Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Starmer is utterly reprehensible

1000 replies

Thegreyhound · 12/05/2025 20:31

I know everyone will disagree, that’s ok- But I just have to say that Starmer today seems to have sunk lower than I ever believed he would with his incendiary ‘island of strangers’ and ‘incalculable damage’ rhetoric.
I find it particularly shocking because he has calculated this and decided it’s worth it to throw immigrants under the bus and essentially give all the ground in the debate to Farage, Tommy Robinson and Enoch Powell types.
Policy can be altered without making statements that are designed to impact race relations and make life even more difficult for people who are just trying to get along and make a living here.
Starmer is vile. This country does indeed feel like an island of strangers these days but the strangers are not the immigrants :(

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BrightonEarlyOneSummerMorning · 13/05/2025 08:44

TheFastTraybake · 13/05/2025 08:41

Are you Jewish? Because if not, you're being both condescending and uninformed. I'd like you to stop doing that.

Are you upset about Muslims?

Are you Jewish? Because if not, you're being both condescending and uninformed

So if I am Jewish, I'm not uninformed?

EasternStandard · 13/05/2025 08:44

JassyRadlett · 13/05/2025 08:41

It's great that we all know that, and I'm sure British Jews are particularly comforted by the fact that we all know that the white supremacists attacking them are only doing it because of the Muslim immigrants.

Meanwhile, quite a few of my European neighbours fucked off home after Brexit because they were told many times to "fuck off home", and so they did.

Plenty of people have problems with any of us who are immigrants.

And you’re backing Starmer’s island of strangers rhetoric still. You do know it echos Enoch Powell’s words

mummytoonetryingfortwo · 13/05/2025 08:45

woodlandcalm · 13/05/2025 08:44

It's not press exaggeration when you live in a small town where some of these men are being placed and promptly filming children in parks.

Where parents are setting up 'park patrol' groups because the police, local MP or Home Office are doing nothing

The outrage and tension is very real.

Edited

I’m not denying that it happens. But it’s a small % of overall migration.

snughugs · 13/05/2025 08:45

BrightonEarlyOneSummerMorning · 13/05/2025 08:21

Nobody has a problem with Jewish migrants. Or European migrants.
But you know that.

People don’t dislike the Poles but the huge influx (far too many) was a reason for Brexit. If Poland hadn’t joined the EU no way would we have voted out of the EU. Also if Tony Blair put a cap on numbers which he was advised Brexit wouldn’t have happened either. I voted Brexit for immigration and would again and I’d vote Reform too. Why people open their eyes and stop the rubbish that we need loads of poor unskilled migrants to prop up businesses, whilst they claim benefits and take over 50% in our social housing stock in London alone to first generation immigrants which will increase. I don’t want lots of poor unskilled people here that get propped up by government support (regardless of colour). Rich, educated Arab with lots of money aren’t draining the system. I mean we’re not exactly getting the brightest and the best to immigrate like Australia we’re getting criminals and losers and paying for the privilege and if we complain are racist.

User135644 · 13/05/2025 08:47

RingLater · 12/05/2025 22:08

The age old when in public service - ‘you can't please everyone, all of the time’.

Labour have picked up a mess, at least the White Paper is well researched and includes evidenced data of the sh*tshow they have inherited.

I almost wish the Conservatives had stayed on to take the flak and sort it out.…or perhaps (no policy) Reform should be elected to sort the mess out.
Yeh, come on Nigel…

At least they're taking practical measures to sort the mess out rather than silly gimmicks like Rwanda.

It just doesn't go anyway near far enough.

EasternStandard · 13/05/2025 08:48

User135644 · 13/05/2025 08:47

At least they're taking practical measures to sort the mess out rather than silly gimmicks like Rwanda.

It just doesn't go anyway near far enough.

How are they addressing the channel crossings?

QueenQueef25 · 13/05/2025 08:48

Paddingtonscaresme · 13/05/2025 08:09

Do you realise that Costa is well known as one of the highest payers when it comes to UK tax payments?

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-20624857
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20580545

I did delete a few sentences, saying I wasn't 100% sure on the figures then,
but here's 2 news links from 2012 saying Starbucks paid after a court case and 14 years of trading and not bothering. And only bc of pressure from public beginning four years before. Amazon was also involved in that court case.
from memory Costa was in the same bag.
That was in 2008. No I'm not Costas accountant and I would think since this court case and 15 years later they would
Pay. But back then, I wouldn't be surprised if they operated I a similar way. there's still a culture of corporations using offshore accounts (obviously?) That would would make hefty contributions to services.

