Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One million immigrants claiming benefits

1000 replies

AnxiousApocalypse · 16/07/2025 01:15

Just been reading the comments sections of the Daily Telegraph and Daily Mail articles about the one million foreigners claiming benefits in the UK. It feels like the final nail in the coffin and a lot of people will feel even more justified in expressing their anger and hate towards immigrants. What happens when Reform win the next general election and come into power? Will people be rounded up en masse and put in detention centres like the USA?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
ZaZathecat · 16/07/2025 08:16

People working full time in low paid jobs are often entitled to Universal Credit as a top up. A lot of immigrants are doing low paid jobs.
Yes, these kind of headlines are a gift to people like Farage and the kind of the GB news peddle all the time.

MiloMinderbinder925 · 16/07/2025 08:17

Satisfiedwithanapple · 16/07/2025 08:11

I completely understand.

Arriving in a small boat is illegal. Then once they proved they had a proper case and who they are they are released.

We could easily increase the amount of detention space.

It’s all the ‘what-aboutery’ that makes this country an easy target. If we did this there would immediately be less people arriving.

Genuinely I don’t understand why people who arrive illegally are not detained until it is decided if they are genuine asylum seekers or not and it is properly ascertained who they are.

You said you didn't understand and that your lack of understanding was genuine. I believe you. It's not illegal for someone to enter a country to claim asylum - see the Refugee Convention.

You also genuinely don't understand that it's not easy to increase detention space - see the current prison crisis for more information. I understand that human rights aren't important to you (though I'm sure you'd claim to respect Western values) but there's a concern about human rights abuses - see Yarl's Wood.

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:18

Summerartwitch · 16/07/2025 08:08

''@Jennps · Today 07:58
No there are no other ways.
In the leftie, unicorns and fairies world, platitudes and hyperbole are sufficient o pay for a functioning country. But in the real world, only cold hard cash pays for stuff.
If you are not a net contributor, then other people are paying for you to live for free. We have plenty of those in this country already. We don’t need to bring in more to add to the burden.''

Nonsense.

Covid and the lock downs showed that ultimately societies don't need another banker or hedge fund manager...

The contribution to society of people on low wages like cleaners, delivery drivers, retail workers, carers, teaching assistant, supermarket workers who keep the food supply going and so on is more than just about them being 'net contributors' or not.

Without them everything would collapse and there would be no 'functioning country'.

Borrowing and printing a trillion pounds to pay for Covid? How did that work out then?

nearly 20% inflation, that’s how.

You’s have to be economically and fiscally illiterate to make the argument that bowing and paying for unproductive people is the way to go.

BoredZelda · 16/07/2025 08:18

Rosscameasdoody · 16/07/2025 08:06

Asylum seekers can’t claim mainstream benefits until they have been given leave to remain, and even then there is a limit to what can be claimed. And it’s worth mentioning that if OP is hoping this will lead to frothing about the benefits budget in general, she should have done her research before posting because support for asylum seekers comes from the Home Office budget, not welfare.

Edited

Also worth mentioning that refugees make up a tiny number of those claiming benefits.

nomas · 16/07/2025 08:18

Julen7 · 16/07/2025 07:49

A pity the Labour govt seem to be oblivious to all this

Tony Blair admits he did not realise how many migrants would come to the UK after EU expanded.

https://archive.ph/oewrc The Telegraph.

Dolphinnoises · 16/07/2025 08:19

What does that mean though? Does it include pensions, and therefore MIL who came to this country when she married FIL in her 20s and has worked here almost all her life and who now has a state pension like everyone else? Or someone like her who is claiming UC or child benefit? Do we mean recent immigrants? Or do we mean settled ones who lost their job recently?

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:19

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 16/07/2025 08:14

The biggest nonsense here, is this "argument" presupposes that the sole source of government income is personal tax, therefore anyone earning under 41k is simply living out of the pocket of those who earn more.

Even more ridiculous is the implication the UK would be better of if it just dispensed with immigrants who earn sub 41k. Sure, do that, and watch the entire Care sector and the NHS cease to function overnight.

Ah yes, I don’t like numbers so I’ll make up some nonsense to refute facts because they don’t suit my economically illiterate narrative.

Yeah, that’s it.

Soulfulunfurling · 16/07/2025 08:21

Unless this situation is addressed robustly and swiftly in the next twelve months, you better be ready for a reform government…with Farage as PM.

TwoFeralKids · 16/07/2025 08:22

sandwichlover93 · 16/07/2025 08:11

Are you okay?

That is actually happening.

Lighteningstrikes · 16/07/2025 08:22

YABU

No wonder this country is sinking.

You’re very naive if you think it just stops at benefits.

At least Nigel Farage would have enough common sense to deport them to Rwanda before this country is completely broken.

Let us all pray there aren’t too many ‘sleepers’ infiltrating us. The UK needs to wake up, and quickly.

PreciousMomentsHun · 16/07/2025 08:23

Sub41k spongers... get these teachers, nurses, carers, labourers, bin men, bus drivers OUT NOW!!

AInightingale · 16/07/2025 08:23

The fact that this thread will almost inevitably be deleted tells you why we've got such a problem. No one is allowed to raise their concerns and that's why we're in this present mess.

TwoFeralKids · 16/07/2025 08:23

nomas · 16/07/2025 08:18

Tony Blair admits he did not realise how many migrants would come to the UK after EU expanded.

https://archive.ph/oewrc The Telegraph.

He didn't realise half of Romania would come? He is thick as shit.

Dorisbonson · 16/07/2025 08:24

Itsanewnameeveryday · 16/07/2025 03:31

I’m confused by these UK concerns.
In Australia 30% of residents were born OS, 50% have parents who were born overseas.
We have our fair share of older folk, people from small country towns and even some outright racists but I hardly ever hear any concerns about scrounging migrants.
Unemployment is 4% and migrants seem to be working hard (many have more than one job).

Australia has a much more selective immigration policy towards economic migrants and additionally turns boats around. The UK does not have the same level of selection and does not turn boats around.

HPFA · 16/07/2025 08:25

More immigrants and benefits bashing.

Look at America - an army subject to no laws or oversight pulling people off the streets because they look Hispanic - as even the government has now admitted - thrown into cages and half-starved. What happens when disease hits?

And inflation rising, job growth slowing, people left to drown, millions taken out of healthcare....all to give huge tax breaks to the very rich.

That's the future Reform likes the look of. The same people who thought Brexit was a good idea.

MiloMinderbinder925 · 16/07/2025 08:25

Soulfulunfurling · 16/07/2025 08:21

Unless this situation is addressed robustly and swiftly in the next twelve months, you better be ready for a reform government…with Farage as PM.

Unlikely with 4 MPs and teenagers running councils.

randomchap · 16/07/2025 08:26

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:15

Dont know which planet you live on. But on earth, it’s money that is used to pay for stuff. People running and working in public services ask for a salary at the end of the month, they can’t go to the supermarket and pay for their weekly shop with a platitude that they provided free services to a non net contributing migrant workers.

Yes, people use money to buy goods and services. I'm glad you understand that.

People who don't earn this 41k are still contributing to society. Your net contribution is way more than just what you pay in tax.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 16/07/2025 08:26

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:19

Ah yes, I don’t like numbers so I’ll make up some nonsense to refute facts because they don’t suit my economically illiterate narrative.

Yeah, that’s it.

The only number mentioned is the 41k figure you yourself suggested people Google, so if there's any economic illiteracy going on...

"economically illiterate narrative"

Yes, better still, we just need more profound stupidity like this -

If you are not a net contributor, then other people are paying for you to live for free. We have plenty of those in this country already. We don’t need to bring in more to add to the burden

The solution to an economy failing because of unsustainable borrowing, meaning we can't pay for public services or train the staff necessary to keep them functional, and therefore have to outsource the jobs to cheaper, foreign labour, is to simply pretend those jobs don't require filling and watch these services cease to be in an instant.

mindutopia · 16/07/2025 08:27

I’m technically an ‘immigrant’ probably according to the Daily Mail. I immigrated to the UK on a spousal visa, though I have acquired citizenship now. I receive ESA because I’m off work going through cancer treatment. It’s like £500 a month. Prior to this, I’ve always worked, unless on maternity leave leave. Dh and I earn very well and contribute quite a lot in taxes as high earners. Prior to my indefinite leave to remain, it was very clear that I had no recourse to public funds and nor did dh because he lived with me.

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:27

This thread proves that large parts of the existing population is too mathematically challenged to understand that it money that is used to pay for stuff, virtues can only signalled, shops don’t expect them as legal tender to most for stuff.

And unless the country is producing more than it’s consuming then you have to bottle almost £20b a month to pay for stuff, like we do now.

And when you add millions more people from overseas who take more out of the system than they put in, you eventually go bankrupt or go knocking on IMFs door.

As I say, a lot of people on this country and most on this thread are too economically and fiscally illiterate to figure this out.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 16/07/2025 08:27

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:27

This thread proves that large parts of the existing population is too mathematically challenged to understand that it money that is used to pay for stuff, virtues can only signalled, shops don’t expect them as legal tender to most for stuff.

And unless the country is producing more than it’s consuming then you have to bottle almost £20b a month to pay for stuff, like we do now.

And when you add millions more people from overseas who take more out of the system than they put in, you eventually go bankrupt or go knocking on IMFs door.

As I say, a lot of people on this country and most on this thread are too economically and fiscally illiterate to figure this out.

Oh the irony! 😂

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 16/07/2025 08:27

TwoFeralKids · 16/07/2025 08:23

He didn't realise half of Romania would come? He is thick as shit.

A lot of them were actively invited and recruited in.

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:28

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 16/07/2025 08:26

The only number mentioned is the 41k figure you yourself suggested people Google, so if there's any economic illiteracy going on...

"economically illiterate narrative"

Yes, better still, we just need more profound stupidity like this -

If you are not a net contributor, then other people are paying for you to live for free. We have plenty of those in this country already. We don’t need to bring in more to add to the burden

The solution to an economy failing because of unsustainable borrowing, meaning we can't pay for public services or train the staff necessary to keep them functional, and therefore have to outsource the jobs to cheaper, foreign labour, is to simply pretend those jobs don't require filling and watch these services cease to be in an instant.

Try writing that again to actually make some sense?

Jennps · 16/07/2025 08:28

randomchap · 16/07/2025 08:26

Yes, people use money to buy goods and services. I'm glad you understand that.

People who don't earn this 41k are still contributing to society. Your net contribution is way more than just what you pay in tax.

No it’s not. Unless you struggle with basic maths.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.