Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be saddened that anyone would want to take away a woman’s right to safe abortion?

1000 replies

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 14:48

It makes me sad and angry that there are so many people who believe that a woman’s right to a termination is up for debate/political football.

It’s always privileged men too.

No woman should be forced to continue with a pregnancy that she doesn’t want.

An abortion is a very safe, simple procedure, it’s a personal and private choice, it’s discreet, no one is ramming it down anyone else’s throat or trying to persuade others to do it. The vast majority of the time is done very early on in the pregnancy. Evidence shows that there are no long term negative physical or mental effects on the woman.

As someone who works for children’s services, there are already far too many children in the care system and they can end up deeply traumatised, and having poor outcomes in life, adoptions often don’t work out and even when they do can be extremely traumatic for both the mother and child. That is not to take away from all of the wonderful adoptive parents and foster carers, but please let’s not romanticise it.

Most adoptions are because the birth parents are unable to care for the child, not because the mother willingly gave the baby up. Therefore to force a woman to give birth would potentially be the worse option for the woman, the child and any existing siblings. It isn’t a fairytale ending where a woman willingly gives up her baby to a loving couple to live happily ever after.

There are babies conceived in poverty, domestic abuse, rape, teenage pregnancies, older age pregnancies. These women should not be forced to give birth, it is not the better option for anyone.

If abortion was ever restricted in the western world then I have no doubt that it would result in unsafe illegal abortions, risking the woman’s life.

Women take all the risk with pregnancy and childbirth. They take an enormous toll on a woman body, her mental health, her life outcomes. We are not living in the dark ages, women deserve the choice.

What right does any privileged male who has probably never experienced any of these things and has probably done very little child rearing, who can never conceive or give birth, have to try to restrict a women’s access to abortion?

Are they themselves going to care for the babies born? Or will they expect that someone else will do it?

OP posts:
Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:52

TinyTeachr · 13/09/2025 20:50

I would be extremely happy if there were far fewer abortions. I don't see it as a morally neutral choice as some seem to. It really saddens me when you hear of pregnancies that could have very easily been avoided being terminated.

I dont think a foetus has the same rights or feelings as a woman or a child that has been born. And I accept that at the early stages they have virtually no awareness. But it seems wrong to me in much the same way as it would seem wrong to me to create a baby animal and then painlessly euthanize it - acceptable if the alternative is worse, but morally better to be avoided if possible.

So I very much wish that there were fewer abortions, and I think that its important that we continue to educate young women about options around contraception and that these methods may fail. That contraception is simple and cheap to access. That sterilisation is an option for those that want it (my sister is autistic. She is now 40 and has never ever wanted children. She has brought up sterilisation many times but always been told no, she might change her mind). That men are encouraged to have vasectomies. That women who do become accidentally pregnant could be supported to giving up those babies if they want to. I also think that its very important to support single mothers and not to judge a woman for having an unplanned child. Maternity rights are extremely important and should be protected.

I do think that it is very important that abortions are legal and accessible. Pregnancy and childbirth are physically taxing and carry risks. Restricting abortion leads to women taking dangerous risks, or doctors refusing one for fear of the law.

I just wish that it was possible to have a conversation about abortion without it being painted as totally black and white- that some people believe it should be illegal and others that it is totally morally neutral. It is possible for someone to have a right to something, but that not always to be the best path.

I find it very frustrating that incest (usually involving young vulnerable girls) and rape are so frequently given as examples. We all know that those make up a tiny proportion of the abortions that are carried out.

Thank you! It’s always made out to be so simplistic by so many posters.

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 20:52

Goodygummdrops · 13/09/2025 20:45

Sorry if it's already been said I'm bit confused by the concept of avoiding a " forced birth" since the baby doesn't miraculously vanish once it's been killed. Still needs birthing.

Are you saying that taking a tablet to end a pregnancy that will feel like little more than a heavy period. And carrying a baby to full term giving birth bringing to a baby that will then need parenting for the rest of your life are the same?

The former is not forced birth.

OP posts:
LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:53

Goodygummdrops · 13/09/2025 20:45

Sorry if it's already been said I'm bit confused by the concept of avoiding a " forced birth" since the baby doesn't miraculously vanish once it's been killed. Still needs birthing.

It’s expelled.

Dont get too bogged down in semantics

VeganMilk · 13/09/2025 20:54

I'm saddened people want to kill unborn children 🤷

I came to my beliefs after thinking about both sides of the argument. Read both sides, thought about my beliefs and came to my conclusion as to what I find immoral.

spoonbillstretford · 13/09/2025 20:56

A lot of people don't like women having sexual autonomy, controlling whether they have children, or control over their own bodies when it comes down to it, especially when they are pregnant and they just see them as an unimportant vessel.

They just want women to be fertile, docile, to fuck on command and breed only when a man wants them to. Pretty much how it always was until reliable contraception and safe abortion became available.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:57

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:49

I think the queru is why is something only worthy when it’s independent. Maybe it can still be worthy when it’s dependant on someone else’s body.

Because a like has to be drawn somewhere.

Where would you put a fetus woth a newborn? What stage?

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:57

spoonbillstretford · 13/09/2025 20:56

A lot of people don't like women having sexual autonomy, controlling whether they have children, or control over their own bodies when it comes down to it, especially when they are pregnant and they just see them as an unimportant vessel.

They just want women to be fertile, docile, to fuck on command and breed only when a man wants them to. Pretty much how it always was until reliable contraception and safe abortion became available.

I dont think I know anyone who thinks that. Grim! 🤣

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 20:57

spoonbillstretford · 13/09/2025 20:56

A lot of people don't like women having sexual autonomy, controlling whether they have children, or control over their own bodies when it comes down to it, especially when they are pregnant and they just see them as an unimportant vessel.

They just want women to be fertile, docile, to fuck on command and breed only when a man wants them to. Pretty much how it always was until reliable contraception and safe abortion became available.

Sad but true.

Even sadder that so many women seem to be up for this too.

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 13/09/2025 20:57

They are not children.
You can find it immoral and sad without making it illegal

Tunacheesequesadilla · 13/09/2025 20:58

Coconutter24 · 13/09/2025 20:28

You’ve missed the point completely. It’s not even about the partners feelings, a baby has just been killed, aborted call it what you want… it’s about the baby, the living being inside the woman

Okay 🤷‍♀️

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 20:58

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:51

I think it’s been made quite clear. People are allowed to disagree.

Of course they can disagree. People should just use valid arguments if they plan on expressing their disagreement, otherwise they'll get nowhere and become frustrated.
The problem is there are no valid anti-choice arguments, which is why these threads always devolve into; "But what about the poor innocent baby!" and similar hyper-emotional pleas.

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 21:00

pointythings · 13/09/2025 20:33

If you want to bring abortion rates down as low as they can be - and believe me, I do, passionately pro choice as I am - then you have to look at the countries where abortion is legal but abortion rates are very low. And you will find they have things in common:

  • A robust welfare system
  • Excellent access to contraception
  • Excellent sex education started early
  • Affordable childcare, enabling women to work
  • Excellent and affordable healthcare before, during and after pregnancy
  • Excellent support for women leaving abusive relationships
  • A culture where female sterilisation and the notion that women do not want (any more) children is accepted
  • A culture where men take responsibility for contraception
  • A culture where men are made to take financial responsibility for children they have fathered

But funnily enough, the very people screaming loudest about wanting to ban abortion are also the people screaming loudest about not having any of the above, because it's socialism.

You can't have your cake and eat it too.

We have all those things except ' culture where men take responsibility for contraception' so women can either do that themselves or choose their partners carefully.

It is extremely easy to prevent pregnancy. Contraception and the MAP all readily available.

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 21:00

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:57

Because a like has to be drawn somewhere.

Where would you put a fetus woth a newborn? What stage?

I suppose when it becomes on par with a newborn when it becomes conscious around
24 weeks.

AngelicKaty · 13/09/2025 21:00

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 20:37

So as you care so much for these human lives as you believe they are.

Would you be prepared to care for them, if the mother is unable to?

Do you campaign for better maternity rights and services for women? Better benefits, better housing, better education. Do you campaign against domestic abuse?

Do you actually care about hat happens to these lives once they are born?

Exactly. It's the same with Trump's 'murica. At the same time 20 states have banned abortion altogether, Trump's administration has gutted children's services (cutting funds and manpower for investigating child abuse, enforcing child support payments, providing child care and much more). They care (allegedly) about babies right up to the moment they're born - then they don't give a damn. The hypocrisy of it all stinks.

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 21:01

VeganMilk · 13/09/2025 20:54

I'm saddened people want to kill unborn children 🤷

I came to my beliefs after thinking about both sides of the argument. Read both sides, thought about my beliefs and came to my conclusion as to what I find immoral.

If you had read the facts, you would know a fetus has only superficial, irrelevant (in this context) commonalities with a born child and you would not use that word.
I therefore conclude you have not actually read the facts.

Digdongdoo · 13/09/2025 21:01

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 21:00

We have all those things except ' culture where men take responsibility for contraception' so women can either do that themselves or choose their partners carefully.

It is extremely easy to prevent pregnancy. Contraception and the MAP all readily available.

How pathetic. Your solution to feckless men is to blame women.

DiscoBeat · 13/09/2025 21:02

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 13/09/2025 19:23

I didn't know you could terminate that late 😱.
I am not comfortable with that I'm afraid

Same.

WhatAboutThisUser · 13/09/2025 21:02

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 20:47

Death of a fetus matters much less than all of this.

And no I don’t see it as being equal to the mother. The concept is absurd and misogynistic

Do you understand what happens to women AND babies when abortion is outlawed?

I recognise the opinion that a foetus is not a fully equal human. Most people are on a spectrum with some thinking it becomes equal at conception, some after birth. To me this is the crux of the whole debate and everything else is noise.

How’s it misogynistic, the balance is the same whether the baby is female or male.

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 21:03

Maltipoo · 13/09/2025 20:58

Of course they can disagree. People should just use valid arguments if they plan on expressing their disagreement, otherwise they'll get nowhere and become frustrated.
The problem is there are no valid anti-choice arguments, which is why these threads always devolve into; "But what about the poor innocent baby!" and similar hyper-emotional pleas.

But why isnt this a valid argument? It’s quite
clear. It’s ending a human life. That is the argument. Ending human lives is wrong. And yes people will also feel sad about it. It’s all emotive.

LayerCakeOfStrangers · 13/09/2025 21:04

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 20:51

I think it’s been made quite clear. People are allowed to disagree.

Well it’s not when all they say is “I’m anti-abortion”

RedSkyatNight25 · 13/09/2025 21:04

I feel quite conflicted about abortion, I do believe it’s a baby at conception and I find the prospect of ending a life terribly sad. I lost a baby at 8 weeks and believe I suffered a loss of a soul/child. I had an ectopic pregnancy so I struggle with the notion it might have been a healthy baby but just implanted in the wrong place. I also struggle when people say it’s just a clump of cells.

But I also believe abortion is sometimes the right choice and personally think it needs to be a conversation between a woman and her medical advisor. I wouldn’t stop abortion, and think it’s important the right to have one is protected.

Lelophants · 13/09/2025 21:04

AngelicKaty · 13/09/2025 21:00

Exactly. It's the same with Trump's 'murica. At the same time 20 states have banned abortion altogether, Trump's administration has gutted children's services (cutting funds and manpower for investigating child abuse, enforcing child support payments, providing child care and much more). They care (allegedly) about babies right up to the moment they're born - then they don't give a damn. The hypocrisy of it all stinks.

I hate this with a passion and this is one if my
many issues with the states that have done this.

pointythings · 13/09/2025 21:06

Gloriia · 13/09/2025 21:00

We have all those things except ' culture where men take responsibility for contraception' so women can either do that themselves or choose their partners carefully.

It is extremely easy to prevent pregnancy. Contraception and the MAP all readily available.

We don't have all those things!

Childcare in the UK is among the most expensive in Europe.
People are still allowed to opt out of sex education, it is delivered far too late and in not enough depth.
We do not have failsafe contraception - no such thing exists.
Our welfare system is among the least generous in Europe.
Support for women leaving abusive relationships is DIRE.
Women of childbearing age are ROUTINELY refused sterilisation.
Men routinely get away with not paying child support.

What Utopian bit of the UK do you actually live in???

Onmytod24 · 13/09/2025 21:06

ThejoyofNC · 13/09/2025 19:06

I'm anti abortion and I'm not a man.

That’s totally okay you don’t have to have one

Elsvieta · 13/09/2025 21:06

Balayagequeen · 13/09/2025 20:37

So as you care so much for these human lives as you believe they are.

Would you be prepared to care for them, if the mother is unable to?

Do you campaign for better maternity rights and services for women? Better benefits, better housing, better education. Do you campaign against domestic abuse?

Do you actually care about hat happens to these lives once they are born?

Pro-abortion people always come out with these lists of utilitarian arguments in at attempt to avoid the central, moral, one. It's killing. We don't advocate killing adults if they're in an environment where there's not enough work or housing to go around or they live in a famine zone or whatever. Dress it up or try to deflect from it all day long, it's taking a human life.

I'm not trying to adopt myself, no. But millions are, usually with a preference for babies, and there aren't nearly enough to go around. Millions of babies killed, while meanwhile millions of adults bankrupt themselves with IVF and the like. Obscenity.

Why get so angry about people (men and women) having a different view to you? You've got what you want; abortion is easy in the UK, there's very little public appetite for changing it, and it's not going to change. If you honestly have no guilty conscience, don't believe it's wrong, don't believe it's even a moral issue at all, why be so bothered by a minority of people telling you otherwise?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.