Starbucks logo

Starbucks agrees to pay more corporation tax

Coffee chain Starbucks takes the "unprecedented" step of agreeing to pay about £20m more in UK corporation tax over the next two years following a public outcry.

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-20624857

Zadar24 · 13/05/2025 08:48

Dangermoo · 13/05/2025 06:54

You can see why Reform are doing so well. I really do think some live in a bubble about Reform's popularity. The biggest laugh is that Reform are seen as the biggest threat to this country.

It’s not funny when they want us to leave the EHCR and privatise the NHS. That is the biggest threat to this country.

mummytoonetryingfortwo · 13/05/2025 08:48

EasternStandard · 13/05/2025 08:48

How are they addressing the channel crossings?

Starmer has been quite vocal with the fact they’re focussing on the gangs, no?

JassyRadlett · 13/05/2025 08:49

BrightonEarlyOneSummerMorning · 13/05/2025 08:42

Come back to me when you can read a post properly: "the white supremacists attacking them are only doing it because of the Muslim immigrants" = deliberate misread

So sorry, I meant emboldened by "the importation of a religious conflict that has nothing to do with us" which obviously has nothing to do with either Muslims or immigrants.

If you're going to state that "nobody" has a problem with Jewish or European immigrants you need to be prepared for quite a bit of challenge that a lot of people (including white people) have a problem with Jews full stop, that a lot of people were violently against EU immigration before Brexit (and Kemi Badenoch has just made a youth mobility scheme a red line in her "tests" for the EU negotiations) and a lot of people are pretty anti all immigrants.

TLDR: don't make silly sweeping statements if you can't bear to have their silliness pointed out.

JassyRadlett · 13/05/2025 08:50

CantStopMoving · 13/05/2025 08:42

I’d still give it a go! 😀

Fair enough! I quite like having a semi-functioning care sector and the elderly and infirm not being condemned to squalor, plus having a good tax base and world class scientific research, so it's a no from me. 😁

Dangermoo · 13/05/2025 08:51

Zadar24 · 13/05/2025 08:48

It’s not funny when they want us to leave the EHCR and privatise the NHS. That is the biggest threat to this country.

Both sound good to me. The NHS is way past the point of fixing, due to years of mismanagement. Human rights OK but how many times do you see that being used as an excuse for crime?

Feetinthegrass · 13/05/2025 08:53

CharSiu · 13/05/2025 08:42

If Western developed nations do not do something about immigration then the move to the right will be immense. Not Farage levels of anti immigration, proper boots on the ground border guards chucking people in to detention centres. Real far right stuff. Poland stop asylum seekers with border patrols at the Belorussian border right now. They risk being fined by the EU.

The left and liberal thinking have made a huge error and it has played in to the hands of the far right but this is only going to get worse. I can see other countries following Poland, maybe not right now but unless people see substantial change then in the near future. I can even see a time when nations attempt to change the 1951 agreement on refugees or leave that agreement entirely.

@CantStopMoving same here, my heritage isn’t white so even though my Dad anglicised the spelling of our name it is obvious that our ancestors aren’t exactly Anglo Saxon.

^ this

UNLESS we get a grip on immigration and quickly across the continent with a system that works, and that is fully able to control immigration effectively we are absolutely fucked. And this is what the far left can not see.

We are going to sleep walk into a far right future, and all that entails.

We want a fair and safe country that lives by our democratic values, that encourages prosperity, the embodiment of equality and freedom. 99% of the nation want this, a nation where everyone is inspired to live well, and contribute productively.

Total immigration control is where this starts, a system that is transparent and effective should be the cornerstone of a well run and successful country. We are not a free for all, but a fair but firm country that is unafraid of enforcement.

Until this happens, we are running the very real risk of ending up with a very far right political movement across the whole of Europe. And then what?

Zadar24 · 13/05/2025 08:54

mids2019 · 13/05/2025 07:18

The problem is not racism but a genuine concern that countries find it difficult to host indifferent faiths and cultures without some form of tension. Please as the formation of Pakistan as an historical example.

In the city near where I live you seem to have sped segregating ghettos of immigrants who seem to wish to be somehow separate from other communities to practise their faith (Islam) and be in close proximity to family and future spouses. This concentration of ethnic minorities leads to areas where often working class people with generations of British ancestors feel in a minority and look to move.

We are also conscious of the fact some immigrants do not like aspects of western liberal values and specifically do not respect many of our great institutions. In my town army cadets are not allowed to walk around town in uniform for fear of attack. This a few days after VE day.

It is this lack of social cohesion coupled with increasing numbers of people that in reality have value sets that aren't aligned to British values that sets alarm bells ringing and had led to the politics in Europe moving to the right (it's not just us look at Europe and the US). Starker has had to react.

Another important point is language. It is imperative that immigrants do have a good quality of English for work purposes and to easily communicate with members of society in gneral. In to many cases our local schools have had to accept the burden of teaching pupils with English as a second language with obvious impact on educational acheivment. In some cases parents do support the learning of a high quality of English but in others, especially poorer immigrants, see their language as something that has to be passed down in terms of identity and so leading to poor immigrant children desperately trying to become bi lingual often at cost.

Looking at crowds for the London marathon and VE day it is striking how few obviously Muslim people go to these things and you have to ask do we wish in 40 years time to have a self segregating country where our joint history and culture is slowly eroded?

Half the people living in my street are Muslim and it certainly isn’t a ghetto. I can think of some mainly white ghetto towns nearby where I wouldn’t want to live.

TheFastTraybake · 13/05/2025 08:54

BrightonEarlyOneSummerMorning · 13/05/2025 08:44

Are you Jewish? Because if not, you're being both condescending and uninformed

So if I am Jewish, I'm not uninformed?

If you are Jewish, I think you're a bit confused, saying that anti semitism isn't an issue and positing your support of Israel as something that binds you with (other) Jews.

Dangermoo · 13/05/2025 08:55

Feetinthegrass · 13/05/2025 08:53

^ this

UNLESS we get a grip on immigration and quickly across the continent with a system that works, and that is fully able to control immigration effectively we are absolutely fucked. And this is what the far left can not see.

We are going to sleep walk into a far right future, and all that entails.

We want a fair and safe country that lives by our democratic values, that encourages prosperity, the embodiment of equality and freedom. 99% of the nation want this, a nation where everyone is inspired to live well, and contribute productively.

Total immigration control is where this starts, a system that is transparent and effective should be the cornerstone of a well run and successful country. We are not a free for all, but a fair but firm country that is unafraid of enforcement.

Until this happens, we are running the very real risk of ending up with a very far right political movement across the whole of Europe. And then what?

Far right for wanting a swing back away from extremism? Goodness, the term far right really does get used liberally.

Notsosure1 · 13/05/2025 08:56

FiveWhatByFiveWhat · 13/05/2025 06:50

From what I've seen though, it's the Conservatives who have mostly lost ground to Reform, not Labour? And Labour are losing their voters because they're being too Tory/following Reform rhetoric?

Also, I'm sorry but WHY are people acting like Reform won a general election or something? They still have less seats/MPs than the greens/lib Dems and yet the amount of coverage they get is making them out to have all the power? They did better than they should in some local elections, but have 4 years before a GE and we all know how much in fighting goes on within the party and what a shambles they are. They've lost 9 councillors already for various reasons.

I'm baffled as to why Labour are trying to copy their narrative to be honest because from what I can see all they're doing is pissing off their own voters. People who would vote Reform almost certainly wouldn't vote Labour anyway.

People who would vote Reform almost certainly wouldn't vote Labour anyway.

Who do you think they’d vote for, Conservative? While it’s true a lot of ex Tory voters have moved to Reform, I think the same can be said of some of the old Labour voters - not the new, m/c liberal model Blair launched, but the original, w/c voters who live in the areas most affected day-to-day by immigration.

As someone up thread previously pointed out, ppl that benefit the most financially from inviting foreign workers in are the rich and big business owners. They don’t have their own communities affected or disrupted by longer waiting lists at doctors, fewer places at schools, fewer houses available and ppl living among them who haven’t been expected to integrate within the community or speak the same language to do so. You can see why there’s a large section of society who feel marginalised - they voted for Brexit. Nothings really changed for them and Reform are listening and telling them what they want to hear. Like Trump supporters they feel seen, after being ignored and called racists by ppl with no real skin in the game. They aren’t true conservative voters but probably voted when the Tories got a load of Labour seats last time - which shows they are desperate to be heard and are willing to vote for whoever promises to do that and take their concerns seriously. We obv all know Reform are the least trust worthy party out there right now but they are scaring the powers that be bc across Europe and in America the more fascist-like parties are gaining ground and threatening democracy.

Like what Starmer is doing with Trump - flattering his ego and playing the long game, this is probably the surgery he is adopting now in terms of the next election.

Zadar24 · 13/05/2025 08:56

Dangermoo · 13/05/2025 08:51

Both sound good to me. The NHS is way past the point of fixing, due to years of mismanagement. Human rights OK but how many times do you see that being used as an excuse for crime?

Torture and making homosexuality illegal are OK with you?

Jackrussellsaremad · 13/05/2025 08:58

JandamiHash · 13/05/2025 00:40

One could argue that any use of the word hysterical is misogynistic- a bit problematic when you’re accused oppressed women of misogyny.

The “so what” part comes when those communities are overrun with people with dangerous and disrespectful misogynistic ideologies. And/or people who don’t continue the economically but take take take and don’t engage with services at all, putting a strain on the economy and have a knock-on effect on the most vulnerable.

Spot on. It's not complicated to see why there's a problem.

Paddingtonscaresme · 13/05/2025 08:58

@queenqueef25 No, youre wrong. Costa is a British company and has always paid tax. Starbuck (and Amazon etc) are multinational and can avoid paying tax in UK by (legally) shifting their profit centre to jurisdictions with a low tax policy like Luxembourg.

JassyRadlett · 13/05/2025 08:58

EasternStandard · 13/05/2025 08:44

And you’re backing Starmer’s island of strangers rhetoric still. You do know it echos Enoch Powell’s words

I've been reading both this morning. There is a clear gulf in both rhetoric and meaning between a statement that white people have been made strangers in their own country, and a statement that without shared language that there is a risk of becoming and island of strangers rather than a cohesive whole.

Not least that one is blatantly racist while the other is promoting cultural integration.

TheFastTraybake · 13/05/2025 08:59

snughugs · 13/05/2025 08:45

People don’t dislike the Poles but the huge influx (far too many) was a reason for Brexit. If Poland hadn’t joined the EU no way would we have voted out of the EU. Also if Tony Blair put a cap on numbers which he was advised Brexit wouldn’t have happened either. I voted Brexit for immigration and would again and I’d vote Reform too. Why people open their eyes and stop the rubbish that we need loads of poor unskilled migrants to prop up businesses, whilst they claim benefits and take over 50% in our social housing stock in London alone to first generation immigrants which will increase. I don’t want lots of poor unskilled people here that get propped up by government support (regardless of colour). Rich, educated Arab with lots of money aren’t draining the system. I mean we’re not exactly getting the brightest and the best to immigrate like Australia we’re getting criminals and losers and paying for the privilege and if we complain are racist.

A Brexit vote was fairly inevitable because Europe was an issue that split the Tory party for decades. Cameron was vain enough to think that he was the PM who could finally resolve it, with disastrous consequences. Not much, if anything to do with Polish migrants, it went a lot further back than that.

TheGreyQuail · 13/05/2025 09:01

Where I used to live it was like a United Nations convention of 1000's and hardly anyone speaking English. Became absolutely sick to death of feeling like the outsider in my home town of 25 years.
If the person who queried my UN reference previously with faux naviety reads this, she now knows what I'm refering to.
I don't care if anyone disagrees or hates me for it. It was a nice place that became a complete shit hole. Men hanging around leering and cat calling at women and girls. Violence increased so much too, it was always groups of men from various ethnic groups clashing in the town, knife crime increased. Never felt safe in town even during the day as things would sometimes kick of.
When I go back to visit family, I hate it as it seems worse now than it was 6 years ago.

Zadar24 · 13/05/2025 09:02

QueenQueef25 · 13/05/2025 08:16

Anyone involved in crimes like the Rochdale scandal or involved in covering it up in higher levels should have citizenship taken and be deported...

Would free up a bit of room.

That’s a fair few British police officers and social workers. Where should they be deported to?

EasternStandard · 13/05/2025 09:03

JassyRadlett · 13/05/2025 08:58

I've been reading both this morning. There is a clear gulf in both rhetoric and meaning between a statement that white people have been made strangers in their own country, and a statement that without shared language that there is a risk of becoming and island of strangers rather than a cohesive whole.

Not least that one is blatantly racist while the other is promoting cultural integration.

Good luck with that. You may back Starmer no matter but those words are great for Reform.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread