Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL still isolating due to covid risk

593 replies

dragontears · 01/09/2025 09:22

AIBU to think this is no way to live now? She works from home and will only leave the house for essential errands with mask on. She is terrified of getting long covid. Feels like her life is very very limited for a 38 year old!

Anyone else have people they know in this position? How to support them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
lovescats3 · 01/09/2025 14:35

wow everanewbie 'sob stories and claims about long covid '? You sound like a nice person

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 14:49

Tiredjusttired · 01/09/2025 14:35

All viruses are novel. That’s because they evolve. Covid was a coronavirus and humans have been living with coronavirus since forever.

As for long term damage - you cite the worst case scenarios but forget how we and our immune systems have evolved and adapted over time. The immune system, like every part of our existed, must be educated. To be educated means a steady exposure to common pathogens so the body can clock up immunity.

It’s not viruses that make children really sick (unless they are already immunocompromised through, say, treatment for leukaemia), it’s lack of proper nutrition, lack of sunlight, lack of interaction with sensible adults, lack of exercise, lack of sleep. It’s also being forced to live in damp, cramped and mould-infested accommodation.

It wasn’t so long ago children used to die of asthma attacks because they were cold, malnourished and central heating didn’t exist.

I feel like some people, in the complete absence of threats like war, poverty, abuse, malnutrition, substandard housing have lost all perspective.

Maybe the OP needs to point out to her sister that she is already living like she’s got long covid anyway.

And I’ve read a scenario where eventually so many people get Long Covid that the world stops functioning properly.

We don’t seem to have much immunity going by repeated infection rates.

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 14:50

lovescats3 · 01/09/2025 14:35

wow everanewbie 'sob stories and claims about long covid '? You sound like a nice person

Well, would you invite the families of the air India crash to a session talking about a phobia of flying? Or maybe having someone who had a limb amputated after being bitten by a poisonous spider as the lead speaker at an arachnophobia conference?

The person in question is irrationally scared of a virus that is usually not much more than a cold, and vanishingly rarely worse than flu to the point of becoming a recluse and ruining her husbands life. This "its vascular!!!" and I'm the 0.001% who got unlucky, poor me, lets live in our cupboard under the stairs stuff just isn't rational. Sorry if that triggers you. Boohoo.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 14:56

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 14:50

Well, would you invite the families of the air India crash to a session talking about a phobia of flying? Or maybe having someone who had a limb amputated after being bitten by a poisonous spider as the lead speaker at an arachnophobia conference?

The person in question is irrationally scared of a virus that is usually not much more than a cold, and vanishingly rarely worse than flu to the point of becoming a recluse and ruining her husbands life. This "its vascular!!!" and I'm the 0.001% who got unlucky, poor me, lets live in our cupboard under the stairs stuff just isn't rational. Sorry if that triggers you. Boohoo.

Crikey you’re a real charmer.

Calliopespa · 01/09/2025 14:57

The truth is we just don't know.

The people being cautious may be totally over-reacting; those of us out and about may live to regret it (or not live to regret it ...)

But the wider point is, short of illegality, we are all entitled to respond to things in the way we wish. Yes, there are different considerations where one has children, or even, like this lady, partners it impacts. But it is up to each and every one of us to assess our circumstances and make our own decisions about how much different pursuits and different precautions matter to us.

There's been way too much judging - on this thread and in the wake of Covid generally.

Enrichetta · 01/09/2025 14:58

AussieManque · 01/09/2025 13:43

I am COVID cautious. I wear my N95 100% of the time I'm indoors (except at home). I only eat in outdoor restaurants and cafes. We test whenever anyone in the household is ill. My children don't get taken to crowded ball pit type places but we do visit indoor things with masks on at non peak times.

COVID is a neuro invasive, vascular disease, and it's clear that every infection, however mild, leaves a mark on the body. It also damages the immune system and can cause cognitive decline. Just because the initial symptoms are mild doesn't mean you have been undamaged. Mainstream media has chosen to avoid the topic but there are articles highlighting the research/evidence on cognitive damage, risk of heart attack and strokes, immune system damage, long COVID etc if you look. And over 400,000 peer reviewed papers.

It makes sense to avoid catching it repeatedly and wearing a mask indoors really is not a problem. I will continue until a more effective vaccine is developed.

What breaks my heart however is children being sent to school with zero airborne mitigations and school admins that prioritise attendance over health. As a result, schools are infection pits, and children pass it on to their wider family and so it spreads. Yet since every infection is damaging, we should be doing everything we can to minimize multiple infections in our kids. In schools that means ventilation at least, preferably combined with air purifiers, and keep sick children home. COVIDsafetyforschools.org is a great resource - please have a look and ask your children's schools what measures they are taking.

The data is very clear (eg long term sick leave stats, not just in UK, and NHS staff illness absence data) that across the population, illness absence has risen continuously since 2020, and it's not because of vaccines.

You should instead be supportive of your SIL, mask up around her and show understanding. She's certainly not wrong to be cautious. And perhaps consider if it's wise to be blase about catching such novel virus about which we have much more to learn.

This is insane. You need help. I pity your children.

bumbaloo · 01/09/2025 15:00

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 09:29

I’ve had long COVID for 2 years. It’s been the most horrific and terrifying time of my life. I was in bed unable to do anything at all for the first year.

Can’t say l blame her.

But she doesn’t have any greater risk of it than anyone else. It’s become an anxiety issue

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 15:01

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 14:56

Crikey you’re a real charmer.

Do you assess risk by the worst case scenario, irrespective of the probability? It is cold, but its the calculation we do thousands of times a day without realising it. The subject of this thread's ability is all out of whack.

CrackingOn50 · 01/09/2025 15:03

OldBeyondMyYears · 01/09/2025 10:26

There’s a young-ish family living on my street who are like this. They have everything delivered, rarely go out (and are masked when they do) and have two school aged children who have never been back to school since. I suspect they are being ‘home schooled’ officially but this can’t be healthy can it?

I do know (as the children were at my school, but not in my class, prior to lockdown) that there is no underlying cause for this, ie nobody in the family is immunocompromised, so would imagine mental health is the cause here.

It’s no way to live…especially with children. 😢

Very similar to family on my street, I'll PM you if that's okay?

GapYearSnow · 01/09/2025 15:03

I actually do agree with @Thepeopleversuswork re covid providing cover for not engaging with world
and I'm someone who has taken a massive step back from society!!
I can't even book a haircut! the only appt I've had to make and keep was for fucked up teeth- pain being the driver!
I think about meeting up with friends etc but I can't bring myself to do it- I've def become semi-agorophobic- I don't work and my world is small- partner, 2 older teens- that's it. I dread the thought of any social or duty interaction (eg mother's 80th this year) and have managed to avoid everything so far.
On the flip side I do definitely have a series of long-lasting infections which seem to have ramped up since both ovaries removed- as @WitchesofPainswick noted, there does seem to be a menopause link and the last year- since a horrible (as in physical and emotional symptoms) bout of covid I've been relentlessly ill with viral infections
Sorry, this is probably not pertinent to op's SIL issue as hers sounds exclusively psychological.
Not sure what I'm saying really- just that although I'm genuinely unwell from perhaps covid or just viral infections in general, I know I've also let things snowball psychologically which it sounds as though has happened with your SIL and I don't seem to be able to dig myself out- waiting for the magic moment that I feel ok.

FairKoala · 01/09/2025 15:05

AussieManque · 01/09/2025 13:43

I am COVID cautious. I wear my N95 100% of the time I'm indoors (except at home). I only eat in outdoor restaurants and cafes. We test whenever anyone in the household is ill. My children don't get taken to crowded ball pit type places but we do visit indoor things with masks on at non peak times.

COVID is a neuro invasive, vascular disease, and it's clear that every infection, however mild, leaves a mark on the body. It also damages the immune system and can cause cognitive decline. Just because the initial symptoms are mild doesn't mean you have been undamaged. Mainstream media has chosen to avoid the topic but there are articles highlighting the research/evidence on cognitive damage, risk of heart attack and strokes, immune system damage, long COVID etc if you look. And over 400,000 peer reviewed papers.

It makes sense to avoid catching it repeatedly and wearing a mask indoors really is not a problem. I will continue until a more effective vaccine is developed.

What breaks my heart however is children being sent to school with zero airborne mitigations and school admins that prioritise attendance over health. As a result, schools are infection pits, and children pass it on to their wider family and so it spreads. Yet since every infection is damaging, we should be doing everything we can to minimize multiple infections in our kids. In schools that means ventilation at least, preferably combined with air purifiers, and keep sick children home. COVIDsafetyforschools.org is a great resource - please have a look and ask your children's schools what measures they are taking.

The data is very clear (eg long term sick leave stats, not just in UK, and NHS staff illness absence data) that across the population, illness absence has risen continuously since 2020, and it's not because of vaccines.

You should instead be supportive of your SIL, mask up around her and show understanding. She's certainly not wrong to be cautious. And perhaps consider if it's wise to be blase about catching such novel virus about which we have much more to learn.

Mainstream media has chosen to avoid the topic but there are articles highlighting the research/evidence on cognitive damage, risk of heart attack and strokes, immune system damage, long COVID etc if you look. And over 400,000 peer reviewed papers

Cognitive decline is also what happens when you live alone and don’t interact with others
Your lifestyle is not what is being described.

The DSis doesn’t actually leave the house to go anywhere other than for food shopping.

Also as you point out long term sick leave has risen since 2020

As there is no data we don’t know if this is all because of having Covid or long COVID.

I would think a lot of those long term sick are because all those people who needed to see a doctor, have tests, surgery etc during 2020-2022 didn’t have these tests in good time and weren’t treated immediately but left to the point that a simple operation with maybe 1 night in hospital and a short time off work won’t help them.
Instead they need more invasive operations and a much longer recovery time.

Its also because now people take days off to recover from a cough or cold where in the past they would go in to work.

I have only seen a handful of people wear masks on the street this year. (Apart from cyclists) and they are tourists. You can tell by their style of dress

OriginalUsername2 · 01/09/2025 15:09

Calliopespa · 01/09/2025 12:23

I do agree that the impact on the DH is troubling in this instance.

But I disagree it is not clear what she is living for. I'm afraid I find that patronising in the extreme. Its not for us to say. She has a job, she has a partner (who she needs to consider, I agree), she gets out for walks. There might just not be anything - pub, shops etc - that she feels that compelled to pursue that cannot be pursued at home.

Yeah I’m wondering what she’s not doing that everyone wants her to do. Maybe it’s showing her face at social events that she doesn’t really enjoy anyway.

Who’s to say what the “correct” way to live is?

Enrichetta · 01/09/2025 15:10

this is probably not pertinent to op's SIL issue as hers sounds exclusively psychological.… not sure what I'm saying really- just that although I'm genuinely unwell from perhaps covid or just viral infections in general, I know I've also let things snowball psychologically which it sounds as though has happened with your SIL and I don't seem to be able to dig myself out- waiting for the magic moment that I feel ok

Have you actually seen a doctor for your ‘genuine’ illness and/or viral infections? Have you seen a counsellor?

Seriously, this is no way to live. You must know that ‘waiting for the magic moment’ when you’ll feel ok is pointless - you need to address your issues and act!

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 15:11

OriginalUsername2 · 01/09/2025 15:09

Yeah I’m wondering what she’s not doing that everyone wants her to do. Maybe it’s showing her face at social events that she doesn’t really enjoy anyway.

Who’s to say what the “correct” way to live is?

Edited

Did you read the part about the husband having to wear a mask for 48 hours and sleep in the spare room if he goes to the pub? People can do what they want, but when they start controlling others....

FourBlackCats · 01/09/2025 15:12

SoManyDandelions · 01/09/2025 10:11

Are people still getting long covid from the most recent variants? The only people I know with LC got it early on (and are still struggling 4-5 years later).

Yes they are. My Mum caught one of the ‘mild’ strains last year, nearly died, was in hospital for ten weeks and now has long covid.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 15:16

FourBlackCats · 01/09/2025 15:12

Yes they are. My Mum caught one of the ‘mild’ strains last year, nearly died, was in hospital for ten weeks and now has long covid.

I got LC from Omicrom 2 years ago.

68 m worldwide have it.

OnTheRoof · 01/09/2025 15:22

dragontears · 01/09/2025 11:41

He has also changed his lifestyle, which is troubling in itself, because it feels enabling of her issue, but I can understand that he wants to keep the peace.

He is naturally an introvert (as I mentioned earlier in the thread, she is actually the more extroverted one before she developed this issue), so he doesn't go out much and also works from home. When he does go out with his mates or comes to see us, which would only happen a couple of times a month, he has to sleep in the guest room and wear a mask for 48 hours afterwards!!!!

Ok that's concerning. What would happen if he refused?

MoveOverToTheSea · 01/09/2025 15:28

OnTheRoof · 01/09/2025 15:22

Ok that's concerning. What would happen if he refused?

Except that what most Covid conscious (aka those who have developed LC from Covid) do…
It’s like, as they have actually felt themselves the huge impact Covid can have, they do their utmost to avoid it at all cost.

I don’t expect my dh to do that because I don’t have the energy for the fight. But having caught Covid twice because he didn’t make any effort to avoid Covid, I now have some air filters in place instead. But I know that, despite seeing me bedbound for years following a covid infection, he doesn’t care enough about my health to wear a mask, at the very least in very high risks situations like a plane journey. It’s hard to forget.

GapYearSnow · 01/09/2025 15:33

Enrichetta · 01/09/2025 15:10

this is probably not pertinent to op's SIL issue as hers sounds exclusively psychological.… not sure what I'm saying really- just that although I'm genuinely unwell from perhaps covid or just viral infections in general, I know I've also let things snowball psychologically which it sounds as though has happened with your SIL and I don't seem to be able to dig myself out- waiting for the magic moment that I feel ok

Have you actually seen a doctor for your ‘genuine’ illness and/or viral infections? Have you seen a counsellor?

Seriously, this is no way to live. You must know that ‘waiting for the magic moment’ when you’ll feel ok is pointless - you need to address your issues and act!

Thank you for this
Yes, I have seen the GP- had bloods and nothing obvious, which I'm grateful for, but they didn't take it further and I didn't push.
I don't know what to do about the illnesses and I've never been one for health anxiety.
Certainly I have a degree of people anxiety which is inevitably ramping up with my lifestyle and I totally admit to a psychological element to all this- whether it preceded physical illness or proceeded it, I'm not sure!!
Thank you, thank you for telling me to act- I need a kick up the bum!! I love spontaneous social interaction- with my neighbour, a shopkeeper, another middle aged woman walking solo in the woods! And I see how mental health feeds into our perception of illness perhaps.
I accept that the magic moment isn't just going to present itself!

DashboardConfession · 01/09/2025 15:42

Enrichetta · 01/09/2025 14:58

This is insane. You need help. I pity your children.

My thoughts exactly. All this will do is raise anxious, paranoid children.

AussieManque · 01/09/2025 15:51

I find it interesting how everyone jumps on the COVID cautious and are quick to accuse them of having a mental illness. It's not anxiety. It's applying a knowledge of science and the precautionary principle. I live my life, just with a mask in places that carry risk, just like I wear a bike helmet on my bike or my seatbelt in the car. Is it so difficult to let people wear a mask because they want to?

@PaxAeterna The fact that you think hand sanitizer will keep us safe from COVID shows you don't understand how it transmits. It's primarily airborne.

I mitigate against car crashes by wearing a seatbelt. I mitigate against COVID with a mask. I'm not social distancing. My elder son goes to school. The only thing we don't do is dine indoors.

Why would you risk "mild" long COVID on your child if there are simple things to reduce risk? Also it's not just long COVID, children are also at heightened risk of diabetes following infection, vascular damage, cognitive decline, those exposed in womb are more likely to experience development delays. Why not take simple precautions? Instead of suggesting I get talking therapy, how about not judging people who want to keep their children healthy while still offering them a normal life? I know I can't avoid infection 100% but I'm going to try my hardest to make sure my family doesn't get it more than necessary because each infection carries risk.

@Tiredjusttired you mention asthma. You know what's just become the top chronic disease in American children: Asthma. Guess what triggers asthma? COVID infections.
Please don't peddle the myth that getting exposed to viruses builds immunity. Exposure to dirt, yes, but not viral pathogens. Or how do you choose which viruses are safe to expose yourself too, why don't you expose yourself to HIV to build your immunity to it? After all the initial symptoms are a fever and cold symptoms... same with polio...

There are longitudinal studies that shows that children who had more respiratory infections in early childhood had worse long term health outcomes. So infection is not beneficial.

It's easier for people to ignore the evidence, than accept that maybe it's not wise to let their children get infected by COVID repeatedly, with all the consequences of that. And this herd mentality allows continued infection and a gradual diminishment of our population's health.

