to paying guests on Monday after being turned over to accommodate almost 300 migrants.

A couple's wedding has been cancelled by a hotel that is being used to house asylum seekers.
Lucie Campbell and Simon Pritchard booked their wedding for 10 December more than a year ago.
But they were left with just days to find a new venue after discovering the Aberconwy hotel is being used to ease overcrowding at Kent detention centres.
Ms Campbell, 28, of Towyn, Conwy, said she was in "disbelief" but has managed to reorganise their special day.
The hotel, which the BBC is not naming for safeguarding reasons, is providing short-term accommodation as part of a project that began last week.

Where did I say that they would still offer spa treatment? You’re being ridiculous. They still have to put sheets on the beds, staff the restaurant to feed the men and do the cleaning.

Quibbling that a previously advertised 4 hotel is no longer a 4 hotel because some services may have been withdrawn but replaced with things like free private health and dental care (yes, I’ve got evidence of that too before you dig further into your denial) is pretty desperate - honestly.

So why not look to Greg Dyke - Tory mate - obviously he saw a chance to make more on asylum seekers than weddings from the Tory gov’t at the time?.
The hotel experience of asylum seekers compared to that of previous guests is far removed. The rooms will have been refitted for one to cram more in one. I’d ask Greg why he considered this best for business.
And free private healthcare - come on - angel care and basic health checks - maybe sourced to private, as NHS does this, or maybe another Tory mate scan. Not in the realm of what most consider as private healthcare.

Livelovebehappy · 22/09/2025 22:20

Allisnotlost1 · 22/09/2025 21:42

Ipsos have polled on this since 1979. You might keep your cards close to your chest but just under 18,000 people last year told Ipsos about themselves. So we do know about voter characteristics.

https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/uk-opinion-polls/how-britain-voted-in-the-2024-election

Education level was one of the strongest predictors of voting leave. Leave was highest among those with low or no qualifications and among skilled manual and routine/unskilled workers. These are facts, not judgements or opinions.

Edited

But 18000? That’s just a snapshot of those who chose to take part. It doesn’t tell us anything other than 18000 people gave details about their lives. Maybe the others who didn’t take part were the opposite side of the spectrum? As I say, those that are uneducated are the ones to tell people who they are, and shout it from the rooftops. Others keep it to themselves. There may be many more who are educated and who vote reform, but just choose not to take part in these polls. That’s the unpredictability of it all. We just don’t know.

MsJinks · 22/09/2025 22:22

peasporrige · 22/09/2025 22:17

The amount of "spend" allowed in care/nursing homes varies with area ;-

  • England: £30.65 per week
  • Scotland: £35.90 per week
  • Wales: £44.65 per week (in Wales it’s called Minimum Income Amount)
  • Northern Ireland: £27.19 per week

People in care homes aren't all gaga or immobile, you know.

They may want to go on an outing/Christmas Meal/afternoon tea with relatives, buy wool for knitting/crocheting, buy presents for grandkids, buy toiletaries (these are not supplied by the home) top-ups for mobile 'phones etc etc.

And why not? They've worked all/most of their lives, some have fought for this country and they deserve it.

Umm - I was being sarcastic in response to the PP I was answering. But there will be truth in my Reform cash grab suggestion- to be clear I definitely wouldn’t agree with this, but not do I agree with hating asylum seekers for getting a tenner.

MaidOfSteel · 22/09/2025 22:22

EarthlyNightshade · 22/09/2025 20:48

Would you personally be happy to work as a carer if the pay was better?

For enough money, of course I would.

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:23

SuffolkSun · 22/09/2025 22:16

And you really believe that some asylum seekers, being put up in buildings previously run as 4* hotels, have minibars and 24hr room service, are provided with high-quality bath products and linen, and that the management comes to turn down their sheets at night and leave a chocolate on the pillow? Apparently you do. Are you usually this gullible.

Hotels are privately owned businesses. If a hotel owner decides to sign a contract with government to house asylum seekers, and cancels wedding reception bookings already taken to do so, that's on the hotel owner, not the government or asylum seekers.

