Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
travellinglighter · 04/08/2025 18:58

its5oclocksomewheresurely · 04/08/2025 18:49

It absolutely is a deterrent. In Singapore there is the death penalty for murder. They had 10 cases last year. We in the UK had 700.

Yeh right a country with less than a tenth of our population who spends more per capita on policing, who have what most European countries would consider draconian restrictions on daily life has a lower murder rate? I’d never have guessed.

soupyspoon · 04/08/2025 19:00

Singapore are an outlier anyway, they have a massive focus on preventative policing and a small population

But in general across many countries there is no link whatsoever with the death penalty and lower murder rates.

Allseeingallknowing · 04/08/2025 19:03

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 04/08/2025 18:57

My problem with the death penalty is that the justice system makes mistakes. If someone has been given a life sentence, and their conviction is found to be wrong, they can be released and compensated. If you execute someone, and then find out they were entirely innocent, they are still dead.

Butif the accused is proven 100% guilty with evidence to prove it- death penalty.

Acommonreader · 04/08/2025 19:04

its5oclocksomewheresurely · 04/08/2025 18:43

Dear Lord. Yes yes yes, of course we must do all that we can to look after the mental “health” of these utter scum bags! Now, where did I place my hessian bag full of tofu?

Again a breath taking lack of foresight! Do you want to live next door to an ex con full of rage , resentment and with serious mental health issues. Or an ex con who has spent his sentence getting help for his issues and some education? I’m really struggling with how you don’t get this.

bombastix · 04/08/2025 19:04

Allseeingallknowing · 04/08/2025 19:03

Butif the accused is proven 100% guilty with evidence to prove it- death penalty.

That is the standard now! Did you not know

Fen476 · 04/08/2025 19:04

its5oclocksomewheresurely · 04/08/2025 18:49

It absolutely is a deterrent. In Singapore there is the death penalty for murder. They had 10 cases last year. We in the UK had 700.

But that is because they have a population 10 times smaller than ours, in Singapore 1 in 10 people are below the poverty line, in the UK it's 1 in 5, law enforcement is efficient - if only the same could be said here! and there is a strong sense of community and social responsibility - here it's everyone for themselves.

If there was no death penalty in Singapore I would still expect their murder rate to be very low compared to ours.

I think it makes absolute sense to encourage good behaviour in prison with perks. It's a form of control really, like treating them like kids. Be good and get rewards, be naughty and we take them away. The punishment for the crime aspect of prison is a loss of liberty and that's enough. It's safer for everyone this way.

Lafufufu · 04/08/2025 19:08

@PassingStranger slightly off topic but I find it fascinating as a strange dichotomy that more than half the country agree euthanasia should be legalised(despite evidence showing in every country its been legalised in its been misused and people have essentially been murdered) they not only have no issue woth it they are positively FOR it.

BUT less than 40% of this pole think we should bring back capital punishment...

Mountainviewatsunset · 04/08/2025 19:12

nam3c4ang3 · 04/08/2025 16:34

I am pro death penalty (I am from a country who still has it) but this country isn’t and so I respect its laws.

As someone who is pro death penalty, do you not worry about people wrongly convicted?

take the Lucy Letby case… she seemed very likely to be guilty, but now there’s a lot of doubt.

In cases like Levi Bellfield, it’s easy to argue for the death penalty.

its5oclocksomewheresurely · 04/08/2025 19:15

Maybe we should just build something in the middle of the ocean with no chance of escape. Drop the food in by parachute. Survival of the fittest.

YouWillFindMeInTheGarden · 04/08/2025 19:26

Nah, I’m never going to be complicit in any death penalty. Sorry, not on my watch!

Cinnamonx · 04/08/2025 19:58

Mumsnet just keeps going down hill.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 04/08/2025 20:02

I'm usually in the camp that prisoners need to be treated humanly.
In his case, death by torture wouldn't be tgood enough for the disgusting psycho beast. Evil.
Surprised he hasn't had a heart attack or faced rough prison justice.

Ashley911 · 04/08/2025 20:09

I think there is an aspect to this wherein we cannot expect the law to reflect the emotional leanings of humanity

XenoBitch · 04/08/2025 20:25

Prisoners with nothing to lose are dangerous to other inmates and the staff.
Perks are a way to keep them in line. Being removed from society, your family and friends etc, is punishment enough.

JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 20:26

XenoBitch · 04/08/2025 20:25

Prisoners with nothing to lose are dangerous to other inmates and the staff.
Perks are a way to keep them in line. Being removed from society, your family and friends etc, is punishment enough.

They happily lost their entire lives and liberty to commit the crime they did so 🤷‍♀️

PassingStranger · 04/08/2025 20:28

YouWillFindMeInTheGarden · 04/08/2025 18:25

Yes, entitled. As an enhanced prisoner.

What about Milly Dowler etc, weren't they entitled to live their lives?

OP posts:
bombastix · 04/08/2025 20:28

Etc

XenoBitch · 04/08/2025 20:30

JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 20:26

They happily lost their entire lives and liberty to commit the crime they did so 🤷‍♀️

Yes, but that is their punishment. There is no further punishments dished out in prison, and neither should there be... because they will then be risk to other prisoners and the staff.

YouWillFindMeInTheGarden · 04/08/2025 20:30

PassingStranger · 04/08/2025 20:28

What about Milly Dowler etc, weren't they entitled to live their lives?

Yeah milly and the other victims, sll victims were of course entitled to live their lives. Of course they are

prisoners are entitled to various things when on enhanced.

PassingStranger · 04/08/2025 20:30

Ashley911 · 04/08/2025 18:35

It is true sensory deprivation can make a person go insane, as was alluded by a previous poster

He was already insane.

OP posts:
JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 20:31

PassingStranger · 04/08/2025 20:28

What about Milly Dowler etc, weren't they entitled to live their lives?

Honestly I believe so many posters on here get a kick out of asserting an undeserving person is ‘entitled’ to something, just to ruffle feathers and feel more enlightened than everyone else.

Handrearedmagpie · 04/08/2025 20:33

JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 16:39

So he hasn’t punched anyone in prison, whoopsie fucking do. He’s only murdered multiple women including a 13 year old schoolgirl who he tortured and raped for hours before strangling her. Leave him in a bare cell with nothing but a tiny window so he can observe the world he will never be allowed to join again.

This

bombastix · 04/08/2025 20:33

Bellfield is completely sane. He is simply a sadist. He likes it. It suits some to say he’s insane. I believe he has a personality disorder. There’s nothing you can do about someone like this but throw away the key for life. Stop publishing articles about him. He loves it

JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 20:37

After abducting Milly and assaulting her at his flat a few yards from Walton Station, he then drove her to his mother’s house. He reversed down a long driveway and then raped her in broad daylight over the boot of his car.
Bellfield then moved her to another location, where the rape and torture continued for a number of hours until the next day when he finally strangled her to death.

I want to post that extract from the Dowler family statement so you cannot hide from your disgust when you assert Bellfield should be able to spend the rest of his life doing enjoyable things at the taxpayers expense and is even ‘entitled’ to them.

tigger1001 · 04/08/2025 20:38

JamesMacGill · 04/08/2025 16:39

So he hasn’t punched anyone in prison, whoopsie fucking do. He’s only murdered multiple women including a 13 year old schoolgirl who he tortured and raped for hours before strangling her. Leave him in a bare cell with nothing but a tiny window so he can observe the world he will never be allowed to join again.

It's more than that though.

incentives to good behaviour makes it a little safer for other inmates (guessing you may not care much about that) but also the officers working there.