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 15:54

AussieManque · 01/09/2025 15:51

I find it interesting how everyone jumps on the COVID cautious and are quick to accuse them of having a mental illness. It's not anxiety. It's applying a knowledge of science and the precautionary principle. I live my life, just with a mask in places that carry risk, just like I wear a bike helmet on my bike or my seatbelt in the car. Is it so difficult to let people wear a mask because they want to?

@PaxAeterna The fact that you think hand sanitizer will keep us safe from COVID shows you don't understand how it transmits. It's primarily airborne.

I mitigate against car crashes by wearing a seatbelt. I mitigate against COVID with a mask. I'm not social distancing. My elder son goes to school. The only thing we don't do is dine indoors.

Why would you risk "mild" long COVID on your child if there are simple things to reduce risk? Also it's not just long COVID, children are also at heightened risk of diabetes following infection, vascular damage, cognitive decline, those exposed in womb are more likely to experience development delays. Why not take simple precautions? Instead of suggesting I get talking therapy, how about not judging people who want to keep their children healthy while still offering them a normal life? I know I can't avoid infection 100% but I'm going to try my hardest to make sure my family doesn't get it more than necessary because each infection carries risk.

@Tiredjusttired you mention asthma. You know what's just become the top chronic disease in American children: Asthma. Guess what triggers asthma? COVID infections.
Please don't peddle the myth that getting exposed to viruses builds immunity. Exposure to dirt, yes, but not viral pathogens. Or how do you choose which viruses are safe to expose yourself too, why don't you expose yourself to HIV to build your immunity to it? After all the initial symptoms are a fever and cold symptoms... same with polio...

There are longitudinal studies that shows that children who had more respiratory infections in early childhood had worse long term health outcomes. So infection is not beneficial.

It's easier for people to ignore the evidence, than accept that maybe it's not wise to let their children get infected by COVID repeatedly, with all the consequences of that. And this herd mentality allows continued infection and a gradual diminishment of our population's health.

Chill out, its a cold.

Merrymouse · 01/09/2025 15:54

AussieManque · 01/09/2025 15:51

I find it interesting how everyone jumps on the COVID cautious and are quick to accuse them of having a mental illness. It's not anxiety. It's applying a knowledge of science and the precautionary principle. I live my life, just with a mask in places that carry risk, just like I wear a bike helmet on my bike or my seatbelt in the car. Is it so difficult to let people wear a mask because they want to?

@PaxAeterna The fact that you think hand sanitizer will keep us safe from COVID shows you don't understand how it transmits. It's primarily airborne.

I mitigate against car crashes by wearing a seatbelt. I mitigate against COVID with a mask. I'm not social distancing. My elder son goes to school. The only thing we don't do is dine indoors.

Why would you risk "mild" long COVID on your child if there are simple things to reduce risk? Also it's not just long COVID, children are also at heightened risk of diabetes following infection, vascular damage, cognitive decline, those exposed in womb are more likely to experience development delays. Why not take simple precautions? Instead of suggesting I get talking therapy, how about not judging people who want to keep their children healthy while still offering them a normal life? I know I can't avoid infection 100% but I'm going to try my hardest to make sure my family doesn't get it more than necessary because each infection carries risk.

@Tiredjusttired you mention asthma. You know what's just become the top chronic disease in American children: Asthma. Guess what triggers asthma? COVID infections.
Please don't peddle the myth that getting exposed to viruses builds immunity. Exposure to dirt, yes, but not viral pathogens. Or how do you choose which viruses are safe to expose yourself too, why don't you expose yourself to HIV to build your immunity to it? After all the initial symptoms are a fever and cold symptoms... same with polio...

There are longitudinal studies that shows that children who had more respiratory infections in early childhood had worse long term health outcomes. So infection is not beneficial.

It's easier for people to ignore the evidence, than accept that maybe it's not wise to let their children get infected by COVID repeatedly, with all the consequences of that. And this herd mentality allows continued infection and a gradual diminishment of our population's health.

From what I gather you haven’t ended all social contact?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/09/2025 15:56

Everanewbie · 01/09/2025 15:54

Chill out, its a cold.

Well it wasn’t a cold for me.

But you keep doing you and chilling out.