OMG, read my post.

Aah, so now, because certain aspects of the service level offered by a hotel that has been advertised as 4 star up until its closure for use by asylum seekers are no longer available, you are claiming that asylum seekers are not being put into hotels??

DuncinToffee · 22/09/2025 22:23

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:19

So? Hotels close for other reasons - obviously. That is not relevant here.

My post lists 3 separate hotels that cancelled weddings to house asylum seekers. One of them was a country house hotel as I originally claimed and PP didn’t believe.

Companies have profited massively from government contracts providing asylum accommodation, look up Serco, Mears, Clearsprings.

Blame the hotel owners for selling rather than refugees seeking safety.

JHound · 22/09/2025 22:26

He is so grostesque.

At least they have admitted it’s not just about illegal immigrants. Changing the rules for those on ILR is just barbaric.

I also see he wants to require migrants to give up a second nationality if applying for British citizenship.

I wonder if his kids will be allowed to keep their dual nationality….

JHound · 22/09/2025 22:27

Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

My dogs ears are bleeding….

Anyway a lot of law abiding and hardworking immigrants happen to work in shortage key roles that just happen to be low paid.

SuffolkSun · 22/09/2025 22:28

Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

What is the indigenous culture of the British Isles in your view? Because I see little attempt by Farage or his followers to respect the culture of Wales, or that of the Scottish Highlands or that of Cornwall - where it's most likely to be found.

As for the rest of your post...smacks very much of nonsense.

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 22:30

Honish · 22/09/2025 22:03

Absolute rubbish and slanderous hyperbole. Reform do not want anyone to leave who pays in more than they take out, is law-abiding and happy to assimilate with and respect the indigenous culture of this land. Particularly Europeans with whom we share the heritage and values of the west with.

Exactly.

Following some rather bizarre assertions in responses to my posts I’m starting to conclude that there is much dishonesty exacerbated by a lack of reading comprehension.

Allisnotlost1 · 22/09/2025 22:31

Livelovebehappy · 22/09/2025 22:20

But 18000? That’s just a snapshot of those who chose to take part. It doesn’t tell us anything other than 18000 people gave details about their lives. Maybe the others who didn’t take part were the opposite side of the spectrum? As I say, those that are uneducated are the ones to tell people who they are, and shout it from the rooftops. Others keep it to themselves. There may be many more who are educated and who vote reform, but just choose not to take part in these polls. That’s the unpredictability of it all. We just don’t know.

Yes, it’s a snapshot. That’s how polling works. Not really feasible to ask tens of millions of people so the point is to select a statistically relevant sample and extrapolate from it.

The same methods of polling are also used to predict outcomes in constituencies and by political parties to target those who will vote for them. So while there can be outliers, it’s simply untrue to say ’we just don’t know’.

JHound · 22/09/2025 22:32

Livelovebehappy · 22/09/2025 22:20

But 18000? That’s just a snapshot of those who chose to take part. It doesn’t tell us anything other than 18000 people gave details about their lives. Maybe the others who didn’t take part were the opposite side of the spectrum? As I say, those that are uneducated are the ones to tell people who they are, and shout it from the rooftops. Others keep it to themselves. There may be many more who are educated and who vote reform, but just choose not to take part in these polls. That’s the unpredictability of it all. We just don’t know.

So you genuinely think that all the polls and surveys showing Remain voters has a higher average level of education are just all randomly selecting educated Remain voters?

Falseknock · 22/09/2025 22:32

BundleBoogie · 22/09/2025 21:50

I don’t see how being profitable or not has any bearing on the level of accommodation. There are many factors that affect profitability. Are you suggesting that some of these hotels were making false claims about their rating?

A friend of mine had booked to stay in a perfectly nice looking London hotel but her booking was cancelled and it is now being rented by the government.

Some of the hotels may well be a bit run down but that doesn’t mean they all are. The government will be getting desperate to accommodate 1000 men that arrive most days now.

It doesn't matter as soon as they closed their doors to the public they were no longer a hotel. I don't think women and children could survive the journey the men decided to take. They risked their lives for a better future for their family.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread